Categories
Columbia Economists Gender Social Work Third Party Funding Vassar

Columbia. Economics Ph.D. alumna, Sydnor Harbison Walker, 1926

 

Sydnor Harbison Walker was a budding labor economist who became an important grants administrator/manager with the Laura Spelman Rockefeller Memorial and later the Rockefeller Foundation. Her 1926 Columbia University dissertation was on the economics of social work, which like home economics, provided an academic harbor within economics for not a few women economists of the time.

_____________________

Life of Sydnor Harbison Walker

Born: 26 September 1891 in Louisville, Kentucky.

Parents: Walter and Mary Sydnor Perkins Walker.

1913. A.B. from Vassar with honors

Taught English and Latin at private schools in Louisville, Dallas, and Los Angeles.

1917. M.A. University of Southern California.

Thesis: “The General Strike with Particular Reference to Its Practicability as Applied to American Labor Conditions

1917. Poughkeepsie City director listing as “assistant Vassar College”.

1918-19. Poughkeepsie City director listing as “instructor Vassar College”.

1919-21 [ca.]. Philadelphia.

Personnel work at Scott Company in Philadelphia [where she met Beardsley Ruml, see below].
Personnel work at Strawbridge & Clothier in Philadelphia.

1921-23. American Friends Service Committee.

One year of relief work in Vienna
Followed by one year in Russia with the American Friends Service Committee.

1924-1929. Laura Spelman Rockefeller Memorial Fund.

Recruited by Beardsley Ruml as “research associate” in June 1924.

1926. Economics Ph.D. from Columbia University. Henry Seager, principal adviser.

Dissertation published: Social Work and the Training of Social Workers. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1928.

1929-1943. Rockefeller Foundation (absorbed the Laura Spelman Rockefeller Memorial Fund in 1929).

1933. Promoted to associate director

1934. Sydnor H. Walker, “Privately Supported Social Work,” in Recent Social Trends in the United States, ed. President’s Research Committee on Social Trends (New York: Whittlesey House, 1934), pp. 1168-1223.

1937. Appointment to acting director of the Social Science Division.

1939. Voted to the board of trustees of Vassar. Resigned October 1942 due to illness.

1941. October. Contracted a spinal infection, involving a paralytic illness that “permanently confined her to a wheel chair”. She had been elected to be president “of a prominent woman’s college” but the illness forced her to decline the honor.

1943. Resigned from the Rockefeller Foundation.

1945. Edited a volume for the Woodrow Wilson Foundation, New York City. “The first one hundred days of the atomic age, August 6-November 15, 1945”.

1948. Appointed assistant to Sarah Blanding, president of Vassar.

1958. Retired from Vassar.

Died: 12 December 1966 in Millbrook, New York, leaving a bequest of $10,000 to Vassar College.

_____________________

Walker’s principal biographer

Amy E. Wells. Considering Her Influence: Sydnor H. Walker and Rockefeller Support for Social Work, Social Scientists, and Universities in the South.  pp. 127-147. Chapter 5 in Andrea Walton (ed.). Women and Philanthropy in Education.  Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2005.

_________. Sydnor Harbison Walker. American National Biography Online. London and New York: Oxford University Press, 2014.

_____________________

Vassar Memorial Minute
Walker, Sydnor Harbison, 1891-1966

Miss Sydnor Harbison Walker, Vassar alumna, faculty member, trustee and Assistant to the President, died December 12, 1966, at her home in Millbrook, New York, at the age of 75. She was born in Louisville, Kentucky, the daughter of Walter and Mary Sydnor Perkins Walker.

After attending Louisville schools, Miss Walker came to Vassar and was graduated in 1913 with honors. Economics was her major interest and she returned to Vassar to teach it in 1917, with an M.A. from the University of Southern California. Professor Emeritus Mabel Newcomer, a young colleague at the time, writes that “her quick wit and gaiety made her well liked among students in the residential hall where she lived ….. as a teacher she exhibited these same qualities, combined with clarity of thought and expression …. although she could be sharply critical of the careless and the dilatory.”

In 1919 Miss Walker decided that she needed some practical experience and went to work for a pioneering firm of industrial relations consultants where she wrote their weekly news letter. Three members of this young firm became college presidents and some years later Miss Walker herself was on the way to the presidency of a prominent college for women. A fourth member of the firm was Beardsley Ruml.

In 1921 Miss Walker engaged in the relief work of the American Friends Service Committee, first in Vienna and later in Russia. In a letter to President Emeritus MacCracken, she vividly describes her experience.

“We are now feeding about 15,000 a week through our depots, and we are supplying clothing to nearly 3,000. Our work is done on an individual case basis, which we think to be the soundest, not only from a social point of view, but because we believe that method essential for the creation of a spirit of international good-will — at no time a secondary object in our program… In addition to the feeding and clothing…. we are teaching mothers to care for their babies through the welfare centers; we are supporting a score of hospitals and other institutions for children; we have restocked farms with poultry and cattle and are helping farmers to build up permanent food resources for the city; and we are assisting materially in such constructive Austrian enterprises as the building of suburban land settlements and the creation of a market abroad for the art work of many gifted persons…we feel that we are a real part of the life of the city and not a superimposed group of relief workers.”

It is not hard for those who knew Miss Walker to visualize her presiding over relief work in the Imperial Palace of the Hofburg, whose stately corridors were cheerless and deserted save for these activities.

Returning to America in 1924, Miss Walker combined her interests in industrial relations with social welfare and education by becoming a research assistant at the Laura Spelman Rockefeller Memorial Fund in New York. In the meantime she received her doctorate in economics from Columbia University in 1928 with a dissertation on “Social Work and the Training of Social Workers.”

When the Rockefeller Foundation absorbed the Spelman Fund in 1929, Miss Walker began her association of twenty years with the Foundation. She moved from the research department to the position of Associate Director of the Social Sciences Division and finally became its Acting Director. While there she developed a program of international relations involving considerable travel in Europe and South America in very responsible positions. In 1933 she collaborated in the preparation of the report of President Hoover’s Committee on Social Trends, contributing a chapter entitled, “Privately Supported Social Work.”

In 1939 Miss Walker was proposed for trustee of Vassar College by the Faculty Club and she was elected by the board. Again quoting Miss Newcomer, “her contribution as a Vassar trustee was very real….Her experience on the faculty and as a student, and her current work in the Rockefeller Foundation, had given her a real understanding of the problems of the college and enabled her to offer constructive criticism and suggestion for change.”

Her resignation as trustee occurred in October 1942, and came because of a crippling illness which led eventually to her permanent confinement to a wheel chair. A friend and fellow alumna described her long battle against mistaken diagnoses, official predictions of helplessness and the end of her career.

“Sydnor simply rejected the idea of permanent immobility…. for a person who never knew what fatigue meant, who never could understand inactivity, either mental or physical, nothing could have been more tragic than paralysis.”

When Miss Walker realized that complete recovery was impossible, on her own initiative she went to one of the first rehabilitation clinics in New York and learned to help herself to a remarkable degree. Also she wrote, and the Woodrow Wilson Foundation published in 1945, a report entitled “The First Hundred Days of the Atomic Age.”

In 1948 another opportunity to serve Vassar came to Miss Walker when Miss Blanding named her Assistant to the President. She returned to live in Metcalf House and became an active participant in Vassar’s development. Miss Blanding knew her as “a brilliant woman who never lost her zest for life nor her interest in things of the mind. She was a voracious reader and stimulating companion.”

After Miss Walker’s retirement in 1957, she bought a large colonial house in Millbrook, reminiscent of her native Kentucky. There she continued her vital interest in Vassar and in the many friendships she had made throughout her rich and colorful life.

Respectfully submitted,

Josephine Gleason
Clarice Pennock
Verna Spicer
Winifred Asprey, Chairman

Source: Online collection published by Vassar College Libraries. Faculty meeting minutes: XVIII-334-336.

_____________________

From The Rockefeller Foundation: A Digital History.

Sydnor H. Walker worked with the Laura Spelman Rockefeller Memorial (LSRM) and the Rockefeller Foundation’s (RF) Division of the Social Sciences, helping to shape research in the social sciences over the course of two decades.

Walker was born in Louisville, Kentucky, in 1891. She received an A.B. in economics from Vassar College in 1913 and an M.A. from the University of Southern California in 1917.

She returned to Vassar in 1917, where she served as an instructor in economics. A colleague commented that Walker was appreciated by the students for “her quick wit and gaiety…although she could be sharply critical of the careless and the dilatory.”[1] In 1919 Walker left her teaching position to join an industrial relations consulting firm headed by Beardsley Ruml. She subsequently went abroad to Vienna and Russia to aid in European relief with the American Friends Service Committee.

Upon her return to the U.S. in 1924, Walker was recruited by Ruml to work for the LSRM as a research associate. She was a staunch advocate of using scientific and standardized methods to conduct research in the social sciences. While working for the LSRM, Walker continued her studies at Columbia University, receiving her Ph.D. in economics in 1928. Her dissertation, “Social Work and the Training of Social Workers,” was published by the University of North Carolina Press in 1928.

When many of LSRM’s programs were consolidated with the RF in 1929 and a new Division of the Social Sciences created, Walker became Assistant Director of the division. She was promoted to Associate Director in 1933 and Acting Director in 1937. Among her interests at the RF, she was a proponent of improving the teaching of social work and the administration of social welfare programs. Her grant-making extended to many southern universities. She also contributed to the development of the social sciences outside the U.S., working with grantees in Europe and Latin America.

Resigning from the RF in 1943 for health reasons, she worked on a report for the Woodrow Wilson Foundation, “The First Hundred Days of the Atomic Age,” which was published in 1945.

She served as a trustee for Vassar College from 1939-1943 and was appointed assistant to the president of Vassar College in 1948, a position she held until 1957.

Sydnor H. Walker passed away in 1966. Former Vassar College President, Sarah Blanding, called her “a brilliant woman who never lost her zest for life nor her interest in things of the mind.”[2] Her officer diaries are available to researchers at the Rockefeller Archive Center (RAC) and additional papers are in the Biographical Collection at the Vassar College Libraries.

*  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *

[1] Josephine Gleason et al. “Sydnor Harrison Walker: A Memorial Minute,” Vassar Faculty Meeting, December 1966, Biographical Files Collection, Vassar College Archives, Vassar Libraries.

[2] Gleason et al.

Source: Webpage, The Rockefeller Foundation: A Digital History. People/Sydnor H. Walker. Also the source for the portrait of Sydnor H. Walker used above.

 

Categories
Bryn Mawr Columbia Gender

Bryn Mawr. Catholic economics instructor threatened with termination, 1921

_______________________________________

When I came across the correspondence in this post, what caught my eye was that a Columbia doctoral student in economics had written to her adviser asking for advice in the face of a seemingly certain termination of her instructorship at Bryn Mawr simply on the grounds of her being Catholic. I thought it good to post a reminder just how broad the category of “the Other” was not even a century ago. 

What is also interesting is the fact that her advisor, E.R.A. Seligman farmed out the draft of her dissertation to a former student of his for a referee report that became the basis of his decision for a revise-and-resubmit of the thesis.

The Bryn Mawr economics instructor/Columbia graduate student, Marjorie Lorne Franklin, was born August 30, 1892 in Albany, New York. She received her B.A. from Barnard College in 1913 and her M.A. from Columbia University in 1914. According to the Bryn Mawr Calendar 1921 (p. 4): Marjorie Franklin was Graduate Scholar, Bryn Mawr College, 1913-14 and Fellow in Economics, 1914-15; Columbia University, 1915-16; Library Assistant, American Telephone and Telegraph Co., 1916-17; and before coming to Bryn Mawr she served as an instructor at Vassar College in 1917-18. However according to the Vassar College yearbook, The Vassarion 1918 (p.30), Franklin was working 1915-16 as Tariff Assistant in Foreign Tariffs Division of U.S. Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce.  From the 1925 Barnard College Register of Alumnae we learn that she married Dr. Walter Freeman in 1924 and was working as a special expert at the U.S. Tariff Commission.  According to the 1940 U.S. census she reported that she was employed as an economist with the Tariff Commission and she was the mother of five sons and one daughter. She died in San Mateo, California on April 22, 1970. I have found no record that Marjorie Franklin Freeman was ever awarded a Ph.D. in economics.

A biographical detail that is irrelevant for understanding the history of economics but much too fascinating to leave unmentioned is that Marjorie Franklin’s husband Walter Freeman (II) was  a neurologist famous for having introduced the Freeman-Watts prefrontal lobotomy procedure— (His papers are archived at George Washington University; there is even a PBS documentary about him “The Lobotomist”). 

 

_______________________________________

Franklin to Seligman: Bryn Mawr terminating her because she is a Catholic

BRYN MAWR COLLEGE
Department of Economics and Politics
Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

Low Buildings,
February 27, 1921

Professor E.R.A. Seligman
Columbia University
New York City

Dear Professor Seligman:

Religious prejudice has entered into my life for the first time in a way that shocks and stuns me. After three years of successful teaching here, President Thomas has decided that the fact that I am a Catholic makes me persona non grata. She states that my work has been successful and admits that I have not allowed my religious ideas to influence my teaching, but claims that from the point of view of the outside world, it is bad for the college to have a Catholic hold my position, considering the political activities of the Catholic Church. The situation is complicated by the fact that Dr. Fenwick, Professor of Political Science in the department is also a Catholic, and President Thomas has decided that one of us must go. I have no intention of protesting the matter, for I realize that it is futile to argue against religious prejudice.

It is doubtless unnecessary to say to you that my ideas on the subject of religion have always been to me something quite apart from my work, and represent, chiefly, my ethical and moral standards, not at all, my political and economic ideas which have been the result of modern scientific training at Barnard and Columbia. Dr. Giddings, who knows my Father, also a graduate of Union College, would testify that I had been brought up in a broad, tolerant atmosphere.

The whole question of religious prejudice seems utterly medieval to me, but since it is evidently effective in the sphere of teaching, it makes me want to turn to the field of business and finance. So I want to talk over with you in the near future the possibility of openings in the banking field.

During the past two months, work on my thesis has been at a standstill due to the fact that my Father has been rather suddenly incapacitated by some spinal trouble which has made him quite helpless. He was operated on two weeks ago by Dr. Elsberg, the famous spinal surgeon, at the Neurological Hospital on East 67th Street, and his fate is still in doubt. As a result I cannot go to him for advice, and so am running the risk of boring you by setting forth conditions in such detail. However, it may be better for you to have a clear statement of the facts in my case before I go up to New York to see you. I should be glad to make an appointment to call any time within the next few weeks.

Very sincerely yours,
[signed] Marjorie L. Franklin

_______________________________________

Franklin to Seligman: Vassar reverses itself, making her an offer

BRYN MAWR COLLEGE
Department of Economics and Politics
Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

Low Buildings,
March 10, 1921

Prof. Edwin R.A. Seligman
Columbia University
New York City

My dear Professor Seligman:

Due to the efforts of Mrs. Smith, my department chief, and other members of the Bryn Mawr Faculty on the Appointment Committee, President Thomas has capitulated completely and has offered e a contract on the most favorable terms, ignoring the late unpleasentness completely.

If I were to consider my own feelings in the matter, I would reject all overtures, but since Mrs. Smith and others went so valiantly to the front for me, stating that they would resign if I were forced to leave, there is now a strong feeling of noblesse oblige on my part toward them.

However, I should like very much to talk things over with you, in general, and particularly to submit to you a substantial draft of my thesis. In view of this, I would rather postpone my interview set for March 16th and make arrangements with Mrs. Stewart to see you later, just before or just after the Easter vacation.

Appreciating your kindness in this situation,

Sincerely yours,
[signed] Marjorie L. Franklin

_______________________________________

Newcomer’s report to Seligman on Franklin’s thesis draft

435 West 119 St.,
New York,
June 20, 1922.

My dear Dr. Seligman:

I have gone over Miss Franklin’s dissertation again rather carefully. It seems to me it has been improved, but frankly it still leaves me with no very clear picture of Philadelphia’s financial condition. It gives a fairly good idea of political conditions, and something of the financial consequences of these conditions; but at no time is there given a definite summarized statement of the actual sources of revenue and the relative importance of each. A statement, e.g., of the actual percentage of revenues obtained from the tax on real estate over a period of years would be illuminating. Most of the data which would be required for such comparisons are available in the tables now included in the appendix, but these data would have to be rearranged and summarized. In their present form they are not of much assistance.

The same indefiniteness appears in the discussion of assessments. The account of correct assessment methods and the shortcomings of those employed in Philadelphia is full and clear; but as to the degree of underassessment and the seriousness of the inequalities one is left in doubt.

Another criticism that I would make is that in some places Miss Franklin introduces material which scarcely seems pertinent because she fails to apply it definitely to the situation in Philadelphia. A case in point is the long discussion of the taxation of land values at the end of chapter four.

Further I find the relative weight granted the various parts of the subject not altogether satisfactory. For instance, special assessments are too important a factor in municipal financing to be introduced first in the conclusions. Also, with full recognition of the bearing of all of the matters discussed on the system of taxation, I still feel that taxation itself has not received its full share of attention.

Finally, I do not find the conclusions convincing. I am afraid that this is rather severe criticism. Let me hasten to add that I think the strictly historical survey of the subject is very good, and I like Miss Franklin’s treatment of the political and administrative problems. I suspect that many of the difficulties which I find are inherent in the subject itself.

I am leaving the manuscript, together with a copy of this letter in Mrs. Stewart’s office.

With best wishes for a pleasant summer, I remain

Sincerely yours,
[signed]
Mabel Newcomer

Note: Mabel Newcomer (B.A. Stanford, 1913; M.A. Stanford, 1914; Ph.D. Columbia, 1917) taught at Vassar 1917-1957.

_______________________________________

Seligman’s decision not to accept Franklin’s thesis draft

Lake Placid, N.Y.,
June 24th, 1922.

Miss Mabel Newcomer,
New York.

Dear Miss Newcomer:-

Many thanks for your kind and explicit letter. I have written to Miss Franklin, embodying most of your points I my letter and have asked her to try again.

I may bother you again when she presents her next, and let us hope, her final draft.

With kind regards,

Faithfully yours,
[E.R.A. Seligman, unsigned in copy]

Source: Columbia University Archives. Edwin Robert Anderson Papers. Box 36, Folder “Box 99, Seligman, Columbia 1918-1924 (A-Z)”.

Image Source: Marjorie Lorne Franklin’s senior year picture in The Mortarboard 1913, p. 195.