Categories
Exam Questions Harvard Social Insurance Social Work

Harvard. Social Ethics Description, Enrollment, Exams. 1914-1915

SOCIAL ETHICS

Social Ethics 1-8
1914-15

Social Ethics 1. Social Problems and Social Policy
Social Ethics 2. Poor-Relief and Neighborhood Work
Social Ethics 3. Criminology and Penology [omitted 1914-15]
Social Ethics 4. Immigration and Race Problems
Social Ethics 5. The Housing Problem
Social Ethics 6. Social Amelioration in Europe
Social Ethics 7. Rural Social Development
Social Ethics 8. Child-Helping Agencies

GENERAL STATEMENT

The courses of this Department are designed to apply ethical principles to social problems, to indicate methods of social research, and to discuss policies for social improvement.

Course 1 offers a general survey of social problems, of the agencies and methods of social betterment. Students are advised before taking it to take introductory courses in Economics and in Philosophy.

Courses 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8 are open to students who have received a satisfactory grade in Social Ethics 1. Juniors and Seniors specializing in Economics or Philosophy and graduate students are eligible to enrolment. These courses all deal intensively with specific social problems, — with conditions, principles, and policy. Courses 2 and 8, offered by officials of Massachusetts charitable organizations, are largely concerned with methods and problems of administration. Course 5 is primarily a course in research. Field work is required in Courses 2, 5, and 8, and can be assigned upon request in Courses 4 and 7.

Courses 20 and 20b are designed for candidates for higher degrees. Courses 20c and 20d are professional courses intended for students who wish to train for administrative positions.

For Undergraduates and Graduates

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 1

Course Description
1914-15

1.  Social Problems and Social Policy. — Lectures, prescribed reading, theses. Tu., Th., Sat., at 10. Asst. Professors Foerster and Ford, assisted by Mr. Staples.(XI)

This course gives a survey of contemporary social problems with special reference to principles and methods of social amelioration.

It begins with a discussion of the bearing of ethics upon social and economic problems and seeks throughout to apply ethical principles to specific problems. Among the subjects dealt with are the methods of social investigation, immigration, incomes and expenditures, the methods of public and private relief of poverty, delinquent and defective classes, control of the liquor traffic, the family, housing, public recreation, wages and hours of labor of men, women and children, industrial disputes and their settlement, compensation for accidents, workmen’s insurance, producers’ and consumers’ coöperation, profit-sharing, ethical aspects of socialism. An important feature of the course is a thesis in the first term dealing with problems of poverty, and in the second term dealing with labor problems; either or both of these may involve field work.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 1
1914-15

  1. Asst. Professor Foerster and Asst. Professor Ford, assisted by Mr. Staples. — Social Problems and Social Policy. Principles and Methods of Social Amelioration.

Total 102: 4 Graduates; 17 Seniors; 41 Juniors; 17 Sophomores; 23 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 1
1914-15

Answer questions in the order given. So allot your time that you may answer all. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.

1.  Describe the nature of recent legislation in the United States providing for the indemnification of industrial accidents. What special evils does such legislation entail? How, if at all, is it to be justified?

2.  What principles should be applied in industrial welfare work? Why?

3.  Having in mind the nature of unemployment and such measures for dealing with it as have been studied in this course, outline a programme of social policy for diminishing the seriousness of unemployment.

4.  Compare workers’ coöperative production and consumers’ coöperative production with respect to: —

(a)form of organization,

(b)management,

(c)remuneration of labor,

(d)distribution of profits.

Sketch the history in Great Britain of both sorts of coöperative production.

5.(a)What is the nature and the value of the Conseils de Prud’hommes.

(b)Criticize the main provisions of the protocol of the New York cloak, suit, and skirt makers’ unions.

6.  Contrast Great Britain with either Germany or Belgium with respect to the history, extent, and form of the consumers’ coöperative movement.

7.  “The main question is this: whether socialism will ever really be in a position to give effect, on its own ground, to the great psychological truth and economic utility which lies in the principle, according to which private interest is made a motive to the discharge of the functions of social production.”

How does Schaeffle answer this question? How would Spargo answer it? What is your answer?

8.  Is a decrease of personal liberty to be feared under socialism? Let your answer include an account of the arguments of Spargo and of Schaeffle.

9.  What is the programme of the Syndicalists for social reconstruction? Criticize this programme. What are your reasons for approving or disapproving this programme?

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 2

Course Description
1914-15

*2 2hf. Poor-Relief and Neighborhood Work. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and field work. Half-course (second half-year). Tu., Th., at 2.30, and frequent conferences by special appointment. Dr. Brackett.(XV)

This course studies the leading principles and methods of social service, with special reference to the following topics: Forms and sources of relief, treatment of special types of dependents, medical social service, organization of charity, financial management, modification of charitable trusts, supervision by public and private agencies, conduct of social settlements and kindred forms of neighborhood work. The course may serve as an introduction to Social Ethics 20c.

There will be frequent personal conferences on reading and field work.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 2
1914-15

  1. 2hf. Dr. Brackett. — Poor Relief and Neighborhood Work.

Total 12: 1 Graduate; 2 Seniors; 3 Juniors; 1 Sophomore; 5 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 2
1914-15

1.  Illustrate the purpose and leading methods of social work by: —

(a)A state policy for treatment of the feeble-minded; and

(b)A state policy for treatment of offenders.

2.  There are in the community a number of boys and young men who have been in the state reformatory school for boys. A suggestion is made that they form an association of alumni of the school.

What do you say for and against the plan?

3.  To what extent would you have the residents in a social settlement undertake to deal with persons who have shown marked anti-social tendencies, as with the drink habit.

4.  What were the chief differences between the work of the English Poor Law commissions of 1832–34 and 1905–09, as to: —

(a)The conditions which they found;

(b)Their recommendations.

5.  Comment on the following extract from a well-known worker and writer: —

“The eternal distinction of charity is that it is personal, the gift of man to man, warmed by feeling and guided by knowledge, where the gift and the giver go together. The state can by no lavishness take the place of such charity; and even when charity creates a fund, which it administers through officers and officials, the personality is lost, and the recipients feel nothing of the power of personal care and thought.”

6.  In a city of 25,000 inhabitants there is talk of the formation of an “Associated Charities.” The objection is made that there is no call for such an agency in such a place; that there are only a few charities, and that everybody knows everybody else.

What would you say in answer to such objections?

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 3
[not offered 1914-15]

Course Description
1914-15

*3 1hf. Criminology and Penology. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and reports. Half-course (first half-year).

This course offers a study of crime and its prevention, and includes investigation of historical and of present conditions. The subjects considered comprise the following: methods of study in criminology; classes of crimes and of criminals; causes and effects of crime; prevalent conceptions of crime and of the treatment which society should accord it; agencies especially intended for the punishment and prevention of crime (including certain features of criminal law and its administration, the identification of criminals, the indeterminate sentence, institutions for the detention, punishment, and reformation of criminals, the supervision and aid of convicts on probation or parole or after discharge, and special methods for dealing with young criminals); the influence on the volume of crime of various agencies designed for general social betterment.

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 41

Course Description
1914-15

4 1hf. Immigration and Race Problems. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and a research. Half-course (first half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 11. Asst. Professor Foerster.(IV)

This course deals principally with immigration into the United States, in its international aspects and as an internal problem; secondarily, with the American negro problem. Emigration from foreign countries is first studied — in its causes, its historical course, and its consequences for the countries from which it proceeds. Next are considered the history of immigration into the United States; the condition of immigrants in this country; and the effects, transitory and permanent, upon the United States, under social, industrial, and racial aspects. Questions of American internal policy (contact, utilization, assimilation) and the question of national policy (restriction, non-restriction, selection, protection) are studied, partly in relation to emigration and immigration legislation of other countries. To the negro problem less time is devoted; the rural and urban populations, their economic and social changes in the post-slavery period, and the broad questions of public and private policy are considered.

The method of the course is analytical rather than historical or descriptive. Special emphasis is laid on the thesis, and from time to time research conferences are substituted for lectures.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 4
1914-15

  1. 1hf. Asst. Professor Foerster. — Immigration and Race Problems.

Total 27: 5 Graduates; 8 Seniors; 8 Juniors; 6 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 4
1914-15

Answer questions in the order given. So allot your time that you may answer all. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.

1.  According to the Nation (November 19, 1914), Professor Tsaukoff of the University of Sofia calculates the cost to Bulgaria of the recent Balkan struggles as $256,000,000. “To this,” the editor comments, “must, of course, be added the immense damage wrought in the economic structure of the nation which lost a large part of its laboring population, — 58,000 men between twenty and forty-five years of age, or 6.7 per cent of the male workers.” A passage in the Quarterly Journal of Economics (November, 1908), is as follows: “For the entire kingdom [Italy] the permanent emigration has in effect deprived the country of one man in the fullest years of life out of every eight; for Campania and Basilicata, one out of six; for Calabria and Sardinia, one out of five.” How far, in your opinion, do the situations set forth in these citations coincide in their significance, and how far do they not?

2.  The view of an Irish bishop, who had visited America, is cited as follows by R. J. Kelley in “The Evils of Emigration”:

“Rarely is the condition of emigrants improved by their change of residence. . . . They are brought into daily contact with persons of little morality and less faith, and the struggle to maintain the soul in its primeval rectitude amid such surroundings often proves too great for the stability of human nature. Nor, in most instances, are the temporal circumstances of the emigrants benefited by the change. Were the same energy expended in industrial pursuits in our own country as is demanded abroad, those who have attained success in other lands would have been equally fortunate at home. . . . Indeed, everything considered, men who have experience of the conditions of life at home and abroad do not hesitate to express their preference for the quiet, innocent joys of an Irish rural home rather than for the irritating strain and wearying struggle which burden life elsewhere.”

Does your view of the gains or losses to immigrants in America agree or disagree with this view? What are the grounds of your opinion?

3.  At what points is the housing problem complicated by immigration?

4.  Wherein is the immigration problem related to (a) the question of a protective tariff, (b) the invention and use of machinery, (c) the policy of conservation of resources?

5.  Do you justify the trade unions in their opposition to unrestricted immigration?

6.  “The remedy for the moral indigestion which unchecked immigration is said to induce is in enlarging the organs of digestion. . . . Immigration consists of masses of our fellow men moving upon our country in pursuit of their share of human happiness. . . . There is no lack of resources, material or spiritual, for carrying out our half of the assimilation programme. . . . We are letting a few do the work we should all be helping in.” (Mary Antin in “They who Knock at our Gates.”)

Outline an argument supporting or opposing this view.

7.  “In two particulars of vital consequence this bill embodies a radical departure from the traditional and long-established policy of this country, a policy in which our people have conceived the very character of their Government to be expressed, the very mission and spirit of the nation in respect of its relations to the peoples of the world outside their borders. It seeks to all but close entirely the gates of asylum which have always been open to those who could find nowhere else the right and opportunity of constitutional agitation for what they conceived to be the natural and inalienable rights of men, and it excludes those to whom the opportunities of elementary education have been denied without regard to their character, their purposes or their natural capacity. . . . The new tests here embodied are not tests of quality or of character or of personal fitness, but tests of opportunity.”

Review this main argument of President Wilson’s in veto of the Burnet bill, from the point of view of (a) the significance of the “gates of asylum,” (b) the distinction between tests of “quality” (etc.), and tests of “opportunity,” and the significance of this distinction.

8.  Consider each of the following statements asking yourself (1) Is it true? and (2) If only partly true wherein is it true and wherein false? Be careful to show what evidence or reasons may be given for the position you take.

(a)The Italians in Mississippi outstrip the negroes of the same region in economic accumulation.

(b)Immigrants have a higher rate of crime than the native population has.

9.  How does prejudice against the negro operate? Do you agree or disagree with Shaler in his recommendations as to the treatment of race prejudice?

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 51

Course Description
1914-15

5 1hf. The Housing Problem. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and research. Half-course (first half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 10. Asst. Professor Ford.(III)

Primarily a course in social research. Each student is required to make an intensive survey of housing conditions in a selected district, or to undertake an original investigation in some detail of the subject. The lectures and prescribed reading deal with methods and results of existing housing surveys, with the causes and remedies of lot and room congestion, with problems of construction, sanitation, and maintenance of tenements, lodging houses, and cottages. The agencies of improved construction of dwellings — philanthropic, coöperative and governmental — are treated, together with methods of residential and industrial decentralization. The function of health and building codes, taxation, land reform, city planning, in the regulation and improvement of housing conditions, are examined in detail.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 5
1914-15

  1. 1hf. Asst. Professor James Ford. — The Housing Problem.

Total 16: 2 Graduates; 8 Seniors; 2 Juniors; 4 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 5
1914-15

Answer all questions fully and with precision. Avoid irrelevant discussion. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.

1.  Discuss the following: —

(a)Loss of seal.

(b)The building zones of Boston.

(c)The balcony fire escape.

2.  Show how tuberculosis is transmitted from person to person. Outline all the provisions which should be incorporated in an urban housing ordinance to prevent the transmission of this disease in multiple dwellings.

3.  Describe in detail the plan, equipment, and management of

(a)The Riverside Dwellings, Brooklyn.

(b)The Rowton Houses of London.

4.  Give arguments for the decentralization of industry. Outline a satisfactory policy which might be applied in Massachusetts (a) to decentralize industry, (b) to provide for the housing of industrial employees.

5.  “Die Wohnungsfrage ist eine Kreditfrage” (Fuchs). In how far is this statement true? How should it be qualified? Outline the typical American method of meeting this problem.

6.  Outline the laws of France which are designed to promote the construction of workmen’s dwellings. Show how far the powers under these laws are utilized. Would you advocate the application of any of the provisions of the French law in Massachusetts? Give reasons fully.

7.  Describe and illustrate by diagram the “Philadelphia type of house.” Explain the prevalence of this type in Philadelphia.

8.  Outline the methods of districting applied in German cities. Compare with those of American cities.

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 6

Course Description
1914-15

6 2hf. Social Amelioration in Europe, with special reference to Social Insurance. — Lectures and prescribed reading. Half-course (second half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 11. Asst. Professor Foerster.(IV)

This course is mainly concerned with schemes of social amelioration that have so far been little developed in the United States. It makes a comparative study of the preventive and constructive measures, public and private, of several countries. After a brief consideration of the function of thrift institutions, unemployment and such devices for dealing with it as relief works, labor exchanges, benefit systems, insurance and labor colonies are discussed. Experience in provision for accident, sickness, invalidity, and old age, by systems of compensation, pensions and insurance, is examined. The course closes with a study of recent developments of legislation governing conditions of labor.

The treatment is throughout inductive. The incidence of the burden of comprehensive social measures, their ulterior effects upon the population and the significance of the principles they involve are frequently discussed.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 6
1914-15

  1. 2hf. Asst. Professor Foerster. — Social Amelioration in Europe, with special reference to Social Insurance.

Total 22: 5 Graduates; 6 Seniors; 8 Juniors; 3 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 6
1914-15

Answer questions in the order given. So allot your time that you may answer all. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.

1.  Speaking in the House of Commons on May 19, 1909 on proposed legislation providing for a system of national labor exchanges, Mr. Winston Churchill said: “There is one thing in connection with labour exchanges. They will not to any large extent create new employment. In so far as facilities for getting labour on particular occasions sometimes lead to extra men being taken on, they will increase employment. That, however, is only a very small result. They will not directly add to the volume of employment. I never contemplated that they should. It would be to invest the policy with an air of humbug if we were to pretend that labour exchanges are going to make more work.” Give your reasons for accepting or not accepting this argument.

2.  Describe unemployment insurance in (a) Ghent; (b) Norway. Would an adaptation of the Norwegian system be feasible and desirable in Massachusetts?

3.  In the course of a speech on legislative provision for old age, on May 7, 1908 (before the enactment of the English law) the Prime Minister, Mr Asquith, said in the House of Commons: “I need not remind the Committee that this question in one shape or another has been before the country now for the best part of thirty years. . . . In the meantime other countries have been making experiments. The German system, which is one of compulsory State-aided assurance, has been in existence since 1889. . . . More instruction, I think, for our purposes is to be derived from the legislation initiated in Denmark in 1891, in New Zealand in 1898, and subsequently in New South Wales and Victoria.” Indicate what are the important problems involved in legislating for old age and show as far as you can how these problems have been dealt with in the laws of the countries under review.

4.  Outline the main provisions of such a law for the indemnification of industrial accidents as in your opinion one of our eastern states might best adopt; show how each of these provisions compares with the corresponding provisions of the important European laws, and indicate reasons for your choice of the terms of the law you propose.

5.  In the plan for sickness insurance submitted to the Commission on Industrial Relations, and published by the United States Public Health Service, the rates of contribution are fixed as follows: —

Employees . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 50 per cent.

Employers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40 per cent.

Community . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 to 10 per cent.

State . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 to 10 per cent.

The contribution by employers is explained as “probably necessary to give them the same interest in the fund which employees have; without this responsibility and incentive to save, only the exceptionally wise or humane employer would take any interest in the prevention of sickness.” What portion does the employer pay in the European systems of sickness insurance which you have studied? How adequate do you regard the explanation given of the need for an employer’s contribution?

6.  Sir Rufus Isaacs, Attorney-General, speaking of German experience in social insurance in the House of Commons on May 24, 1911, said: “Germany has gradually built up a system which by common consent is of most beneficent character and is working to the advantage not only of the employer, but also of the employed . . . without impairing the independence of the workers.” Discuss the issue of “independence” from such points of view as you have studied, particularly from the point of view of Belloc.

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 7

Course Description
1914-15

7 2hf. Rural Social Development. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and a thesis. Half-course (second half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 10. Asst. Professor Ford.(III)

This course deals with the methods of rural social research, and with measures for the improvement of rural social conditions. It begins with an examination of the distribution of rural population in the United States, the bearing of physical and economic environments and of racial distribution upon local social problems. The causes of rural depopulation, degeneracy, poverty, disease are examined, with special reference to ascertaining the means of prevention. Measures are considered for the development of country life from without through “back-to-the-land” movements, urban and State assistance; and for rural reconstruction from within through adaptation of existing local institutions and through coöperative movements.

The third hour of each week is devoted to the discussion of prescribed reading or to direction of research.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 7
1914-15

  1. 2hf. Asst. Professor James Ford. — Rural Social Development.

Total 16: 2 Graduates; 6 Seniors; 1 Junior; 2 Sophomores; 5 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 7
1914-15

Answer all questions fully and with precision. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.

1.  What data should be secured in a thorough rural social survey concerning local poverty and the relief of poverty? Answer in detail.

2.  Compare immigrant races in rural communities with reference to the rapidity of assimilation. Name and explain the factors which operate to promote or retard assimilation.

3.  Discuss (a) the Kallikak family; (b) the Boerenbond of Belgium.

4.  State in detail the moral value of play. Outline a policy for the provision of developmental play for farm boys of 12–16 years of age.

5.  Compare urban and rural mortality rates within the United States registration area from any three transmissible diseases. Account for the differences between the urban and rural rates from each of these diseases.

6.  (a) Describe the forms of organization and the business methods of coöperative grain elevator associations. (b) Show fully in what ways the coöperative movement may promote the moral development of the individual member.

7.(a)Compare urban and rural population in the United States with respect to: —

age distribution,
school attendance,
illiteracy.

(b)Show the causes and consequences of rural conditions noted in (a).

8.  “One of the most distinctive features of capitalism is the division of the population connected with industry into two great social classes — those who own but do not use and those who use but do not own, the instruments by which wealth is produced and distributed.” (Simons: “The American Farmer”) (a) In which of these classes does Simons place the American farmer? (b) For what reasons? (c) Show the weaknesses of his argument.

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 8

Course Description
1914-15

8 1hf. Child-Helping Agencies: Their Problems and Methods. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and field work under skilled direction. Half-course (first half-year). Tu., Th., at 2.30, and a conference hour by special appointment. Dr. Carstens.(XV)

This course deals with the important phases of child-helping work in well equipped communities. It treats of the historical development of this form of social service, the advantages of institutions and individual family homes for dependent and neglected children, juvenile courts and probation, juvenile delinquency, the various forms of child protection, the training of defectives in sight, hearing, and speech, and the training and custody of the mentally defective. In addition special studies are made of illegitimacy, infant mortality, child labor and other special phases of child-helping work.

Each student is required to become acquainted with at least one of the important groups of organizations in child-helping service that are found in Boston and vicinity.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 8
1914-15

  1. 1hf. Dr. Carstens. — Child-Helping Agencies.

Total 7: 2 Graduates; 1 Senior; 1 Junior; 3 Others.

Sources:

Division of History, Government, and Economics 1914-15. Published in Official Register of Harvard University, vol. XI, No. 1, Part 14 (May 19, 1914), pp. 73-76.

Harvard University. Report of the President of Harvard College, 1914-15. Pages 65-66.

Papers set for final examinations in history, history of science, government, economics, philosophy, social ethics, education, fine arts, music in Harvard College (June, 1915).

Image Source:  F. Séguin “Conseil des Prud’hommes. Tribunal de Conciliation” (1895) in Musée Carnavalet, Histoire de Paris (D.13479).

Categories
Exam Questions Harvard Social Insurance Social Work

Harvard. Social Ethics course descriptions, enrollments, final exams. 1913-1914

SOCIAL ETHICS

Social Ethics 1-8
1913-14

Social Ethics 1. Social Problems and Social Policy
Social Ethics 2. Administration of Agencies for Poor-Relief and Neighborhood Welfare
Social Ethics 3. Criminology and Penology [omitted 1913-14]
Social Ethics 4. Immigration and Race Problems
Social Ethics 5. The Housing Problem
Social Ethics 6. Social Amelioration in Europe
Social Ethics 7. Rural Social Development
Social Ethics 8. Child-Helping Agencies

Social Ethics Instructors
1913-14

Jeffrey Richardson Brackett
Robert Franz Foerster
James Ford
Hermann Franklin Arens
Carl Christian Carstens

GENERAL STATEMENT

The courses of this Department are designed to apply ethical principles to social problems, to indicate methods of social research, and to determine measures for social improvement.

Course 1 offers a general survey of social problems, of the agencies and methods of social betterment. Students are advised before taking it to take courses both in Economics and in Philosophy, and must have taken a course, or the equivalent of a course, in one of these subjects.

Courses 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8 are open to students who have received a satisfactory grade in Social Ethics 1. Juniors and Seniors specializing in Economics or Philosophy and graduate students are eligible to enrolment. These courses all deal intensively with specific social problems, — with conditions, principles, and policy. Courses 2 and 8, offered by officials of Massachusetts charitable organizations, are largely concerned with methods and problems of administration. Course 5 is primarily a course in research. Field work is required in Courses 2, 5, and 8, and can be assigned upon request in Courses 4 and 7.

[…]

For Undergraduates and Graduates

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 1

Course Description
1913-14

1. Social Problems and Social Policy. — Lectures, prescribed reading, theses. Tu., Th., Sat., at 10. Asst. Professor Foerster and Asst. Professor Ford.

This course gives a survey of contemporary social problems with special reference to principles and methods of social amelioration.

It begins with a discussion of the bearing of ethics upon social and economic problems and seeks throughout to apply ethical principles to specific problems. Among the subjects dealt with are the methods of social investigation, immigration, incomes and expenditures, the methods of public and private relief of poverty, delinquent and defective classes, control of the liquor traffic, the family, housing, public recreation, wages and hours of labor of men, women and children, industrial disputes and their settlement, compensation for accidents, workmen’s insurance, producers’ and consumers’ coöperation, profit-sharing, ethical aspects of socialism. An important feature of the course is a thesis in the first term dealing with problems of poverty, and in the second term dealing with labor problems; either or both of these may involve field work.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 1
1913-14

  1. Asst. Professor Foerster and Asst. Professor James Ford, assisted by Mr. Arens. — Social Problems and Social Policy. Principles and Methods of Social Amelioration.

Total 77: 4 Graduates; 15 Seniors; 39 Juniors; 10 Sophomores; 2 Freshmen; 7 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 1
1913-14

Answer questions in the order given. So allot your time that you may answer all. Your opinions should be supported by reasons which should take account of the arguments of both reading and lectures.

1. Outline the means by which trade unions attempt to get and retain a monopoly of labor.

2. What are the effects of (a) immigration, (b) trade unionism, on rates of wages?

3. Compare English and German measures for indemnifying employees in case of accident.

4. What are the devices for settlement of industrial disputes in the American states? What are the essentials of a successful method of dealing with industrial disputes?

5. Discuss: —

(a)gain-sharing,

(b)an American example of industrial partnership,

(c)the advantages and disadvantages to railway employees of railway pensions systems.

6. What are the limitations upon consumers’ co-operation? What are the limitations upon workers’ (independent) co-operative production? What are the obstacles to the realization of such a socialist state as Wells describes?

7. What are the characteristics of successful communist societies? What have been the causes of failure of the unsuccessful? From this history of communism can you infer anything as to the feasibility of Wells’ socialist state?

8. What is the program of action of: —

(a)Marxian socialism?

(b)Revolutionary syndicalism?

(c)The Socialist party of the United States?

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 2

Course Description
1913-14

*2 2hf. Administration of Agencies for Poor-Relief and Neighborhood Welfare. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and field work. Half-course (second half-year). Tu., Th., at 2.30, and a third hour by special appointment. Dr. Brackett.

This course studies the administration of public and private agencies of social service, with special reference to the following topics: Forms and sources of relief, treatment of special types of dependents, medical social service, organization of charity, financial management, modification of charitable trusts, supervision by public and private agencies and principles and methods of social settlements and kindred forms of neighborhood work. The course may serve as an introduction to Social Ethics 20c.

There will be frequent personal conferences on reading and field work.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 2
1913-14

  1. 2hf. Dr. Brackett. — Administration of Agencies for Poor Relief and Neighborhood Welfare.

Total 5: 1 Senior; 2 Juniors; 2 Sophomores.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 2
1913-14

1. What is your idea of the

(a)underlying purposes,

(b)the leading methods,

of a social settlement?

2. What argument would you use, to try to persuade a “ministers’ meeting” in a town of ten thousand persons that there is need of a society for organizing charity in their town?

3. What should be the attitude of relief agencies to families in distress because their wage-earners go on a strike?

4. A. What were the leading suggestions of

(a)the majority report,

(b)the minority report,

of the English Poor Law Commission of 1909, as to public aid in relief of distress?

B. What do you think of the majority and the minority reports of the English Commission of 1909 as bearing on the causes of distress?

5. Outline a state policy for dealing with one of the following types: —

A. The feeble-minded

or

B. The delinquent.

6. You are a comparatively new subscriber to a charitable agency whose purposes, as set forth in its publications, seem to you to be very important. It is supported by subscriptions and is under the management of a small board of directors elected at the annual meeting of subscribers. You think, especially from what you hear from social workers in other agencies, that this agency is not well developed, is wasting opportunities of service to the community. What ways would you suggest for securing improvement in the work of that agency?

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 3

Course Description
[omitted 1913-14]

[*3 1hf. Criminology and Penology. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and reports. Half-course (first half-year).]

Omitted in 1913-14.

This course offers a study of crime and its prevention, and includes investigation of historical and of present conditions. The subjects considered comprise the following: methods of study in criminology; classes of crimes and of criminals; causes and effects of crime; prevalent conceptions of crime and of the treatment which society should accord it; agencies especially intended for the punishment and prevention of crime (including certain features of criminal law and its administration, the identification of criminals, the indeterminate sentence, institutions for the detention, punishment, and reformation of criminals, the supervision and aid of convicts on probation or parole or after discharge, and special methods for dealing with young criminals); the influence on the volume of crime of various agencies designed for general social betterment.

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 41

Course Description
1913-14

*4 1hf. Immigration and Race Problems. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and a research. Half-course (first half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 11. Asst. Professor Foerster.

This course deals principally with immigration into the United States, in its international aspects and as an internal problem; secondarily, with the American negro problem. Emigration from foreign countries is first studied — in its causes, its historical course, and its consequences for the countries from which it proceeds. Next are considered the history of immigration into the United States; the condition of immigrants in this country; and the effects, transitory and permanent, upon the United States, under social, industrial, and racial aspects. Questions of American internal policy (contact, utilization, assimilation) and the question of national policy (restriction, non-restriction, selection, protection) are studied, partly in relation to emigration and immigration legislation of other countries. To the negro problem less time is devoted; the rural and urban populations, their economic and social changes in the post-slavery period, and the broad questions of public and private policy are considered.

The method of the course is analytical rather than historical or descriptive. Special emphasis is laid on the thesis, and from time to time research conferences are substituted for lectures.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 4
1913-14

  1. 1hf. Asst. Professor Foerster. — Immigration and Race Problems.

Total 21: 5 Graduates; 2 Seniors; 3 Juniors; 3 Sophomores; 2 Freshmen; 6 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 4
1913-14

Answer questions in the order given. So allot your time that you may answer all. When your conclusions differ from those reached in the course, it is best to indicate wherein and why. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.

I (about 1 hr.)

Comment upon the following citations made from Stelzle’s “American Social and Religious Conditions,” by answering the correspondingly numbered questions below.

1. “The condition of the labor market in the U. S. determines the number of foreigners that come and go, so that the immigrant is in a constant state of flux.”

1. What evidence can you adduce to prove or disprove this statement? How completely are the changes in the demand for labor reflected in the “flux”?

2. “To-day by the mere fact of his arrival, every immigrant increases the value of the land in the United States by $500. Every new-born babe has the same effect upon land values.”

2. How do you prove or disprove this statement? Can you illustrate your argument by citing the position of negroes and Italians in Mississippi?

3. “They come to us, most of these immigrants, after their own countries have paid the cost of their education. They are ready to take up their day’s work the moment they land on our American shore.”

3. Briefly describe the condition of new immigrants as to education and fitness for economic activity.

4. “Not only do they rapidly adopt American customs, but their personal and bodily appearance undergoes a marked change. In many instances, the children of the immigrant show greater height and weight than the same race in the mother country, and in some cases, even the head form, which has always been considered one of the most stable and permanent characteristics of races has undergone very great changes. . . . If these physical changes are so great, we may well conclude that the whole mental and even moral circumstances of the people may also rapidly change under the new conditions.”

4. Discuss the logic of the conclusion as to mental and moral qualities. Giving your reasons in some detail, state whether

(1) the presumption is that immigration

(a)will improve our future race stock,

(b)will not affect it in any respect, or

(c)will hurt it,

or (2) our knowledge of heredity justifies no presumption at all.

5. “However, it must not be assumed that there are no perils in the foreigners who are coming to us in such large numbers. It is quite possible that in many respects they may become an undigested mass. One of the problems which concerns us is that of distribution.”

5. How far and in what sense is distribution practicable? Would its ulterior consequences be good or ill?

II (not more than 1½ hrs.)

6. Hourwich holds that rates of wages are not affected, adversely at least, by immigration. How does he seek to prove his argument? What is your chief reason for accepting or rejecting his argument?

7. How does Fairchild reply to Hourwich’s contention that immigrants have made it possible for American wage earners to rise?

8. Compare the industrial and social consequences of the legal restriction of child or woman labor with those of the legal restriction of unskilled or low-skilled immigration. How is demand for labor related to changes in rates of wages?

9. (Briefly.) Suppose all public and philanthropic expenditures upon immigrants to cease, what main results would follow?

10. “Reading and writing the English language would be our next demand for him. For this we should ask state legislation, establishing compulsory education for non-English speaking adults. If it be objected that school attendance could not be secured on account of the length of working hours, the obvious answer is that hours of labor which shut out all opportunity for exercise of the mental faculties or the social instincts, are thereby shown to be too long and should be reduced.” (Miss Claghorn, in the Survey, Dec. 27, ’13). Do you approve? Should public and philanthropic aid be given to permit immigrants (and Americans in the same occupations) to live according to the More and Chapin standards of efficiency ($800–900 in New York for a family)?

III (about ½ hr.)

11. What occupational training had negroes under slavery?

12. What are the gains and losses to Italy through emigration? Which are greater?

13. Describe either

(a) the boarding system among immigrants, (Fairchild) or

(b) the history, and its significance, of company houses in Lowell (Kenngott).

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 5

Course Description
1913-14

*5 1hf. The Housing Problem. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and a research. Half-course (first half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 10. Asst. Professor Ford.

Primarily a course in social research. Each student is required to make an intensive survey of housing conditions in a selected district, or to undertake an original investigation in some detail of the subject. The lectures and prescribed reading deal with methods and results of existing housing surveys, with the causes and remedies of lot and room congestion, with problems of construction, sanitation, and maintenance of tenements, lodging houses, and cottages. The agencies of improved construction of dwellings — philanthropic, coöperative and governmental — are treated, together with methods of residential and industrial decentralization. The function of health and building codes, taxation, land reform, city planning, in the regulation and improvement of housing conditions, are examined in detail.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 5
1913-14

  1. 1hf. Asst. Professor James Ford. — The Housing Problem.

Total 9: 3 Graduates; 4 Seniors; 2 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 5
1913-14

Answer all questions fully and with precision. Avoid irrelevant discussion. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.

1. Outline the problem of room overcrowding in (a) American and (b) English cities. (c) State the provisions of the New York Tenement House Act (1909) which are designed to control this evil. (d) What means of control are suggested by Veiller (“Room Overcrowding and the Lodger Evil”)? (e) Show the merits and the limitations of (c) and (d). (f) By what further measures can this problem be met advantageously?

2. Outline a practicable housing policy for Boston, that would preclude further disasters of the type of the recent “Arcadia” fire.

3. Outline the provisions of the New York Tenement House Act which deal with the enforcement of that Act.

4. Give a criticism of Howard’s plan for the establishment and operation of Garden Cities. (a) What parts of Howard’s scheme are impracticable? (b) What parts are practicable and of value?

5. “No apartment house shall be erected in residential districts unless the consent of two-thirds of the owners of land in the block in which the erection is proposed, is obtained.” (Ordinance of Calgary, Alberta, 1912.)

(a)What undesirable conditions is this ordinance designed to prevent?

(b)Are these conditions met in a satisfactory way by this ordinance? (Give your reasons in detail.)

(c)Discuss the merits of the “Zone System” as an alternative means of excluding apartment houses from residential districts.

6. “The housing problem is a land problem.”

(a)What is meant by this statement?

(b)In how far is it correct?

(c)Enumerate all methods by which the “land problem” may be attacked to improve housing conditions.

(d)Which of these methods would you urge for immediate adoption in Massachusetts?

(e)Why do you urge these methods?

(f)Why do you exclude other methods?

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 6

Course Description
1913-14

*6 2hf. Social Amelioration in Europe, with especial reference to Social Insurance. — Lectures and prescribed reading. Half-course (second half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 11. Asst. Professor Foerster.

This course is mainly concerned with schemes of social amelioration that have so far been little developed in the United States. It makes a comparative study of the preventive and constructive measures, public and private, of several countries. After a brief consideration of the function of thrift institutions, unemployment and such devices for dealing with it as relief works, labor exchanges, benefit systems, insurance and labor colonies are discussed. Experience in provision for accident, sickness, invalidity, and old age, by systems of compensation, pensions and insurance, are examined. The course closes with a study of recent developments of legislation governing conditions of labor.

The treatment is throughout inductive. The incidence of the burden of comprehensive social measures, their ulterior effects upon the population and the significance of the principles they involve are frequently discussed.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 6
1913-14

  1. 2hf. Asst. Professor Foerster. — Social Amelioration in Europe, with special reference to Social Insurance.

Total 21: 6 Graduates; 2 Seniors; 6 Juniors; 2 Sophomores; 1 Freshman; 4 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 6
1913-14

So allot your time that you may answer all questions. Your opinions should be supported by reasons, which should take account of the arguments of both reading and lectures.

1. “Take the case of one employer who employs ten men on Monday and another who employs ten men in the same class of employment on Tuesday. If there is no such organisation as that contemplated by the labour exchanges, the result will be you will have twenty men partially employed on those two days. The express object of the organisation of the labour exchanges is that instead of having twenty men partially employed, you will have ten men fully employed. . . . Not only will the establishment of labour exchanges not add to employment, but if they are to serve the only purpose which they can economically serve, the necessary consequence of their establishment must be actually to diminish employment. . . . I think it is important that those who are pressing forward this proposal to start labour exchanges should realise that the inevitable economic consequence of establishing those exchanges will be that you will diminish the number of men who can find work of any kind, although you are going to give them a larger living wage.” — F. E. Smith, House of Commons, May 19, 1909.

(a)By what reasoning do you sustain or oppose this argument? In your answer consider Beveridge’s reply to objections to decasualization.

(b)Outline the English system of labor exchanges and indicate whether, because of it, there will be less unemployment during the next cyclical period of depression than there would be if the system had not been established.

2. “But when I look beyond and ask whether it is conceivable that we may begin so to hold out the thought that men may be able to receive from the State that which in olden days they won by their own strong labours, self-denial, and thrift, then I am apprehensive lest we should, in attempting to do a good, do a great and grievous wrong, robbing ourselves and our children of that which is the best inheritance, the inheritance of a sturdy, strong, self-reliant manhood, that will take upon itself the responsibilities of life and be equal, therefore, to the responsibilities of Empire.” — Bishop of Ripon, House of Lords, July 20, 1908, speaking on the bill for old age pensions.

In which of their provisions do the laws dealing with old age in England, Denmark, Belgium, and Germany (considered in order) favor or hinder the maintenance of self-reliance in the population? In your discussion of the English situation review the argument of Hobhouse.

3. Where does the financial burden of old age provision ultimately fall (a) in England, (b) in Germany?

4. “Depend upon it, this Bill when it passes is the death warrant of the friendly societies of this country. . . . It is because I believe that in its present form this Bill is a great danger to liberty that I think it is vital that the country should have a further opportunity of expressing its opinion upon it and of saying whether it desires to have these German shackles put upon it, or whether it would not prefer to have a scheme founded upon the principle of liberty and independence.” — Lord Robert Cecil, House of Commons, December 6, 1911, speaking on the bill for sickness insurance.

(a)Compare the organization and history of the friendly societies with the organization and history of the French mutual aid societies; why the difference of result?

(b)Point out the similarities of the provisions of English and German sickness insurance.

(c)Would you, like Lord Cecil, oppose the state’s interference with the voluntary societies of England? Why?

5. Point out the technical difference between an assessment and a premium system of insurance against industrial accidents. What type exists in Austria? in Germany? How is the employer affected by the two types?

6. Describe (a) Danish unemployment insurance.

(b) Choice and remuneration of doctors under Danish and German sickness insurance.

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 7

Course Description
1913-14

*7 2hf. Rural Social Development. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and a thesis. Half-course (second half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 10. Asst. Professor Ford.

This course deals with the methods of rural social research, and with measures for the improvement of rural social conditions. It begins with an examination of the distribution of rural population in the United States, the bearing of physical and economic environments and of racial distribution upon local social problems. The causes of rural depopulation, degeneracy, poverty, disease are examined, with special reference to ascertaining the means of prevention. Measures are considered for the development of country life from without through “back-to-the-land” movements, urban and State assistance; and for rural reconstruction from within through adaptation of existing local institutions and through coöperative movements.

The third hour of each week is devoted to the discussion of prescribed reading or to direction of research.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 7
1913-14

  1. 2hf. Asst. Professor James Ford. — Rural Social Development.

Total 17: 5 Graduates; 4 Seniors; 2 Juniors; 4 Sophomores; 2 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 7
1913-14

Answer all questions fully and with precision. Avoid irrelevant discussion. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.

1. What data concerning poverty should be sought for a rural social survey in a Massachusetts township? Why is each item important? What are the possible sources of the data on local poverty?

2. Is it wise to place immigrants who were farmers in the country of their birth on farms in this country? Give all important arguments pro and con. Qualify your conclusions where necessary.

3. (a) Define pageant. Outline the plot of the Thetford pageant. Show how the pageant may be made a means of rural social development.

(b) What evidence have we of the part played by environment in producing the degeneracy of the Hill Folk?

4. Describe the work of the Laurel Hill Improvement Society of Stockbridge, Massachusetts. What methods and program for village improvement societies does experience prove to be most effective?

5. Outline the problems of recreation that are characteristic of rural communities. Name four groups of agencies by which these problems might be met. Select one sex and age group and show what is now done and what might be done by each agency to meet the recreation problem of that group.

6. Give arguments for and against consolidation of rural schools. Defend your conclusion.

7. What are the prerequisites of successful co-operation among farmers? (Powell, chap. on “Fundamentals in Co-operation,” and lectures.)

8. Describe fully and critically the forms of co-operative organization and the business methods of California fruit growers.

9. How may rural communities be distinguished from urban?

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 81

Course Description
1913-14

*8 1hf. Child-Helping Agencies: Their Problems and Methods. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and field work under skilled direction. Half-course (first half-year). Tu., Th., at 2.30, and a conference hour by appointment. Dr. Carstens.

This course studies the important phases of child-helping work in well-equipped communities. It treats of the social service rendered by the institutions and the family homes which receive dependent or neglected children, of juvenile courts, probation, training schools for juvenile delinquents, and of the various forms of child protection. The methods of training children defective in sight, hearing, and speech, and the training of the mentally defective are studied. Illegitimacy, infant mortality, and child labor are studied in their bearing upon the work of child-helping agencies.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 8
1913-14

  1. 1hf. Dr. Carstens. — Child-Helping Agencies.

Total 3: 2 Graduates; 1 Sophomore.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 8
1913-14

1. Give the significant steps in the development of the care of dependent children in the United States.

2. Show the inter-relationship of dependence, neglect, and delinquence, and illustrate by examples.

3. What is meant by “The Subsidy System in Private Charity”? Give arguments pro and con.

4. Make clear in what way feeble-mindedness becomes a community concern, and illustrate by examples.

5. What is meant by: (a) Mothers’ Pensions, (b) Guardianship, (c) Binet System, (d) Prenatal Care; and explain their relation to community care for children.

Sources:

Division of History, Government, and Economics 1913-14. Published in Official Register of Harvard University, vol. X, No. 1, Part X (May 19, 1913), pp. 71-75.

Harvard University. Report of the President of Harvard College, 1913-14. Pages 60-61.

Papers set for final examinations in history, history of science, government, economics, philosophy, psychology, social ethics, education, fine arts, music in Harvard College (June, 1914), pp. 74-83.

Image Source:  “Die deutsche Sozialversicherung steht in der ganzen Welt vorbildlich und unerreicht da.” Landesarchiv Baden-Württemberg, Hauptstaatsarchiv Stuttgart J 151 Nr 2230, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Categories
Exam Questions Philosophy Political Economy Suggested Reading Syllabus Yale

Yale. Economics of Democratic Politics. Readings, essay questions, final exam. Rose-Ackerman, 1980

Further jewels (transcribed below) from the Ed Tower collection of economics course materials come from the 1980 course taught at Yale by Susan Rose-Ackerman on the economics of democratic politics. I have used Claude to read, transcribe and follow the formatting of the original Tower pdf file downloaded from Duke. This gives me more time for curating and searching for more content and not just for leisure!

_______________________________

Susan Rose-Ackerman
Economics 488a (693a) / E&PS 202a
Fall, 1980
ML 313     Undergraduate Course

THE ECONOMICS OF
DEMOCRATIC POLITICS

All reading for the course is on reserve at both Cross Campus and Social Science Libraries. There will also be a xeroxed package for sale at Gnomen Copy.

Every week, I will distribute a set of discussion questions (not problem sets) to think about as you do the reading for the next week. Three times during the term, each student will write a short paper (about 5 pages) on one of these questions. The papers are to be turned in to my secretary by 5 p.m. on the Tuesday before the topic is discussed in class. This will give me time to read the papers before class. At the end of the course, there will be a take-home final exam.

Students who wish to use this seminar as a way to fulfill their writing requirement for the economics major should speak to me individually. Students who wish to write a longer term paper may do so and can be excused from some of the short papers, but must still take the exam. I would, however, like to try to coordinate the term papers with the classwork. Graduate students taking the course for credit should also speak with me so that I can be sure that they are not asked to duplicate material they already know.

My office is in Room 114 in the ISPS building at 111 Prospect and my secretary is in Room 117. Office hours are Monday from 2 – 4 p.m. or make an appointment at some other time (afternoons are preferable). My telephone number is 436-1087.

_______________________________

Susan Rose-Ackerman
Econ. 488a (693a) / E&PS 202a
Yale University
Fall, 1980
Wednesday, 2:30 – 4:30
ML 313

SYLLABUS
THE ECONOMICS OF
DEMOCRATIC POLITICS

BOOKS AT COOP:

Mueller, Dennis C., Public Choice, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1979.

Downs, Anthony, An Economic Theory of Democracy, Harper and Row, 1957.

Calabresi, Guido and Philip Bobbitt, Tragic Choices, Norton, 1978.

Miller, J. and B. Yandle, Eds., Benefit-Cost Analyses of Social Regulation. Case Studies from the Council for Wage and Price Stability, American Enterprise Institute, Washington, D.C., 1979.

Arnold, Douglas R., Congress and the Bureaucracy, Yale University Press, 1979.

OPTIONAL:

Fiorina, Morris, Congress Keystone of the Washington Establishment, Yale University Press, 1977.

Sen, A.K., Collective Choice and Social Welfare, North Holland.

Rose-Ackerman, Susan, Corruption: A Study in Political Economy, Academic Press, 1978.

DATEI.INTRODUCTION: THE ROLE OF THE STATE: CORRECTING MARKET “FAILURES” OR MAKING “FAIR” COLLECTIVE CHOICES

9/10 1.Mueller, Chapters 1 and 2.

 II.WEALTH MAXIMIZATION, UTILITY MAXIMIZATION, AND EQUALITY

 A.Wealth Maximization vs. Utility Maximization

  1.Review of Public Goods Theory and Welfare Economics

(Opt)a)F. Scherer, Industrial Market Structure and Economic Performance Rand McNally, 1973, Chapter 2.

(Opt)b)W. Baumol, Economic Theory and Operations Analysis, 4th Ed., Chapter 21. (General Equilibrium and Welfare Economics), Sections 1-14, pp. 496-531.

(Opt)c)R. Musgrave and P. Musgrave, Public Finance in Theory and Practice, 2nd Ed., Chapter 3.

9/17 2.Ronald Dworkin, “Is Wealth a Value?;” Anthony Kronman, “Wealth Maximization;” and Richard Posner, “The Value of Wealth,” Journal of Legal Studies (1980) 9: 191-252.

9/24B.Equality and Utility

  1.Douglas Rae, “The Egalitarian States: Notes on a System of Contradictory Ideals,” Daedalus (Fall 1979) 108: 37-54.

  2.A.P. Lerner, Economics of Control, Chapter 3.

 (Opt)3.A.K. Sen, On Economic Inequality, Clarendon Press, Oxford, Chapter 1.

  4.Paul Samuelson, “A.P. Lerner at Sixty,” Review of Economic Studies (June 1964) reprinted in Collected Scientific Papers of Paul A. Samuelson, 3: 647-650, part 7 only.

  5.Bruce Ackerman, Social Justice in the Liberal State, Yale Press, 1980, Chapter 1, Sections 1-6.

 (Opt)6.Mueller, Chapters 12 (on Rawls) and 13 (on Harsanyi).

 (Opt)7.Sen, Chapter 9.

 III.DIRECT DEMOCRACY

10/1A.Voting Rules

  1.Mueller, Chapter 3 (Chapter 5 is optional).

 (Opt)2.R. Musgrave, The Theory of Public Finance, McGraw-Hill, 1959, Chapter 6.

  3.R. Niemi and W. Riker, “The Choice of Voting Systems,” Scientific American (June 1976) 234: 21-27.

 (Opt)4.J. Buchanan and G. Tullock, The Calculus of Consent, University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor, 1962, Chapter 10, 131-145.

10/8B.Justifications for Majority Rule

  1.Mueller, Chapter 11.

 (Opt)2.Sen, Chapter 10 (unstarred).

 (Opt)3.Douglas Rae, “Decision Rules and Individual Values in Collective Choices,” American Political Science Review (1969) 63: 40-56.

  4.Ackerman, Chapter 9, parts 60, 61, 62, 64.

10/15
C.New Voting Systems: Demand Revealing Schemes

(1/2)

  1.Mueller, Chapter 4.

  2.T.M. Tideman and G. Tullock, “A New and Superior Process for Making Social Choices,” Journal of Political Economy (December 1976) 84: 1145-1160.

 (Opt)3.V.L. Smith, “The Principle of Unanimity and Voluntary Consent in Social Choice,” Journal of Political Economy (December 1977) 85: 1125-1140.

 IV.REPRESENTATIVE DEMOCRACY

10/15A.Electoral Competition

(1/2)

10/22 1.Mueller, Chapter 6, pp. 97-120.

  2.J. Schumpeter, “The Classical Doctrine of Democracy,” and “Another Theory of Democracy,” Chapters 21 and 22 of Schumpeter, Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy, 3rd Ed., Harper, 1950, 250-283.

  3.Downs, pp. 1-141.

  4.Rose-Ackerman, Chapters 1, 2, 3 and 11.

  5.Susan Rose-Ackerman, “Inefficiency and Reelection,” Kyklos (1980) 33: 287-307.

 (Opt)6.David Mayhew, Congress: The Electoral Connection, Yale University Press, 1974.

10/29B.Legislators, Voters and Interest Groups: Is It Rational to Participate in Politics?

  1.Mueller, pp. 120-124.

  2.Downs, pp. 260-276.

  3.Mancur Olson, “A Theory of Groups and Organizations,” Chapter 1 of Olson, The Logic of Collective Action, Harvard, 1965, pp. 5-52.

  4.Brian Barry, “Political Participation as Rational Action,” Chapter 2 of Barry, Sociologists, Economists and Democracy, Collier-MacMillan, 1970, pp. 13-40.

  5.Benn, Stanley E., “The Problematic Rationality of Political Participation,” in Laslett and Fishkin, Eds., Philosophy, Politics and Society, 5th Series, Yale University Press, 1979, pp. 291-312.

 (Opt)6.A.K. Sen, “Rational Fools: A Critique of the Behavioral Foundations of Economic Theory,” Philosophy and Public Affairs (Summer 1977) 6: 317-344.

 C.Exit, Voice and Disloyalty [sic]

 (Opt)1.Mueller, Chapter 7.

 (Opt)2.Albert Hirschman, Exit, Voice and Loyalty, Harvard Press, 1970.

[11/5,11/12]D.Legislative-Bureaucratic Interaction

  1.Mueller, Chapter 8.

  2.William A. Niskanen, Bureaucracy and Representative Government, Aldine, 1971, Chapters 1, 2, 17-21 (pp. 3-23, 189-290).

  3.Albert Breton and Ronald Wintrobe, “The Equilibrium Size of a Budget Maximizing Bureau: A Note on Niskanen’s Theory of Bureaucracy,” Journal of Political Economy (Feb 1975) 83: 195-207.

  4.W. Niskanen, “Bureaucrats and Politicians,” and J. Margolis, “Comments,” Journal of Law and Economics (Dec 1975) 18: 617-660.

 (Opt)5.M. Fiorina, Congress: Keystone of the Washington Establishment, Yale University Press, 1977.

  6.M. Fiorina, and R. Noll, “Voters, Legislators and Bureaucracy: Institutional Design and the Public Sector,” American Economic Review – Papers and Proceedings (May 1978) 68: 256-260.

  7.Douglas R. Arnold, Congress and the Bureaucracy, Yale University Press, 1979. Part I (pp. 3-91); Chapters 8 and 9 (pp. 165-216); Chapters 6 and 7 are optional.

  8.R. Musgrave, “Leviathan Cometh or Does He?,” mimeo.

[11/19]E.Policy Analysis and Politics

 (Opt)1.Musgrave and Musgrave, Chapters 7 and 8 on expenditure evaluation.

 (Opt)2.Charles Schultze, The Politics and Economics of Public Spending, Brookings Institute, Washington, 1968.

  3.Miller and Yandle, selected chapters.

12/3V.SOCIAL WELFARE FUNCTIONS AND HARD CHOICES: ARROW AND CALABRESI

  1.Mueller, Chapters 9, 10 and 14.

 (Opt)2.Kenneth J. Arrow, “Values and Collective Decision Making,” in Philosophy, Politics and Society (1967), Laslett and Runciman, Eds.

 (Opt)3.Sen, Chapters 1-3, 5, 7 (unstarred chapters).

  4.G. Calabresi and P. Bobbitt, Tragic Choices, W.W. Norton, 1978, omit Chapter 6 and pp. 64-78.

_______________________________

Economics 488a (693a) / E&PS 202a
Susan Rose-Ackerman
Fall, 1980

QUESTIONS FOR SEPTEMBER 17

WEALTH MAXIMIZATION
vs. UTILITY MAXIMIZATION

If you need a review of public goods theory and welfare economics, read some of the material in II.A.1. (Be sure you know what Pareto Optimality means.)

The discussion will center on the reading in II.A.2. Begin with Kronman’s article and then read the (longer) article by Dworkin followed by Posner’s comments. In Dworkin, parts V and VI (pp. 205-219) are optional.

Kronman and Dworkin criticize Richard Posner’s contention that society should try to maximize wealth. Do you agree with Posner that wealth maximization is a happy compromise between utilitarianism and Pareto superiority? Why or why not?

Posner is especially concerned with using wealth maximization as a criterion in judicial decisions. Others, however, have proposed it as a criterion in other areas of economic life. Thus, macroeconomists are often concerned with maximizing GNP or National Income. Policy analysts use methods that seek to maximize the dollar value of net benefits. Criticize or defend these benefit measures in the light of Dworkin’s and Kronman’s arguments.

_______________________________

Rose-Ackerman
E&PS 202a
Fall, 1980

QUESTIONS FOR SEPT. 24

EQUALITY AND UTILITARIANISM

1)Be sure you understand Lerner’s argument on pp. 29-32. Then discuss the role of information in Lerner’s conclusion that utilitarian calculations imply the equal division of a given amount of total income among the population. How does Samuelson’s argument differ from Lerner’s?

2)Douglas Rae lists several contradictory meanings of equality. How might a conversation based on Bruce Ackerman’s three principles resolve these issues? How does Lerner resolve them? Hint: Some of Rae’s quandaries are simply assumed away by Lerner.

(a)Consider in particular Rae’s discussion of equality and value. On p. 47-49, Rae contrasts two tests:

TEST A: Is X as well off with what X gets as Y is with what Y gets?

TEST B: Is X as well off with what X gets as X would be with what Y gets? (Likewise, is Y as well off with what Y gets as he would be with what X gets?)

Suppose you had to pick one or another of these “tests.” How would you do it? How would Lerner, Ackerman and Posner do it?

You may write on either (1) or (2). If you pick (2), you may concentrate on the issues raised in (2a). Papers should be about five pages long and should be turned in before 5:00 p.m. on Tuesday, September 23. There is an envelope for the papers on my secretary’s door (Room 117, 111 Prospect).

_______________________________

Econ 488a (693a) / E&PS 202a
Rose-Ackerman
Fall, 1980

QUESTIONS FOR OCTOBER 1

You may write on any one of the questions below.

1)Should the trading or selling of votes be permitted in a direct democracy that uses majority rule to make choices? Explain your position.

2)Mueller (following Buchanan and Tullock) states that: “Were there no costs associated with the unanimity rule itself, it would obviously be the optimal rule, since it minimizes … external decision costs.” Do you agree? Why or why not?

3)Economists (to quote Musgrave) have frequently been concerned “with finding a technique by which individuals can be induced to reveal their true preferences on matters of budget policy.” When can majority rule meet Musgrave’s criterion? What else might one want voting systems to do besides reveal preferences? Might a system be “fair” even if it is not capable of providing good information to policymakers about voters’ preferences?

4)Do you agree with Gordon Tullock that majority rule leads to an oversupply of government services? Explain your answer.

5)Does “logrolling” solve the problem of voting cycles?

6)Consider the Table on p. 65 in Mueller. Should Muskie have been the 1972 Democratic Party nominee? Why or why not?

_______________________________

Econ. 488a (693a) / E&PS 202a
Rose-Ackerman
Fall, 1980

QUESTIONS FOR OCTOBER 8

1)Comment on the following assertion: Majority rule should not be used to make collective choices because of the likelihood of voting cycles.

2)Bruce Ackerman claims to have resolved the tension between democratic rule and the protection of individual rights. Has he?

You may write on either question.

_______________________________

Econ. 488a (693a) / E&PS 202a
Rose-Ackerman
Fall 1980

QUESTIONS FOR OCTOBER 15

1.Do you agree with Tideman and Tullock that demand revealing schemes “are superior to other processes” for making social choices?

2.What are the essential differences between a representative democracy and a direct democracy? Do the arguments in favor of the unanimity rule carry over to the votes of legislative representatives? What about the arguments for and against majority rule?

3.Explain why a system with three political parties has very different properties from a system with two parties. What are the special advantages (and disadvantages) of a two-party system?

READING:

In Mueller, pp. 69-71 are optional. Tideman and Tullock’s article is a fuller discussion of the demand revealing scheme discussed on pp. 72-84 in Mueller. In Part IV, read Mueller, Schumpeter and as much Downs as you can.

_______________________________

Econ. 488a (693a) / E&PS 202a
Rose-Ackerman
Fall 1980

QUESTIONS FOR OCTOBER 22

READING:

Finish Downs and read my article and the selected chapters from the corruption book (Chapter 3 is most important).

1.In Downs’ model, political parties single-mindedly seek reelection. In Rose-Ackerman’s book on corruption, politicians seek both income and reelection. In both models, however, the information available to voters and politicians is a key variable. Because voters are poorly informed, Downs concludes on p. 136 that “rational behavior by political parties tends to discourage rational behavior by voters.” Rose-Ackerman states (p. 29) that “the impact of voter ignorance on corruption is not straightforward: While sometimes it makes bribery more likely than in … idealized models …, it is also quite possible that it will lead to a less corrupt political system.” Do you agree with these conclusions? Criticize the theories as logical, consistent exercises and as tools for understanding the American political system.

2.Develop a model law regulating and/or subsidizing the campaign spending of American political candidates. Explain why you think your proposed law is desirable based on Downs, on Rose-Ackerman’s book and article and on your knowledge of American politics.

3.Will a representative democracy that uses majority rule voting in the legislature make Pareto Efficient choices? Discuss. Ignore, for now, the further problems of carrying out the laws using the government bureaucracy.

_______________________________

Susan Rose-Ackerman
Econ. 488a (693a) / E&PS 202a

QUESTIONS FOR OCTOBER 29

1.Is it rational to vote? Compare your own answer with Downs’ answer, Barry’s critique of Downs, and Benn’s alternative response. How would you answer the question posed by Benn on p. 310? “If it makes no appreciable difference to outcomes how or whether a given individual expresses his attitudes, why should he not choose some private or less exacting mode of expression, like singing political songs in the bath, or some mode that he chooses quite at random to count as expressing his attitude — slowing down, say, as he drives past the Post Office?”

2.When is it rational to make a campaign contribution or engage in a lobbying campaign designed to affect legislative outcomes? Compare Olson and Barry’s discussion of this issue. What do you think?

***

If anyone wishes to write on a question for October 22, they may do so as long as they move beyond the class discussion.

_______________________________

Econ. 488a (693a) / E&PS 202a
Rose-Ackerman
Fall 1980

QUESTIONS FOR NOVEMBER 5 AND 12

LEGISLATIVE – BUREAUCRATIC INTERACTION

READING:

November 5:Mueller, Chapter 8, pp. 148-167; Breton and Wintrobe and the two readings by Niskanen.

November 12:    Fiorina and Noll, Arnold, Mueller, pp. 167-170, and Musgrave.

On November 5, we will discuss Niskanen’s theory of the budget-maximizing bureaucrat and various critiques and extensions of this view.

On November 12, we expand the analysis of legislative-bureaucratic interactions to include Fiorina’s theory and Arnold’s empirical work. We then go on to consider the interchange between Buchanan and Brennan, on one side, and Musgrave on the other, over whether government is “too big.”

NOVEMBER 5

1)Critically assess Niskanen’s theory of bureaucracy as presented in his 1971 book. (The theory is presented in simple terms in both Mueller and Breton and Wintrobe.) Do you think that he successfully responded to the criticisms of his book in the 1975 article? In thinking about these questions, distinguish between theoretical difficulties per se and doubtful empirical claims.

2)Niskanen’s reform proposals in Chapters 17-21 seek to increase the competitive pressures on government. Criticize these proposals on distributional and efficiency grounds.

3)Niskanen’s model of a budget-maximizing bureaucrat obviously cannot apply to top officials in regulatory agencies such as the ICC or the FCC. What alternative theories appear plausible to you? Do they apply with equal force to agencies that regulate a single industry such as communications or the airlines and to agencies like the EPA and OSHA that regulate one piece of the behavior of firms in many industries?

NOVEMBER 12

1)Fiorina states that “Contrary to what is popularly believed, the bureaucrats are not the problem. Congressmen are. The Congress is the key to the Washington establishment.” Criticize this conclusion in the light of Niskanen’s and Arnold’s analyses of the link between the bureaucracy and the legislature.

2)The reading in IV.D stresses the links between the bureaucracy and the legislature. Downs, in An Economic Theory of Democracy, however, ignores the bureaucracy. How would Downs’ theory have to be modified to take account of the issues discussed by Niskanen, Fiorina and Noll, and Arnold?

3)Critically assess the debate between Buchanan-Brennan and Musgrave. What kind of evidence would be decisive? Does Buchanan and Brennan’s argument imply that a constitutional amendment should be passed to limit the size of the government budget? What might such an amendment say?

_______________________________

Rose-Ackerman
Econ. 488a (693a) / E&PS 202a
Fall, 1980

QUESTIONS FOR NOVEMBER 19

READING:

In Yandle and Miller, read two of the following chapters: 5, 8, 9, 10 or 11. Be sure to read Musgrave and Musgrave if you need to learn the basics of cost-benefit analysis. Schultze is optional although you may be interested in looking at Schultze’s assessment of cost-benefit analysis.

QUESTION:

The reports in Yandle and Miller were all prepared by economists on the staff of the Council on Wage and Price Stability. They are critiques of regulations proposed by various agencies. Choose one of the assessments (preferably chosen from 5, 8, 9, 10 or 11) and write your own critique of the Council report. In other words, suppose you are a White House staffer, trained in economics, who must advise the President on what policy to follow. You can consider economic efficiency, the distribution of costs and benefits, the quality of information available and the political feasibility of the Council’s recommendations. I, of course, realize that you only have the Council report to go on and that you, therefore, may not have information about all these issues.

_______________________________

Rose-Ackerman
Econ. 488a (693a) / E&PS 202a
Fall 1980

QUESTIONS FOR DECEMBER 3

SOCIAL WELFARE FUNCTIONS
AND HARD CHOICES:
ARROW AND CALABRESI

1)Study the proof of Arrow’s impossibility theorem in Mueller, Chapter 10. What are the implications of this result for normative theories of state action? In particular, how do cost-benefit criteria violate Arrow’s conditions?

2)Calabresi and Bobbitt discuss “tragic choices.” What is a tragic choice? Discuss ways in which Calabresi’s “paradox of first order sufficiency” leads to “inconsistent” valuation of life across different policy areas. What do you think would be the consequences of valuing life in a “consistent” way? To answer this question you have to explain what you mean by a “consistent” valuation.

3)Is there any relationship between Calabresi and Bobbitt’s analysis of “tragic” choices and Arrow’s impossibility result? In particular, consider Calabresi and Bobbitt’s “cycle strategy” (Chapter 7). Does it violate Arrow’s conditions? If it does, do you care? What do you think of this way of resolving “tragic” choices?

4)In “Values and Collective Decisionmaking” (p. 231-2) Arrow writes: “Let me conclude by suggesting one type of use of irrelevant alternatives, which may be termed ‘extended sympathy.’ We do seem prepared to make comparisons of the form: Action x is better (or worse) for me than action y is for you. This is probably in fact the standard way in which people make judgments about appropriate income distributions; if I am richer than you, I may find it easy to make the judgment that it is better for you to have the marginal dollar than for me … The principle of extended sympathy as a basis for interpersonal comparisons seems basic to many of the welfare judgments made in ordinary practice. It remains to be seen whether an adequate theory of social choice can be derived from this and other acceptable principles.” What do you think about the idea of using “extended sympathy” to make welfare judgments?

_______________________________

Rose-Ackerman
Fall 1980

FINAL EXAMINATION

THE ECONOMICS OF DEMOCRATIC POLITICS

(ECONOMICS 488a (693a) / E&PS 202a)

DUE:

24 Hours after you pick up the test. Type or write legibly.

DIRECTIONS:

Answer one question in Part I, two questions in Part II and the question in Part III. The question in Part III will be weighted more heavily than the others.

There is no specific page limit but verbosity, long summaries of the reading and platitudes will not be appreciated. You will notice that some of the questions are identical or close to some of our weekly topics. If you wrote a paper on that topic or a closely related one, you may not answer that question on this exam.

Choose questions that cover the course as broadly as possible so you do not repeat yourself. You may use course reading and class notes to help you think about the questions. Obviously, you should not talk about the exam with other students who have not yet taken it.

PART I

ANSWER ONE OF THE FOLLOWING SIX QUESTIONS:

(1)Is there,in fact, no reasonable way of collectively ranking a set of alternatives, the conclusion of Arrow’s theorem? If you agree, then how should a group faced with a collective choice problem proceed? If you disagree, describe a “reasonable” method of choice, and defend it against Arrow, Niemi and Riker, etc.

(2)Should the trading or selling of votes be permitted in a direct democracy that uses majority rule to make choices? Explain your position.

(3)Mueller (following Buchanan and Tullock) states that: “Were there no costs associated with the unanimity rule itself, it would obviously be the optimal rule, since it minimizes … external decision costs.” Do you agree? Why or why not? Do the arguments in favor of the unanimity rule carry over to the votes of legislative representatives?

(4)Economists (to quote Musgrave) have frequently been concerned “with finding a technique by which individuals can be induced to reveal their true preferences on matters of budget policy.” When can majority rule meet Musgrave’s criterion? What else might one want voting systems to do besides reveal preferences? Might a system be “fair” even if it is not capable of providing good information to policymakers about voters’ preferences?

(5)Does “logrolling” solve the problem of voting cycles? Explain.

(6)Will a representative democracy that uses majority rule voting in the legislature make Pareto Efficient choices? Ignore the further problems of carrying out the laws using the government bureaucracy.

PART II

ANSWER TWO OF THE FOLLOWING SIX QUESTIONS BUT DO NOT ANSWER BOTH 1 AND 2.

(1)Cost-benefit analysis seeks to maximize the dollar value of net benefits. What is the relationship between the cost-benefit criterion and utilitarianism? How does cost-benefit analysis violate Arrow’s conditions?

(2)Some people have suggested that cost-benefit analysts weight the benefits accruing to poor people higher than the benefits accruing to more wealthy people. What normative position is implied by this procedure? Do you think it would be a good idea to use weighted cost-benefit analysis as a way to make public choices.

(3)Do you agree with Tideman and Tullock that demand revealing schemes “are superior to other processes” for making social choices? Explain.

(4)When is it rational to make a campaign contribution or engage in a lobbying campaign designed to affect legislative outcomes? Compare Olson and Barry’s discussion of this issue. What do you think? Should the government regulate lobbying and campaign contributions?

(5)Niskanen’s model of a budget-maximizing bureaucrat obviously cannot apply to top officials in regulatory agencies such as the Interstate Commerce Commission and the Federal Communications Commission. What alternative theories appear plausible to you? Do they apply with equal force to agencies that regulate a single industry such as communications or the airlines and to agencies like the Environmental Protection Administration that regulate one piece of the behavior of firms in many industries?

(6)The reading in IV.D stresses the links between the bureaucracy and the legislature. However, in An Economic Theory of Democracy, Downs ignores the bureaucracy. How would Downs’ theory have to be modified to take account of the issues discussed by Niskanen, Fiorina and Noll, and Arnold?

PART III

EVERYONE MUST ANSWER THIS QUESTION.

This course has combined reading on normative theories of state action with positive models of how government will behave. The basic normative positions we considered are:

(1)Wealth maximization

(2)Utilitarianism

(3)Equalization of satisfaction levels

(4)Ackerman’s “Liberal State” theory

(5)Efficiency, i.e. an incomplete rule which argues only that society should be on the Pareto frontier

(6)Procedural “fairness,” e.g. the conditions underlying May’s theorem or Arrow’s conditions

(7)Calabresi and Bobbitt’s interest in supressing conflicts of values.

Suppose that one takes a realistic view of the self-interested behavior of bureaucrats, elected officials, voters, and organized interest groups (based on Part IV of the course). Now pick three normative positions taken from the above list or take two from the list and add a third which expresses your own beliefs. For each one, discuss how you would wish to organize the political-economic system so that the normative goal could be approximately achieved even though citizens and political actors are basically self-interested. If this does not seem possible, point to the weak links. My paper in Kyklos and Corruption, pp. 228-235 illustrate how one might do this for two different principles.

Source: Digitized photocopy reproduced in Economics Reading Lists, Course Outlines, Exams, Puzzles & Problems compiled by Edward Tower. Vol. 20 (July 1981): Public Choice, Political Economy, and the Economics of Public Policy & Law, pp. 98-118.
The Eno River Press Collection in Economics, compiled by Duke professor (now emeritus) Ed Tower, is the motherload of syllabi, problems sets, and exams from economics courses taught over roughly two decades at the end of the 20th century. Thanks to the initiative of Steven Medema, this material has been digitized and made available as .pdf files:  1980 (15 vols.); 1981 (25 vols.); 1990 (25 vols.); 1995 (25 vols.). There is an analogous set of volumes, likewise available in business administration.

Image Source: Joseph Christian Eyendecker (1874-1951), “Democrat and Republican”, painting at the Lucas Museum of Narrative Art, a copy was published in Saturday Evening Post, Oct. 17, 1936.

Categories
Exam Questions Harvard History of Economics Syllabus

Harvard. Reading list and semester exams. History of economics. O.H. Taylor, 1962-1963

Overton Hume Taylor (1897-1987) served as the Harvard economics department’s one-man show of PPE interdisciplinarity at both the undergraduate and graduate level for two decades covering the middle of the 20th century. He was a native of Craig, Colorado, received his B.A. at the University of Colorado in 1921 and Ph.D. from Harvard in 1928. He held the rank of instructor at Harvard 1929-1960 and ultimately promoted to professor, 1960-64. He retired from Harvard in 1964, going on to teach at Vanderbilt University for five years. He moved to live with his brother (Angus Taylor) in Kensington, California four months before dying of cancer. His wife, Edith Meyer Taylor (1905-1984), was an expert on cerebral palsy (Psychological Appraisal of Children with Cerebral Defects, 1959).

Previously posted course materials for the history of economic thought and socialism taught by Overton Hume Taylor at Harvard.

____________________________

HARVARD UNIVERSITY
Department of Economics

Professor Taylor

Economics 105
Outline
Autumn 1962

  1. Sept. 24-Oct. 5. Introductory; Political and Economic Life and Thought in the West in Classical Antiquity, the Middle Ages, and Early Modern Times.

Reading due October 5:

      1. O. H. Taylor, Philosophies and Economic Theories, in Economics and Liberalism.
      2. G. H. Sabine, A History of Political Theory, first 4 chapters.
      3. J. A. Schumpeter, History of Economic Analysis, Part II, chapters 1 and 2.
      4. Plato’s Republic, 1st 4 ‘books’, especially ‘book 2’.

Mon. Sept. 24.  Introductory lecture, about the course, and the background of Plato’s thought.

Wed. Sept. 26. Plato vs. “capitalism” and democracy.

Fri. Sept. 28. Aristotle’s philosophy, ethics, politics, and economics.

Mon. Oct. 1. Later antiquity — Stoicism and Roman Law — Christianity and Western Civilization — Medieval Europe — and Scholasticism.

Wed. Oct. 3. From medievalism to modernity; Hobbes; and Mercantilism.

Fri. Oct. 5. Discussion.

  1. Oct. 8-19. Locke; the Enlightenment; the Physiocrats; and the Psychological  — and — Ethical Theories of Shaftesbury, Hutcheson, and Adam Smith.

Reading due October 19:

      1. O. H. Taylor, 1st 3 essays in Economics and Liberalism.
      2. O. H. Taylor, 1st 3 chapters in A History of Economic Thought.
      3. J. Locke, 2nd Treatise on Civil Government, chapters 2-9 inclusive.

Mon. Oct. 8. The 17th century intellectual revolution and the 18th century enlightenment; modern science and philosophy, and rational ethics and politics; and the classical liberalism, natural law version.

Wed. Oct. 10. Locke’s philosophy, ethics, and political philosophy.

[Fri. Oct. 12. Holiday]

Mon. Oct. 15. The philosophy and economics of the Physiocrats.

Wed. Oct. 17. The psychological — and — ethical theories of Shaftesbury, Hutcheson, and Adam Smith.

Fri. Oct. 19. Discussion.

  1. Oct. 22 – Nov. 2. Adam Smith’s Economics, and Benthamism

Reading due November 2:

      1. O. H. Taylor, A History of Economic Thought, chs. 4 and 5.
      2. A. Smith, The Wealth of Nations, 1st 7 chapters.

Mon. Oct. 22. Adam Smith on national wealth and the causes of its growth.

Wed. Oct. 24. A. Smith on value, prices, and the ‘natural’ working of the free, competitive economy.

Fri. Oct. 26. A. Smith on wages and profits.

Mon. Oct. 29. Benthamism — the classical liberalism, utilitarian version.

Wed. Oct. 31. Benthamism (2).

Fri. Nov. 2. Discussion

  1. Nov. 5 – Nov. 16. Classical Economics — Malthus and Ricardo.

Reading due November 16:

      1. O. H. Taylor, A History of Economic Thought, chs. 6, 7, 8.
      2. J. M. Keynes, essay on Malthus, in [Essays in Biography, 1933]
      3. D. Ricardo, Works, ed. Sraffa, vol. 1, Principles of Economics, 1st 6 chapters.

Mon. Nov. 5. The Malthusian theory of population growth and poverty.

Wed. Nov. 7. Ricardo vs. A. Smith on value and prices.

Fri. Nov. 9. Ricardo on economic growth — wages, profits, and rents — and the stationary state.

Mon. Nov. 12. Ricardo vs. Malthus on over-saving and inadequate demand — Say’s Law of Market

Wed. Nov. 14. Ricardian — classical economics; comments.

Fri. Nov. 16. Discussion.

  1. Nov. 19-30. J. S. Mill’s Philosophy, Ethics, Politics, and Economics.

Reading due November 30:

      1. O. H. Taylor A History of Economic Thought chs. 9, 10.
      2. J. S. Mill, Utilitarianism, and On Liberty.
      3. J. S. Mill, Principles of Political Economy, Bks. I chs. 4, 5, 10, 11, 12; and Bk. II chs. 1, 2, 4, 11, 15, 16.

Mon. Nov. 19. Introductory, about Mill; and Mill’s vs. Bentham’s utilitarian ethics.

Wed. Nov. 21. Mill on liberty, and the evolution of 19th century liberalism.

Fri. Nov. 23. Mill’s economics, I; production, capital, economic growth, and the stationary state.

Mon. Nov. 26. Mill’s economics II; distribution of wealth, socialism, private property, agrarian reform, and natural – competitive wages, profits, interest, and rent.

Wed. Nov. 28. Mill’s economics III; the role of the state.

Fri. Nov. 30. Discussion.

  1. December 3- Marxism.

Reading due December 14:

      1. O. H. Taylor, A History of Economic Thought, ch. 11.
      2. J. A. Schumpeter, Capitalism, Socialism, and Democracy, Part I.
      3. P. M. Sweezy, Theory of Capitalist Development, Parts I, II except (omit) chap. 7.

Mon. Dec. 3. Introductory, about socialism, Marx, and Marxism.

Wed. Dec. 5. Hegel and Marx, philosophies of history.

Fri. Dec. 7. The Marxian economic interpretation of history, and theory of class struggles.

Mon. Dec. 10. Marxian economics I. Theory of value, wages, and “capitalist” incomes.

Wed. Dec. 12. Marxian economics II. Theory of capital accumulation and economic progress, the falling profit rate, recurrent depressions, and the growth of monopolies.

(Last few sessions before Christmas holidays left unscheduled here.  Room to “catch up”, complete discussion of Marxism.)

Reading Period Assignment

John Stuart Mill. Principles of Political Economy, Book III.

____________________________

HARVARD UNIVERSITY
Department of Economics

Economics 105
Examination
January 26, 1963

Professor O. H. Taylor

Write half-hour essays on six of the following subjects including No. 7.

  1. Adam Smith’s theory of ‘sympathy’ and ‘the moral sentiments,’ and his theory of a socially well-working economic system ruled by competition and the ‘self-interest’ of each individual.
  2. Adam Smith’s and Ricardo’s theories of economic growth.
  3. Adam Smith’s and Ricardo’s theories of value.
  4. Benthamism and classical economics — their similarities and differences, and effects on each other.
  5. Effects of the Malthusian population doctrine on the Ricardian system of economic theory.
  6. J. S. Mill’s views on the roles of (1) institutions and (2) economic ‘laws,’ in affecting the distribution of wealth.
  7. J. S. Mill’s theory of value and the pricing of products in the competitive economy.

Source: Harvard University Archives. Final Examinations—January 1963—Social Sciences (HUC 7000.28, 144 of 284).

____________________________

HARVARD UNIVERSITY
Department of Economics

Economics 120
Spring 1963

  1. February 4-15: Marxism

Reading due February 15:

      1. O.H. Taylor, A History of Economic Thought, Chapter 11
      2. Marx and Engels, The Communist Manifesto
      3. J.A. Schumpeter, Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy, Part I.
      4. P.M. Sweezy, The Theory of Capitalist Development, Parts I, II.

Monday, February 4- Introductory Lecture

Wednesday, February 6- “Utopian” Socialism, early 19th c.  Europe, and Marx

Friday, February 8- Hegel and Marx and Marx’s “sociology” of history

Monday, February 11- Marx’s Economics I.

Wednesday, February 13- Marx’s Economics II.

Friday, February 15- Discussion.

  1. February 18-March 1: Victorian Conservative Liberalism and Neo-Classical Economics

Reading due March 1:

      1. O.H. Taylor, A History of Economic Thought, Chapter 12
      2. E. von Böhm-Bawerk, Positive Theory of Capital, Books III, IV
      3. T.N. Carver, Distribution of Wealth, Chapters 2,3,4

Monday, February 18- Introductory Lecture

Wednesday, February 20- “Marginal Utility,” costs and value; the “marginalists” vs Ricardo on value

[Friday, February 22-Holiday]

Monday, February 25- “Marginal productivity” and income distribution; wages; capital and interest

Wednesday, February 27- Marginal Productivity and incomes continued; rent and business profits

Friday, March 1- Discussion

  1. March 4-15:  Marshall

Reading due March 15

      1. O.H. Taylor, A History of Economic Thought, Chapter 13
      2. H.D. Henderson, Supply and Demand, first 5 chapters or
      3. A. Marshall, Principles of Economics, 8th edition, Books III, IV, Chapters 9-13, and V, Chapters 1-5

Monday, March 4- Marshall, Ricardo, and the “revolution”

Wednesday, March 6- Marshall on the law of demand and laws of returns, costs and supply–under competition

Friday, March 8- Marshall on price determination in the short, intermediate and long-run

Monday, March 11- Marshall on competition and monopoly

Wednesday, March 13- Marshall on income distribution

Friday, March 15- Discussion

  1. March 18-29: Democratic Socialism, Communism and Fascism; and Modern U.S. Liberalism and Conservatism

Reading due March 29

      1. O.H. Taylor, A History of Economic Thought, Chapters 14, 15.
      2. — — — —, Economics and Liberalism, Introduction and essays #1-4 incl., 7,9
      3. G.B. Shaw, The Fabian Essays
      4. Crossman and others, New Fabian Essays

Monday, March 18- Western Socialism’s turn away from Marxist Orthodoxy; the Fabians and British Socialism

Wednesday, March 20- From Marxist Orthodoxy continued; European “revisionism”

Friday, March 22- Czarist Russia, Lenin, and Modern Communism

Monday, March 25- Fascism

Wednesday, March 27- The U.S. in and since the 1930’s — Liberalism and Conservatism

Friday, March 29- Discussion

SPRING VACATION

  1. April 8-19: Monopoly and Competition in the Modern Economy

Reading due April 19

      1. O.H. Taylor, A History of Economic Thought, Chapter 16
      2. E.H. Chamberlin, Theory of Monopolistic Competition, first 5 chapters

Monday, April 8- Competition and Monopoly in the Economy and the Public Interest; the Traditional Views and the New, Modern Analysis

Wednesday, April 10- Product Differentiation and Competing Monopolies

Friday, April 12- Oligopoly

Monday, April 15- Large-scale Organizations, Individual Freedom, Public Control and the Common Welfare

Wednesday, April 17- Discussion

[Friday, April 19, Holiday]

  1. April 22-May 3: Keynesian Economics

Reading due May 3

      1. O.H. Taylor, A History of Economic Thought, Chapter 17
      2. S.E. Harris, The New Economics, Part III.

Source: Harvard University Archives. Syllabi, course outlines and reading lists in Economics, 1895-2003. Box 8, Folder “Economics 1962-63 (1 of 2)”.

Reading Period Assignment

David McCord Wright. Democracy and Progress, 1943.
or
John Maurice Clark. Alternative to Serfdom, 1947 (revised, 1960).

____________________________

HARVARD UNIVERSITY
Department of Economics

Economics 120
FINAL EXAM
 June 1, 1963

Write half-hour essays on six questions including No. 7

  1. State incisively, as parts of Marx’s theory of the functioning and development of capitalism, his economic theories on the following topics:value, wages, surplus value, accumulation and concentration of capital, the changing organic composition of capital, and the falling profit rate; and then more fully explain and discuss his theory or theories on one or two of those topics.
  2. Explain and discuss either the marginal utility theory of the pricing of products, or the marginal productivity theory of the pricing of the productive services of labor and of capital, in a competitive economy.
  3. Explain and discuss Marshall’s theory of the long-run normal or equilibrium price of a product produced by a competitive industry, under conditions of decreasing cost with growth of the industry and its market.
  4. Compare and discuss “the classical liberalism” and present day American “liberalism”, with equal attention to their points of agreement and of disagreement.
  5. Explain and discuss (1) the required conditions for the existence of an economic system of ‘pure’ competition, and the sense and way in which such a system, if it could and did exist, would best serve the economic welfare of society as a whole; and (2) how ‘product differentiation’ leads to a system of ‘monopolistic competition’ or ‘competing monopolies’; and the defects and merits of this system, for the economic welfare of society.
  6. Explain and discuss the ideas of ‘Keynesian theory’ on the following points:how growth of the peoples’ incomes affects consumption and saving; how growth of the economy’s stock of capital, through new investments, affects the profitability of further new investments; why and how total demand may become insufficient to sustain ‘full employment’, in an ‘affluent’ society; and how the government should use ‘fiscal policy’ to maintain ‘full employment’?
  7. Write out the principal comments that you want to make on Wright’s Democracy and Progress, or on Clark’s Alternative to Serfdom.

Source: Harvard University Archives. Final Examinations—June 1963—Social Sciences (HUC 7000.28, 147 of 284).

____________________________

Other posts with course material
on the history of economics
taught by Overton Hume Taylor at Harvard

Final exams for “Modern Economic Theory and its Critics”. O.H. Taylor, 1938-39 https://www.irwincollier.com/harvard-final-exams-for-modern-economic-theory-and-its-critics-o-h-taylor-1938-39/

O.H. Taylor’s undergraduate course, Intellectual Background of Economic Thought, 1941 https://www.irwincollier.com/2106-2/

O.H. Taylor’s Final Exam for Intellectual Background of Economic Thought, 1941 https://www.irwincollier.com/harvard-o-h-taylors-final-exam-for-intellectual-background-of-economic-thought-1941/

Outline and final exam. Economic and Political Ideas, Taylor. 2nd term, 1947-48 https://www.irwincollier.com/harvard-outline-and-final-exam-economic-and-political-ideas-taylor-2nd-term-1947-48/

Economic and Political Ideas. O. H. Taylor, 1948 https://www.irwincollier.com/taylor-economic-and-political-ideas-harvard-1948/

Half-year exam for O.H. Taylor’s Economics and Political Ideas, 1949 https://www.irwincollier.com/harvard-half-year-exam-o-h-taylors-economics-political-ideas-1949/

Graduate history of political economy course. Taylor, 1948-49 https://www.irwincollier.com/harvard-graduate-history-of-political-economy-course-taylor-1948-49/

Economics of Socialism. Overton Taylor et al., 1950 Harvard. Economics of Socialism. Overton Taylor et al., 1950

Economics of Socialism, Syllabus and Final Exam. O.H. Taylor, 1953 Harvard. Economics of Socialism, Syllabus and Final Exam. O.H. Taylor, 1953

History of Economics. First semester readings and exams. O. H. Taylor, 1955-56 https://www.irwincollier.com/harvard-history-of-economics-first-semester-readings-and-exams-o-h-taylor-1955-56/

Harvard. Undergraduate economics syllabus. Socialism, O.H. Taylor, 1955 Harvard. Undergraduate economics syllabus. Socialism, O.H. Taylor, 1955

Categories
Economic History Exam Questions Harvard

Harvard. European Economic History up to mid-18th Century. Enrollment, exams. Gray, 1912-1913

This post completes the collection of course descriptions, enrollments, and final exams for Harvard economics courses from the 1912-13 academic year with an advanced course in economic history. The course was attended by four Harvard male graduate students and one Radcliffe woman (presumably also a graduate student) and covered European economic life from mediaeval times to the Industrial Revolution.

_______________________

Howard Levi Gray

1874. Born July 11 in Starkesville, New York
1897. A.B. University of Rochester
1898. A.B. Harvard.
1900. A.M. Harvard.
1907. Ph.D. in History, Harvard
1909-14. Instructor in History, Harvard
1911-12. Instructor in Economics, Harvard
1914-15. Assistant Professor of History and Tutor.
1915-1940. Professor of History, Bryn Mawr College
1940. Retired from Bryn Mawr College
1945. Died September 14 at Canajoharie, New York.

__________________________

Earlier Harvard courses
on European economic history

Links to earlier course material for European Economic History from Harvard, 1883-84 through 1912-13.

_______________________

ECONOMICS 23
Course Description
1912-13

[Economics] 23 (formerly 11). Economic History of Europe to 1760. Tu., Th., Sat., at 10. Dr. Gray.

As is implied by its scope, this course purposes to give a general survey of each aspect of European economic life from mediaeval times to the Industrial Revolution. Such subjects will be studied as the results of the Crusades, the effects of the Black Death, the development of the Hanseatic League, the causes of sixteenth century revolts in England and Germany, the domestic and mercantilist systems. Instruction will be by lectures and discussion. One thesis will be required.

Source: Harvard University. Division of History, Government, and Economics, Courses of Instruction, 1912–13, p. 66.

_______________________

ECONOMICS 23
Course Enrollment
1912-13

[Economics] 23 (formerly 11) Dr. Gray. — Economic History of Europe to the Middle of the Eighteenth Century.

Total 5: 4 Graduates; 1 Radcliffe.

Source: Harvard University. Reports of the President and the Treasurer of Harvard College, 1912-13, p. 58.

_______________________

ECONOMICS 23
Mid-year Examination
1912-13

  1. Write briefly on eight of the following subjects: town economy; Charters of St. Gall; inscription of Henchir Mettich; bucellarii; polyptique de l’abbé Irminon; opera antumpnalia; cnihts’ gild; the hearth tax of 1328; distribution of wealth at Basel in the fifteenth century; ad fiscum id est ad feodum.
  2. (One Hour.) Discuss the rise of the mediaeval manor in France, in Germany, and in England. Estimate the value of sources and secondary works which relate to this subject.
  3. State and criticise the various theories regarding the origin of mediaeval towns.
  4. Sketch the development and organization of the woolen industry in England to the sixteenth century.

Source: Harvard University. Mid-year examinations, 1852-1943. Box 9, bound volume Examination Papers, Mid-Years 1912-13.

_______________________

ECONOMICS 23
Year-end Examination
1912-13

  1. Discuss the origin and early expansion of capital in Italy, the Low Countries, Germany and England. (One hour.)
  2. Compare the development of copyhold in England with that of Meierrecht in Germany. In what way were agrarian conditions in southwestern Germany different from conditions in the northwest at the beginning of the sixteenth century.
  3. Trace the growth of the mercantile system in England. Has Cunningham’s treatment any bias? Explain.
  4. Describe fully four of the following documents: —

Notularium Johannis Scribae.
An English Pipe Roll.
Royal licenses to export English wool in 1273.
De institutis Lundonie.
Chrysobullium Alexii I.

Source: Harvard University Examinations. Papers set for final examinations in history, history of science, government, economics, philosophy, social ethics, education, fine arts, music in Harvard College (June 1913), p. 55.

Image Source: Page from the Polyptyque d’Irminon linked by Wikimedia Commons to the Gallica website of the Bibliotheque nationale de France.

 

________________________

Links to earlier course material for
European Economic History.
Harvard 1883-84 through 1911-12

Economics 4
Economic History of Europe and America
since the Seven Years’ War.

1883-84. C.F. Dunbar
1884-85. C.F. Dunbar
1885-86. C.F. Dunbar
1886-87. C.F. Dunbar
1887-88. C.F. Dunbar
1888-89. J.H. Gray
1889-90. A.C. Miller
1890-91. C.F. Dunbar
1891-92. W.M. Cole
1892-93. W.M. Cole

Economics 6a
European Industry and Commerce
in the Nineteenth Century

1906-07. E.F. Gay
1907-08. E.F. Gay
1908-09. E.F. Gay
1909-10. E.F. Gay assisted by H.L. Gray
1910-11. E.F. Gay with J. Klein. Reading list included.
1911-12. E.F. Gay with J. Klein

Economics 8

1898-99. Western Civilization, mediaeval and modern, in its Economic Aspects [W. Cunningham, Reading List]

Economics 10
Elements of Economic History
from the Middle Ages to Modern Times

1893-94. W.J. Ashley
1894-95. W.J. Ashley

Economics 13
Development of Land Tenures
and of Agrarian Conditions in Europe.

1893-94. W.J. Ashley

Economics 10
Mediaeval Economic History of Europe

1895-96. W.J. Ashley
1902-03. E.F. Gay
1900-01. W.J. Ashley
1903-04. not offered
1904-05. E.F. Gay
1905-06. E.F. Gay
1906-07. not offered
1907-08. not offered
1908-09. not offered
1909-10. H.L. Gray

Economics 11
Modern Economic History of Europe and America.

1896-97. Modern Economic History of Europe and America,W.J. Ashley
1897-98. Modern Economic History of Europe and America, W.J. Ashley
1898-99. Industrial Revolution in England, W. Cunningham

Economics 11
Modern Economic History of Europe

1899-1900. W.J. Ashley, Reading List
1902-03. E.F. Gay
1903-04. E.F. Gay
1904-05. E.F. Gay
1905-06. E.F. Gay
1906-07. E.F. Gay
1907-08.. E.F. Gay
1908-09. not offered
1909-10. E.F. Gay
1910-11. E.F. Gay
1911-12. Advanced Modern European Economic History. E.F. Gay

 

 

Categories
Exam Questions Harvard Policy Problem Sets Public Finance Suggested Reading Syllabus

Harvard. Economic Principles and Public Policy. Syllabus, readings, questions. Schelling, 1981

In my opinion Thomas C. Schelling (1921-2016) has achieved something greater than the Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel (2005). The history of economics will remember him as the very model of a modern thinking economist’s economist.

The earlier post for the reading list and final exams from his 1970 Harvard course “Conflict, Coalition and Strategy” has been viewed nearly 19,000 times, making it the highest single post in the eleven year history of Economics in the Rear-view Mirror.

The purpose of today’s post is to provide a digital, transcribed version of Schelling’s 1981 course materials for “Economic Principles and Public Policy” assembled from a PDF file of the scanned copy of this material compiled and published by Ed Tower in his Eno River Press Collection in Economics. In this form, it will be even easier to access, search, copy, and paste from. 

_________________________

Where to Find the Motherload

The Eno River Press Collection in Economics, compiled by Duke professor (now emeritus) Ed Tower, is the motherload of syllabi, problems sets, and exams from economics courses taught over roughly two decades at the end of the 20th century. Thanks to the initiative of Steven Medema, this material has been digitized and made available as .pdf files:  1980 (15 vols.); 1981 (25 vols.); 1990 (25 vols.); 1995 (25 vols.). There is an analogous set of volumes, likewise available in business administration.

Professor Ed Tower came to Duke in 1974. He received his Ph.D. in Economics from Harvard in 1971. He has held appointments at the Australian National University, the University of Auckland in New Zealand, the Economics Institute, the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University, the Helsinki School of Economics and Business Administration, Nanjing University in the Peoples’ Republic of China, and Simon Fraser University in Canada. He has also consulted on economic development problems at the World Bank and the U.S. Agency for International Development, and in Indonesia, Kenya, Malawi, and Sudan, and has written on development problems in Malaysia, the Peoples’ Republic of China, and Taiwan.
Source: Duke Economics Department, WWW Resource.

_________________________

Undergraduate Course

HARVARD UNIVERSITY
Economic Principles and Public Policy
Economics 1021
Spring 1981

T. C. Schelling

Course Outline and Reading Assignments

All readings listed are assigned; none are optional.

Books Required to Purchase:

Robert H. Haveman and Julius Margolis, Public Expenditure and Policy Analysis, second ed. (paperback), Rand McNally, 1977.

Robert Dorfman and Nancy Dorfman, Economics of the Environment, second ed., W.W. Norton and Company, 1977.

Richard Goode, The Individual Income Tax, revised ed. (paperback), The Brookings Institution, 1976.

Charles L. Schultze, The Public Use of Private Interest,
The Brookings Institution, 1977.

Arthur M. Okun, Equality and Efficiency, The Brookings
Institution, 1975.

T.C. Schelling, Micromotives and Macrobehavior, W.W. Norton and Company, 1978.

Harold M. Hochman, The Urban Economy, W.W. Norton and Company, 1976.

Book Required to Obtain:

Your Income Tax, Publication 17, Internal Revenue Service,
not for sale.

Note: The class meets in lecture 13 times before Spring Recess. Reading assignments for the 8 meetings after Spring Recess will be distributed later.  Sections will meet each week except the first week and the week before Spring Recess.

_________________________

Outline and Readings
Pages Meetings
I. Lives and Decisions 136
(Cumul-ative totals in parentheses)
3
  1. Chase, Samuel B., (ed.), Problems in Public Expenditure Analysis, The Brookings Institution, 1968, pp. 127-176.
  2. Vaupel, James W. and John D. Graham, “Egg in Your Bier?”, The Public Interest, No. 58, Winter 1980, pp. 3-17.
  3. Zeckhauser, Richard, “Procedures for Valuing Lives,” Public Policy, Fall 1975, pp. 419-464.
  4. Lave, Lester B. and Eugene P. Seskin, “Air Pollution and Human Health,” in Robert Dorfman and Nancy S. Dorfman, Economics of the Environment, 2nd ed., W.W. Norton & Co., pp. 422-449.
II. Policy: Why Things May Not Take Care of Themselves 177 (313) 2 (5)
  1. Haveman, Robert H. and Julius Margolis, Public Expenditure and Policy Analysis, 2nd ed., 1977, Introduction, pp. 1-24.
  2. Davis, Otto A. and Morton I. Kamien, “Externalities, Information and Alternative Collective Action,” H and M, pp. 82-104.
  3. Schelling, T.C., Micromotives and Macrobehavior, W.W. Norton & Co., 1978.

Ch. 1, “Micromotives and Macrobehavior,” 9-43.
Ch. 3, “Thermostats, Lemons, and Other Families of Models,” 83-133.
Ch. 4, “Sorting and Mixing:  Race and Sex,” 137-155.
Ch. 6, “Choosing Our Children’s Genes,” 193-203.

  1. Steiner, Peter O., “The Public Sector and the Public Interest,” in H and M, pp. 27-40.
III. Examples of Market Failure 214 (527) 2 (7)
The Environment

  1. Ruff, Larry E., “The Economic Common Sense of Pollution,” in D and D, pp. 41-58.
  2. Dales, J.H., “The Property Interface,” in D and D, pp. 172-186.
  3. Dales, J.H., “Land, Water, and Ownership,”in D and D, pp. 229-244.
  4. Mishan, E.J., “Property Rights and AmenityRights,” in D and D, pp. 245-251.
  5. Schelling, T.C., “Prices as Regulatory Instruments for Environmental Protection,”JFK School of Government, December 1980.
  6. Goldman, Marshall I., “The Convergence ofEnvironmental Disruption,” in D and D, pp. 312-325.

The City

  1. Baumol, W.J. & Wallace E. Oates, “The CostDisease of the Personal Services and the Quality of Life,” pp. 57-73, in The Urban Economy by Harold M. Hochman, W.W. Norton and Co., 1976.
  2. Thompson, Wilbur, “The City as a DistortedPrice System,” pp. 74-86, in The Urban Economy.
  3. Alonso, William, “Urban Zero Population Growth,” pp. 164-179 in The Urban Economy.
IV. Helping People 118 (645) 3 (10)
The Conflict Between Equity and Incentives

  1. Tobin, James, “The Case for an Income Guarantee,” The Public Interest, Summer 1966, pp. 31-41.
  2. Schorr, Alvin L., “Against a Negative Income Tax,” and James Tobin, “A Rejoinder,” The Public Interest, Fall 1966, pp. 110-119.
  3. Weisbrod, Burton A., “Collective Action andthe Distribution of Income:  A Conceptual Approach,” in H & M, pp. 105-131.
  4. Products Liability:  Bexiga vs. Havir Mfg.Corp., Harvard Law Review, Vol. 86 (March1973), pp. 923-931.
  5. Implications of Guaranteeing Medical Care,Institute of Medicine, 1975, Schelling et al., pp. 23-37, 39-44, 53-57.

Cash, Kind, or Rationing

  1. Tobin, James, “On Limiting the Domain of Inequality,” The Journal of Law and Economics, Vol. 13 (October 1970), pp. 263-277.
  2. Thurow, Lester C., “Cash Versus In-Kind Transfers,” American Economic Review, Papers and Proceedings, May 1974, pp. 190-195.
  3. Frieden, Bernard J., “Housing Allowances:  An Experiment That Worked,” The Public Interest, No. 59, Spring 1980, pp. 15-35.
V. Case Study: Day Care 68 (713) 0 (10)
  1. Nelson, Richard R., The Moon and The Ghetto, W.W. Norton and Co., 1977, pp. 83-103.
  2. Rivlin, Alice, “Federal Support for Child Care:  An Analysis of Options,” in H & M, pp. 442-475.
  3. Bruce-Briggs, B., “‘Child Care,’ The FiscalTime Bomb,” The Public Interest, #49, Fall 1977, pp. 87-102.
VI. Review Questions 0 (713) 1 (11)
Spring 1981
Course Plan

WEEK OF

SECTION

2/2

No sections

2/9

Problem: Right Turn on Red

2/16
[Washington’s B-Day]

Quiz

2/23

Hour Exam:
Lives, Policy, Environment, City

3/2

Problem: Moral Hazard

3/9

Quiz

3/16

15 Questions Due

3/23

****** RECESS ******

3/30

Hour Exam:
Helping People, Cash v Kind, Day Care, Crime, Energy

4/6

Problem: Tax

4/13

Quiz: Tax

4/20

Quiz: Tax

4/26

****** READING PERIOD ******

Source:  Economics Reading Lists, Course Outlines, Exams, Puzzles & Problems compiled by Edward Tower. Vol. 20 (July 1981): Public Choice, Political Economy, and the Economics of Public Policy & Law, pp. 133-137.

_________________________

ECONOMIC PRINCIPLES
AND PUBLIC POLICY

M-228 & ECONOMICS 1021
Spring 1981

T. C. Schelling
Harvard University

The Income Tax

            These questions are prompted by a reading of the Form 1040. Some of the questions will be discussed in class, some are for your reflection and study. The purpose is to alert you to the kinds of questions and issues that almost any line in the tax form can raise. Several hours can be devoted to the economic philosophy underlying income taxes, discerning intention, recognizing administrative com-promise, analyzing incentives, and evaluating the income tax as an instrument to achieve a variety of goals. It need not be viewed as a coherent philosophy or a set of integrated and compatible purposes; searching for inconsistencies or obsolete details, and reflecting on historical processes and political compromises, are part of the exercise.

Page 1 of Form 1040

  1. Why “income rather than “wealth?”
    What difference does it make whether income or wealth is the subject of the tax?
  2. Why is the calendar year the unit of accounting?
    What provisions modify this annual slicing?
    What would be an ideal accounting period, or is there one?
    What incentives result from slicing time into annual units?
  3. Should a married couple be treated as a single unit, as two persons, or allowed some choice in how to file?
    Do you perceive any incentives on marriage and divorce?
  4. What reason can you think of for the extra exemption for the blind, not for the deaf or the crippled?
    Why might blindness be exactly equivalent to one dependent?
    Should blindness be treated as an exemption or a tax credit?
    What are the differences between this kind of help for the blind and cash grants not related to income?
  5. Should the allowance for a dependent be a constant amount of income, irrespective of bracket? Should it instead be graduated, so that the differential between a large and small family at high income is greater than the differential at a lower income? Should it be a tax credit rather than an exemption?
  6. Is there an implied philosophy about family, children, and birth, in this treatment of dependents? Does it imply that children are:

1) a consumer good,
2) an insurable accident,
3) a productive asset,
4) a social obligation?

Are there incentives on family size or timing due to this treatment of dependents?

  1. What is the argument for including capital gains as a kind of income? Alternatively, what is the argument for not treating them the same as income?
    Why distinguish long-term from short-term? Is this an anti-gambling or anti-speculation bias? Is it expected or intended to have incentives on the holding of securities?
    Why are only “realized” gains taxed, so that if your stock or property rises in value you pay no tax unless you sell it?
    What are the incentives: do people get “locked in” to property holdings that have risen in value, having to hold it rather than exchange it for other stock and property?
    Why is a special exemption made for the sale of one’s own house?
  2. Should gambling gains and losses be treated like any other income?
    Should they be ignored altogether and left untaxed?
    Does the treatment discriminate against “pure” gambling but not against gambling on the commodity or stock market?
    Is this treatment consistent with the increasing popularity of state lotteries, off-track and on-track betting, etc.?
    What effect will the treatment of gambling gains and losses have on the ability of legal gambling to compete with illegal gambling?
  3. Can you guess what kinds of “employee business expenses” a typical university professor will take credit for on his tax return? Do you expect any incentives, such as the likelihood of having better office equipment, more telephone extensions, better personal libraries, if they are tax-deductible?

Schedule A

  1. Itemized deductions: Is there a single rationale for the items deductible? Is it:
      1. to get at a better accounting of income
      2. to encourage expenses of the kinds that have been made deductible.
      3. to compensate for special hardships and obligations;
      4. or what?
  2. Why is medical care somewhat deductible?
    How does treatment of medical care discriminate between the poor and the well-to-do?
    Could you estimate the “cost” to the Internal Revenue Service (or to other taxpayers if they would have to make it up in higher tax rates) of this treatment of medical care?
    If you could redistribute an equivalent amount, to compensate people for an injury and illness and disability, would you rather distribute it in a manner unrelated to income or income taxes?
    Can you find a plausible explanation of the quantitative treatment of medical care: e.g., 1/2 of insurance premiums; excess over 3% of income; subtracting out 18 in line 3; etc.
  3. How would you prefer to treat funeral expenses? Should sanitary or tasteful disposal of a dead body be treated as a terminal medical expense? Can you think of good reasons for the actual treatment of this item?
  4. What contributions are tax-deductible, and why?
    Is this equivalent to a subsidy of churches by the federal government?
    Is the object to stimulate contributions?
    Is this a useful way to decentralize federal subsidies, by a system of “matching grants” to anybody who wants to support his favorite charity?
    Who has more leverage in determining where the IRS makes its contributions, a poor or a rich person?
  5. What do you think are the most questionable “contributions,” the ones about which it is hard to decide whether they are within the spirit of the income tax?
    Is it a “contribution” if I make a sizable gift to a private school in hopes that they will give priority admissions to my children?
    Can I unload a library that I’ve grown tired of, and treat it as a cash “gift” to the University?
    Suppose I make the gift and the recipient throws it away?
    Suppose I make a “gift” to a nursing home that is really a disguised bill for the care of an aged relative, but the nursing home winks and lets me “pay” the bill in a tax-deductible way?
  6. Why should the interest you pay be deductible? (Interest you receive is taxable.) Does this put a distortion in the incentive structure–regarding, say, mortgaged homes vs. outright ownership–or does it eliminate a distortion?
  7. Is the treatment of “casualty losses” equivalent to insurance handled by the Treasury?
    Does it discriminate in favor of the rich, the poor, the property-less, or the property owners?
    Could the treatment of casualty losses have any influence on the insurance that people purchase?
    If I smash my car and somebody else’s, and he sues me for damage and I pay, should both parts of the loss be deductible, or only the damage to my own car?
  8. Why allow deductions for taxes paid to state and local government but not other federal taxes?

General Questions

  1. It has been argued that employees of the federal government ought not to pay income tax: they are simply returning part of their salary. If they were exempted from tax we could lower their pay to the “after taxes” level, saving them the trouble of making out returns and the IRS the trouble of processing them. Do you see objections to that procedure?
    Do your objections apply equally to state taxation of incomes earned in state employment?
  2. Children who are eighteen or younger count as dependents, no matter how much income they had. Should we reexamine this age, as voting ages, draft ages, and ages over which juvenile courts have jurisdiction change as the years go by, and with the increasing independence of teenage “dependents?”
    A child with income abruptly ceases to be a dependent at age nineteen. Would there be advantage in having dependency taper off gradually?
  3. In earlier years, military combat pay was excluded from taxable income.
    Why would the federal government prefer to do it that way rather than with an outright pay increase?
    It has recently been proposed to exempt all military pay from federal taxation. What are the reasons for and against?
  4. If you and your employer both pay a percentage of your salary into a retirement fund, should your part not be treated as income and subject to taxation? Should his?
    If the retirement fund invests it, should the accrual of interest and dividends to your retirement account be currently taxable?
    How much flexibility should the IRS allow you in putting part of your income into a retirement fund, temporarily beyond reach of the income tax?
    Suppose your retirement fund permits you to withdraw from it in an emergency? Does that make it just an investment fund to escape the income tax?
    Suppose you cannot withdraw it but you can borrow against it.
    Is it only a pretense that it is still there and you have not drawn it down to spend it?
    What general purpose do you see in permitting contributions to a retirement account to evade immediate taxation, but not any other form of saving that is invested for the sake of deferred consumption? Is this just another subsidy for incentives, or is there some logical reason to exempt this contribution, as being not “earned” until one is legally able to draw on it after retirement?
  5. Consider some income that is not subject to tax–either legally immune, or just practically uncollectible (evasion being easy and people willing to evade in the belief that others do).
    Specifically, tips to waiters and waitresses. who do you think benefits from untaxed tips?
    What do you think the effect is on waiters’ wages and the prices of restaurant meals? Does your answer depend on the income earned by waiters?
    Think of some untaxed fee or salary supplement in a high income bracket, and answer the same question–e.g., untaxed fees of abortionists when abortion was illegal.
    Can you make any general proposition about who benefits to what extent when any identifiable kind of income goes untaxed, either because it is legally exempt or because the tax is regularly evaded?

Beneficiaries and Incentives

  1. Select some disadvantaged or underpriviledged group that you would like to help with extra income at government expense.
    1. What is the best device you can think of that might be incorporated in the income tax to serve that purpose?
    2. Compare that income-tax measure with the best alternative measure (not involving the income tax) that would serve the same purpose.
    3. How much of the tax benefit (i.e. the tax loss to the government) is likely to go to the people whom you did not especially wish to receive the benefit? How serious an inefficiency is that?
    4. How many of the people you would like to help are not reached by your proposed tax measure, and how serious is that inefficiency?
  2. Select an activity that you would like to stimulate at government expense.
    1. What is the best device you can think of that might be incorporated in the income tax to serve that purpose?
    2. Compare that income-tax measure with the best alternative measure (not involving the income tax) that would serve the same purpose.
    3. How much of the tax benefit is likely to go to taxpayers whose activity is unaffected by your income-tax measure?
    4. How would you estimate the amount of the desired activity (measured perhaps in the increase in taxpayer expenditure on it) induced per dollar of lost tax revenue?
  3. Discuss the incentives in the income tax that affect the following. Indicate the direction in which they affect it, the likely magnitude of the effect, and the desirability of the incentive effect:
    1. owning a home, or renting;
    2. doing work around the house rather than hiring it done;
    3. diverting wages and salaries into institutionalized retirement arrangements;
    4. choosing among savings accounts, bonds, stocks, and real estate;
    5. purchasing collision-damage auto insurance;
    6. having another child;
    7. housewives taking full-time jobs and getting sitters, housekeepers, cleaning help, etc., to take care at home;
    8. choosing one’s occupation.
  4. What in the income tax do you think affects the way Harvard University is administered? (For example, the health service, retirement arrangements, providing expenses rather than income to faculty, granting scholarships).
  5. Income Tax Work Incentives
    It has been argued that an income tax induces people to work less because it reduces their net hourly compensation. A person who can do extra work at $7.50 per hour may not do it if he keeps only $5.
    It has also been argued that an income tax induces people to work more because it lowers their net income for any amount of work they do; to maintain desired standards of living the income tax leaves them no choice but to work more.
    How would you resolve the dispute, either choosing one of these two points of view, denying them both, or finding some reconciliation between these two opposing arguments?
  6. Taxes and the Ability to Pay
    It has been argued that the income tax is unique among taxes in discriminating according to “ability to pay.” why, then, should there be additional taxes unrelated to the ability to pay? There are other taxes and they add up to as much as the income tax. Of course, in politics nobody’s perfect, and we needn’t be surprised that “ability to pay” is honored and violated at the same time. Still, there may be good reasons why an income tax is not or cannot be relied on as the sole source of revenue.
      1. How successfully does it tax people on their “ability to pay?”
      2. Give some good reasons for not expecting the income tax to be able to serve as the unique, universal, all-purpose tax.
    1. Child Dependency Allowance
      The present income tax allowance for children is that $1000 per child can be deducted from income before calculating the tax. In taxes saved, a child is worth more in a high-tax bracket than in a low bracket. On the other hand, the expenses attributable to an extra child for a family with an income of $15,000 is probably much closer to the $1000 allowance than are the expenditures attributable to an extra child in a family of similar size with an income of $60,000.
      It can be argued that the difference between no children and three children at a family income of $60,000 is far greater than the $1000 per child allowed as untaxable income, and that it makes sense to enlarge that allowance at higher incomes.
      It can also be argued that raising the allowance at higher incomes will reduce the progressivity of the tax, allowing just another benefit to wealthier families while poorer families would get no such relief.

      1. Explain how you would choose between these two points of view, or reconcile them, in recommending how to handle children in the income tax.
      2. would your answer to (a) be any different if the dependency allowance were a tax credit rather than a deduction from income?
  1. A tax is called “progressive” if the amount paid rises more than proportionally to income, “regressive” if less, and “proportional” if the ratio of tax to income is uniform. The word “progressive” also suggests “fair” or “liberal” and “progressive income tax” tends to have both meanings. with either meaning it is sometimes hard to determine which among two or more tax schedules, or changes in a tax schedule, or more or less “progressive,” or exactly what change in rates should be characterized as preserving the same progressivity.
    Below are six income-tax schedules.
    Indicate how you would go about ranking them, or comparing them, in their “progressivity.”
    Would you need to know something about the underlying distribution of income to make the comparison?
    If so, explain.
Income Bracket $000 Percentage rate on income in bracket
A B C D E F
0 – 6 0 0 0 0 0 17
6 – 12 15 10 10 0 0 29
12 – 24 20 15 13 30 5 27
24 – 48 30 25 20 30 31 45
48 – 100 50 45 33 60 45 58
100 – 200 75 70 50 70 73 79

Compared with Schedule A:

Do one or more of the schedules raise or lower all taxes in the same proportion? Which ones?

Do one or more raise or lower all taxes by the same proportion of income? Which ones?

Do one or more raise or lower all income after taxes in the same proportion? Which ones?

Does one or more of them have the same progressivity as A?

Do any two of them have the same progressivity as each other?

Among them all, including A, which is least progressive and which most, and how do you rank the others?

NOTE: Because the rates go stepwise, any change will affect somewhat differently people at different points within a bracket. I suggest you make the comparisons at the bracket limits, i.e. at $6, $12, $24, $48, $100, and $200.

Source: “The Income Tax”. Photocopy reproduced in Economics Reading Lists, Course Outlines, Exams, Puzzles & Problems compiled by Edward Tower. Vol. 12 (July 1981): Public Finance Exams, Puzzles & Problems, pp. 9-17.

_________________________

T. C. Schelling/Harvard University
ECONOMIC PRINCIPLES
AND PUBLIC POLICY
Spring 1981

Ec. 1021
M- 228
EXAM QUESTIONS FROM EARLIER YEARS
  1. Proposed Policies for Evaluation
  2. Swine Flu Vaccination
  3. 55-Mile Speed Limit
  4. Worth of Saving Lives
  5. Crime Rates and Police Coverage
  6. Fire Protection
  7. Smoking in Class
  8. Saturday Sections
  9. Apartment House Heating
  10. Deposit on Cans and Bottles
  11. Smoking in Class: Another Room
  12. Library Air Conditioning
  13. State-University Tuition
  14. Nursery Schools
  15. Youth Fare
  16. Welfare and Work Incentives
  17. Dining Hall Problem
  18. University Parking
  19. Vouchers, Goods- (services)-in-Kind, or Cash
  20. Gasoline Mileage
  21. Elasticity of Response
  22. Property-Tax Exemption for Veterans
  23. Incentive Effects of Private Insurance
  24. Overbooked Airline
  25. Environment in the USA and the USSR
  26. Insurance and “Moral Hazard”
  27. Common Property
  28. The City
  29. Child Care

*  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *

  1. Proposed Policies for Evaluation

      Without reaching any final conclusion about any of the actual or proposed policies listed below, indicate for each of them one or two important considerations that this course has brought to your attention.

      1. Individual fire-detection units have been developed that emit a distinctive noise when fire occurs in a dwelling; they cost about $35. It is proposed that federal funds be offered to the states for refunding $20 per unit, for up to two such units, to any landlord or homeowner purchasing such equipment, in any state that, through its fire-safety authority or its regulation of the fire insurance industry, makes such detection devices mandatory or that severely penalizes the insurance rates of homes without them.
      2. Public provision to low-income persons with specific disabilities, and to the low-income very elderly, of “taxi vouchers,” useable in payment of metered taxi fares, redeemable in cash from the taxi company, in some standard amount calculated to cover some minimum number of trips per month for which such disabled and elderly people would need transportation by automobile.
      3. Cheap postal rates on books.
      4. Free eyeglasses for schoolchildren who need them, li parent’s or guardian’s income is below some specified level (as documented by income tax return).
      5. Free admission to selected Harvard football games for non-academic employees of the University.
      6. Requirement that any disability benefits generally available to company employees be provided also for some specified length of time for pregnancy and child-birth.
      7. The restriction, as presently in Cambridge, of most side street parking to local residents, enforced by parking fines for all vehicles without local-resident stickers,
      8. A provision that Harvard clerical, secretarial, and similar non-teaching staff be authorized, with the permission of their immediate supervisors, to enroll for grade and credit in one undergraduate Harvard course during each academic year, at no charge and with official time off from regular duties during class hours.
      9. Requirement that all new apartment buildings provide separate metering of heat in each individual apartment, with separate thermostat or other controls on heat use.
      10. Preferential hiring of veterans in government jobs.
      11. Federal program to finance welfare benefits so that benefits will be uniform among all 50 states.
      12. Free gymnasium-locker-shower and other athletic facilities made available to all employees of a large corporation, as a fringe benefit of likely value to employee health.
      13. On days when the weather makes it advisable to curtail sharply the volume of traffic on the Mass. Turnpike Extension (from the western suburbs to downtown Boston) put into effect, by radio announcement, the standby rule that cars will be admitted to the turnpike only if the first digit of the license plate is odd or even according as the date of the month is odd or even.
      14. Income-tax deduction or credit for home insulation expenditure.
      15. Life insurance equal to $50 thousand if single, $100 thousand if married, plus $25 thousand for each dependent child, for firemen and policemen killed in the line of duty.
      16. Unemployment compensation treated as “insurance” and not taxable as income.
      17. “Gasoline stamps” (patterned after food stamps) that low-income owners of registered cars and trucks can purchase at a discount, in limited quantities, as a cushion against the impact on low-income people of a federal gasoline tax.
      18. Mandatory deposit of 25¢ on every beer or soft-drink container purchased in Massachusetts, can or bottle, to be refunded upon return to any store where beer or soft drinks are sold, together with requirement that all containers sold in the state carry distinctive ineradicable markings to prevent wholesale turn-in of cans and bottles from outside the state.
      19. Mandatory $25 per year (for three years) increase in automobile insurance premium for every moving traffic for “safe” the proceeds used to reduce insurance rates drivers.
      20. The extra federal income-tax exemption for the blind.
      21. Federal income-tax deduction for contributions to schools.
      22. Rent control for persons over 65, for the disabled, and for certain other disadvantaged tenants.
      23. Exemption from minimum-wage law for youths under 17.
  1. Swine Flu Vaccination

      It is nearly forgotten now, but put youself back to January 1977: Forty million people had received swine flu vaccine. It was not clear whether an epidemic of swine flu might yet occur, and there was no final judgment on whether the vaccine itself entailed significant risk. Anywhere from 40 to 400 people were thought to have possibly died in consequence of the vaccine itself. It had been feared that a flu epidemic might ki11 40,000.

      A characteristic of vaccination is that the more successful the program, the less protection anyone needs. If everyone is vaccinated, you don’t need to be. And if the epidemic is averted, vaccination deaths may outweigh flu deaths.

      An important possibility in that January was that there remained a serious risk of swine flu but no sign of it yet, and that the publicity about some real or imagined fatal complications had made doctors afraid to offer the shots, patients reluctant to receive them, and health officials afraid to recommend them.

      Suppose it were January 1977 and you were convinced that comprehensive vaccination could entail some hundreds of deaths from the vaccine, that it could reduce flu deaths by tens of thousands if an epidemic were otherwise going to occur, and that the chance of an epidemic was about one in five if vaccination were discontinued.

      How would you evaluate the risks and benefits of stopping or proceeding with the program?

      What suggestions could you make on ways to induce people to get themselves vaccinated?

  1. 55-Mile Speed Limit

      The nationwide 55 mph speed limit that went into effect in 1974 was associated with a reduction in traffic fatalities for which no other explanation has been found. Suppose it becomes established that that speed limit, if enforced, will save three or four thousand lives per year with a commensurate reduction in injuries and automobile damage, but at some cost in truck and auto travel time and some cost of enforcement.

      The deaths and injuries, to say nothing of automobile damage, are worth taking seriously. The costs of slower transport and the lost work or leisure time have to be taken seriously. But I do not know whether the costs and benefits of enforcing the speed limit make the speed limit a good bargain in lives saved, a disproportionate nuisance for a minor reduction in mortality, or a toss-up.

      1. How would you help me reach a decision?
      2. Indicate the numerical information you would want to gather and how you would use it in estimating benefits and costs.
  1. Worth of Saving Lives

            Consider a costly program that is expected to reduce the likelihood of death within some identifiable segment of the population, and thus reduce statistically the number of deaths within that part of the population. In addressing the question of what it is worth to save those lives, i.e. to reduce those deaths, via that program, an important question is, Worth to whom? Who cares, and how much?

            Outline the way you would go about identifying the relevant interested or affected parties–individuals or governments–and how you might investigate the extent of their interest, especially the money value of their interest.

  1. Crime Rates and Police Coverage

      It has been observed that in some cities the incidence of armed robbery and illegal violence is kept at a low level by an effective response of the police, who, having a low level of violence to contend with, provide a deterrent likelihood of quick arrival. In other cities of similar social and geographic character the incidence of violence is so high that the police cannot answer calls promptly or investigate each incident. There is often no convincing explanation for the much greater prevalence of violent crime in the one case compared with the other-except, of course, the difference in effectiveness of police coverage. Yet examination shows that the numbers of police do not differ widely in the two situations.

      On the analogy of the “tipping” model, develop an analysis that could explain this phenomenon.

  1. Fire Protection

      Fire protection is nearly everywhere a city-government or town-government responsibility in the United States. It is (a) financed out of taxes and (b) provided by town employees using town equipment. By contrast, fire insurance is a private activity, homeowners buying it from private companies. Evidently there is a belief that the market cannot meet the need for fire protection: either people won’t subscribe or private firms won’t offer it. Or maybe there is just a custom that nobody questions.

      1. What are some plausible reasons why fire protection might not be left to “the market”?
      2. Do you think some of these reasons are decisive, and fire protection needs to be organized as it is?
      3. Can you think of any alternative approaches to fire protection that might be worth experimenting with?
  1. Smoking in Class

      In “The Economic Common Sense of Pollution” Ruff discusses the idea of charging people for their polluting activity, rather than simply prohibiting or permitting it. A familiar form of pollution is smoking in enclosed places where non-smokers are present.

      Suppose a special section of some class meets regularly in the evening. Some members of the class want to smoke; others complain of poor ventilation and object to any smoking. Somebody proposes that smokers might pay for the privilege of smoking.

      It is known that you have given some thought to the “pricing” of pollution, and you are asked whether it makes sense to charge for smoking and, if so, how to determine how much to charge and what to do with the proceeds.

Discuss it.

  1. Saturday Sections

      A course instructor generously offered to meet Saturday morning with interested members of the class to go over the week’s material, answer questions, etc.. Attendance was meager for a few weeks but picked up as the semester wore on, and by late in the term most of the class was showing up Saturday morning. The following year, the instructor made the same arrangement; attendance was meager for a few weeks and then fell off until only a few loyal participants were left. Even they were gone by the end of the semester.

      The instructor is perplexed at how one class was so eager while the other lost even the little interest it had. He is looking over the enrollments for the two years to see whether he can distinguish anything about the composition of the classes that would explain the difference. He wonders what to expect if he tried it once more. He’ll be happy for any advice you can give him.

  1. Apartment House Heating

      It is expected that many apartment buildings, especially among the lower-rent apartments, may again be unable to obtain as much heating fuel this winter as in past years, It is characteristic of apartments, especially the cheaper ones, that there is no metering of the heat consumed by individual tenants. If nobody takes steps to reduce heat consumption the building may run out of fuel for several days at a time, with frozen pipes and frozen people. If somebody takes steps to reduce the heat absorbed by his own apartment, usually nobody will notice–not his neighbors, not the landlord.

      Nobody has a good idea of how much reduction in heat consumption by individual apartments will be needed, as measured by anything the tenant can measure–e.g., room temperature, radiator temperature, etc. Some apartments require more heat than others to maintain the same temperature. (Corner apartments require more heat.) Some families have elderly people, babies, sick people. Some apartments are vacant most of the day, some are occupied all day.

      Nothing in any tenant’s lease makes any provision for heat control, rationing, rebates or extra charges.

      You are asked by some concerned tenants to help work out a reasonable way to minimize the risk of acute discomfort and danger due to exhaustion of fuel.

      Analyze the problem. State what data you would need in order to proceed. Outline at least one solution you would pro-pose, or several alternatives. And indicate how you might persuade tenants and landlord to accept your proposal in the event they fail to appreciate its merits or exaggerate its defects.

  1. Deposit on Cans and Bottles

      Legislation has been introduced to require a deposit on every beer or soft drink can or bottle, the deposit returnable upon return of the container. There are interests in favor and interests opposed. There is rarely discussion of how large the deposit should be–five or ten cents seems to be what people expect. The stated purposes are primarily to reduce littering and secondarily to conserve materials and energy by re-using containers or recycling materials.

      What would you want to take into account–and what facts would you want to investigate–if it were up to you to choose and justify the amount (or amounts, if variable) that the deposit should be, if there were to be a deposit.

  1. Smoking in Class: Another Room

      Consider a classroom of students among whom some like to smoke, some find it disagreeable, and some don’t care. There is dispute whether smoking should be prohibited. (It has traditionally been permitted but complaints have been frequent.) An alternative room is available, one with an air conditioning system that will mitigate the smoke nuisance for both smokers and non-smokers.

      The air-conditioned room costs extra, and the extra cost will have to be borne by the students.

      1. How would you determine whether the air-conditioned room is worth the cost? Be explicit about your criterion of “worth.”
      2. How would you propose the extra cost be paid–by which students and in what proportions?
  1. Library Air Conditioning

      A group of citizens has tried to get the town to spend $20,000 to air condition the library. They argue that the building is hot and stuffy in summer and the utilization of the library and the quality of the experience are diminished. For two years the proposal has gone before the town’s governing body, and both times it has been defeated. The opposition argues that the tax rate is out of hand anyway and this is a frill that will benefit a few at the expense of everyone.

      The question will arise next year and the town leaders want to put this issue to rest. They have no axe to grind, just want the question settled. You have been requested to prepare an analysis and a recommendation.

      1. How would you frame the issue for analysis?
      2. What data would you want to evaluate different choices?
      3. Are there sources of money other than town-wide tax support that you would consider?
  1. State-University Tuition

      Radio station WBZ editorially has opposed the principle that a state university ought to charge residents a tuition of only one-fifth the usual tuition at comparable private universities, arguing that student loans and occasional scholarships coupled with regular tuition payments would be more justifiable.

      A recent court decision called into question the right of state universities to charge higher tuitions to nonresidents than to residents of the state.

      Evaluate the idea of low tuition for state residents at state universities, with attention to the following questions:

      1. Why should tuition be low compared with other universities?
      2. Why should tuition be subsidized only at the state university and not at any university in the state?
      3. Why should tuition be low only for residents of the state?
      4. Why should tuition not be similarly subsidized for state residents who get their education at colleges outside the state?

      Be sure to discuss who benefits and who loses, what the effect may be on college attendance, and what the effect may be on attendance at the state university.

  1. Nursery Schools

      Some of the most expensive private schools, from nursery schools to colleges, provide scholarships for a few children whose parents could not afford the tuition. The system is challenged as inappropriate charity by some tuition-paying parents, and defended by others as a way of sharing privileges that only a few can otherwise afford. Nursery schools are usually not endowed, so the costs of scholarships are borne by the parents who pay tuition for their own children.

      If you were asked to speak on this issue at a meeting of nursery school parents, on grounds that you have taken this course, what are the main points you would make to help the parents think about the issue?

  1. Youth Fare

      The Civil Aeronautics Board gave notice that “youth fare” had to be terminated. (Youth fare was lower fares for young people, usually with some loss of priority to the youths taking advantage of it.) The argument was that youth fare discriminates against other passengers.

      Discuss the “discriminatory pricing” represented by the youth fare, indicating who is likely to gain and who to lose, with what effect on average fare, volume of travel, passenger convenience, and so forth.

      Identify any significant distributional implications of the particular groups or classes that appear to gain and to lose.

      What do you consider to be the chief socio-economic or other characteristic of “youth” that one ought to have in mind in considering the merits of youth fare?

  1. Welfare and Work Incentives

      If a welfare program assures every eligible family a specified minimum income, providing the difference between actual earnings and that minimum, the incentive and the opportunity to work gainfully are said to be impaired by a “100 percent income tax.” But without some assured minimum many families will fall below any decent standard of living.

      1. Explain the basic dilemma.
      2. Discuss proposed solutions.
      3. Evaluate the difficulty of finding an ideal solution to the problem.
  1. Dining Hall Problem
    1. Evaluate these alternative ways to distribute food and to assess costs in a graduate school dining hall.
      1. At every mealtime there is a fixed menu. Everybody gets the same meal and the same quantities. Total cost is divided equally among all those eligible to use the dining hall.
      2. As in No. 1 there is a fixed menu, but everybody eats as much as he pleases. The total amount of food is the same as in No. 1; and if some take more than their share and none take less, the last to arrive will face shortages. The cost is assessed in equal shares.
      3. Substantial variety is offered; everybody helps himself to whatever he likes, as much as he likes; adequate supplies are made available. Everybody is assessed an equal share of the total cost.
      4. A cheap meal is offered free; a variety of more expensive meals can be purchased a la carte. The cost, less the proceeds, is divided among the members.
      5. Same as No. 1, but the menu is fixed for each day of the week and known to all. People are charged only for the meals they eat, and may eat elsewhere. All meals count the same in everybody’s monthly bill.
    2. What difference will it make—
      1. if individual dishes (and beverages, rolls, etc.) are in such form that they can be shared, given away, or traded among diners;
      2. if every member is issued a specified number of transferable guest passes each month;
      3. if every member has a pass, good for each mealtime, and anyone holding the pass will be admitted without further identification.
  1. University Parking

      A university possesses some parking area and finds that the number of employees who need parking has grown to twice the number of spaces available. Alternative public parking off campus is expensive. Numerous proposals have been made about what to do:

      1. Assign non-transferable parking stickers to half the employees. Do this (a) by seniority, (b) by lottery, or (c) any other selection system you propose.
      2. Same as a but let the stickers be sold, traded, or given away by the recipients.
      3. Assign spaces to those who live farthest away where there is no public transportation.
      4. Convert university parking space into public parking lots, charging admission to the general public like any other commercial parking lot.
      5. Give all employees who drive to work one ticket and “sell” parking to university employees at a “price” of two tickets per space, letting everybody choose whether to sell his ticket to another employee or to buy somebody’s ticket and acquire a parking space.

      Make a recommendation and support it with the best argument you can construct. You need not recommend one of the above alternatives, but you must indicate why the scheme you recommend is superior.

  1. Vouchers, Goods- (services) -in-Kind, or Cash

            What are the central issues raised by the choice between giving people (1) such things as food stamps, school vouchers, trash collection vouchers, as against giving them (2) goods in kind, e.g., free lunches, or free schooling, or free trash collection, as against giving them (3) cash. Discuss the principles that should govern the choice, and illustrate your answer by three examples that highlight significant differences. (If you like, use food, schooling, and trash collection. If not, use any three that help you make your points.)

  1. Gasoline Mileage

      A major reason for U.S. dependence on foreign oil is that American automobiles get poor gas mileage. Three alternative remedies might be:

      1. Prohibit production of cars that get less than some specified miles per gallon;
      2. Put a tax on new cars that is related to gas consumption, high on cars with poor mileage while fuel-efficient cars pay a small tax or no tax or even receive a rebate;
      3. Tax gasoline, not automobiles.

            Evaluate the three proposals in terms of what you have learned in this course.

  1. Elasticity of Response

      Some policies are motivated by an interest in changing the way people behave; others are intended to compensate people for the results of the marketplace or for extraordinary misfortune. Few policy measures are without some induced change in behavior, whether the change is intended or not.

      Discuss the “elasticity of response” as a factor in policy evaluation. By “elasticity of response” is meant the degree to which behavior is affected by the policy.

      Discuss the kinds of policies for which a high elasticity will frustrate the policy or make it too expensive, and the kinds that in contrast are justified by a high elasticity.

      Give examples of both kinds. Your examples may be from income taxation, medical insurance, welfare programs, resource conservation, pollution abatement, or any field that interests you.

  1. Property-Tax Exemption for Veterans

      Many states provide benefits to veterans–mortgage guarantees for purchase of homes, civil-service preferences, certain kinds of tax exemption.

      One proposal is that, as a benefit pertinent to young veterans raising families, every veteran should receive some stipulated exemption from property taxes within the state, possibly a specified amount or percentage to be subtracted from the assessed valuation on his property before the tax rate is applied.

      (The mechanisms for this may be complex, since states might have to reimburse towns, which impose most of the property taxes, but suppose that the internal finances can be worked out.)

      Evaluate the proposal.

      Identify the purposes it may serve.

      Identify any important distinctions and details that would make a major difference in the proposal.

      Assuming that some state resources were to be made available for returning veterans, identify one or two alternative proposals that, at about the same aggregate cost, might come closer to meeting the criteria by which you judge such a program.

  1. Incentive Effects of Private Insurance

      An important principle in the analysis of social insurance programs is that incentive effects, many of which will be perverse but some may be beneficial, should be watched out for. Briefly discuss the incentive effects you might want to watch out for–and how you would evaluate them–in any policy designed to encourage, to discourage, or to rely on, the following kinds of private insurance that might be available in the market.

      Assume that in each case the insurance pays compensation in cash.

      Give some thought to who does the insuring–e.g., the customer’s own heating-oil company in (c).

      1. Insurance against loss due to burglary.
      2. Insurance against being convicted of burglary.
      3. Insurance against running out of heating fuel.
      4. Insurance against receiving a grade lower than some specified grade in a graduate course.
      5. Insurance against running out of gasoline during a gasoline shortage (for any reason).
      6. Insurance against losing money in the resale of a house in a “declining neighborhood.”
      7. Insurance against auto collision during hazardous driving conditions.
      8. Insurance against the cost of emergency help in the event of dead batteries, flat tires, or being trapped by snow in one’s driveway.
      9. Insurance against all medical costs incurred during a hospital stay.
  1. Overbooked Airline

      An airline oversubscribes a flight and by scheduled flight time has 140 passengers with valid reservations and only 120 seats on the plane, which will depart two hours late because of late arrival, so there are nearly two hours in which to decide what to do. There are no established rules to cover the situation. The airline has no record of the dates on which people made their reservations. The passengers have been informed of the situation but not told what the airline proposes to do. You are to advise the airline right now.

      Pick one among the following procedures, or make up a procedure of your own that is not on this list, and defend it by comparing it with what you think are the most serious or attractive alternative procedures listed.

      1. Issue boarding passes randomly by drawing names out of a hat, making clear to the passengers that the names have been shuffled to guarantee randomness.
      2. Announce that the flight will be delayed until 20 people have either cancelled their reservations or made other arrangements, boarding the 120 still remaining.
      3. Have everyone hand sealed bids for places on the plane. The highest 120 bids are selected and the money collected. The amount collected is distributed among some or all of the 140 passengers in any manner you choose–equal shares to everyone, equally to those who did not bid high enough to get on, or whatever seems appropriate to you.
      4. Announce that spaces will be allotted according to the dates when reservations were made, the earliest 120 reservations to be given seats on this flight, and call out 120 names as though the airline actually had those dates available.
      5. Simultaneously raise the price of going tonight and lower the price for going tomorrow until you find a pair of prices at which:
        1. exactly 120 wish to go tonight, and
        2. the airline breaks even, that is the discount to the 20 who go tomorrow equals, in total, the surcharge on the 120 who go tonight.
      6. Issue 120 boarding passes by random selection—making clear the passengers understand that the names have been shuffled and the selection is random–but announce that the boarding passes are transferable, passengers may transact any business they wish with their boarding passes–e.g., a couple travelling together that obtains only one pass may attempt to buy a second pass or to sell the one they have and go together later.

Additionally, answer the following:

      1. Which among these procedures would be more acceptable if everybody knew in advance what the standard procedure would be in this situation?
      2. Which among these procedures would be less attractive if everybody knew in advance what the procedure would be.
      3. Which procedures are most likely, if they are the acknowledged general rule for these situations, to induce the airline to book the right number of people for each flight? (By the way, what is the right number for each flight that the airline ought to book?)
  1. Environment in the USA and the USSR

      In his chapter on Environmental Disruption, Marshall Goldman compares environmental destruction in the Soviet Union with that in the United States, finding not only that there is such a problem in both countries but that the specific occurrences look much alike. It is often supposed that in the United States businesses will disregard the environmental damage which they do because they are in pursuit of profit; it is often supposed that no such motives would obtain in a socialist economy. It may come as a surprise that in an economic system without the profit motive there is similar disregard for the environment.

      How does Goldman explain the parallelism in the way the environment fares at the hands of these two dissimilar social and economic systems? How persuasive do you find his analysis?

  1. Insurance and “Moral Hazard”

      It is often argued that insurance may be self-defeating because of “moral hazard,” the tendency for people, once insured against some risk, to skimp precautions against the risk. People whose homes are insured against fire take fewer precautions against fire than if they had no insurance; people insured against theft may decorate their homes with more valuable objects than if they were uninsured.

      For the contrary it is also argued that insurance frees people from the necessity to go to expensive lengths to guard against fire or theft, and that what is sometimes derrogated as “moral hazard’ is merely the efficient substitution of insurance for the more expensive alternative, protection. Better to pay $1 per $1,000 of home value per year to cover the cost of a house or two destroyed by fire than to spend $3 per $1,000 of value in protection, especially when the protection is imperfect.

      Evidently these two views of insurance conflict. Presumably they conflict whether the insurance is privately purchased on the market or publicly provided by government. If you were asked which of the two views is the correct one, or are both views in the wrong, what answer would you give?

  1. Common Property

In his article on a “Common-Property Resource: The Fishery,” Scott Gordon (in the book edited by Dorfman and Dorfman) likens the problem of the fishery to that of hunting and trapping, the drilling for petroleum from a common underground pool, and the use of common pasture for private animals in the medieval “common.”

State succinctly the nature of the general problem of common-property resources of the kind he investigates.

Give an example or two of your own.

Indicate some of the ways that these different variants of the same general problem may be solved.

  1. The City

Wilbur Thompson, in the article contained in Hochman’s, The Urban Economy, refers to “The City as a Distorted Price System.

Can you explain what he means by this characterization?

Can you give a few examples?

What does he say (or imply) ought to be done about it?

Do you have an opinion on that?

  1. Child Care

In her article on federal support for child care, in the Haveman and Margolis book, Alice Rivlin cites figures that “acceptable” day care for a pre-school or school-age child would cost around $2,000 per year. The figures were from 1968; with inflation it might be over $3,000 now. Among the arquments in favor of federal support for day care is the desirability of permitting comparatively poor mothers to work out of the house and augment their earnings.

Rivlin discusses the issue of extending federally financed day care to middle-income families (up to $12,000 per year at the time she wrote, equivalent to perhaps $16,000 now). If you do, she says, it’s expensive. If you don’t, you have the equivalent of a high “income tax” on poor women’s earnings.

Explain the dilemma.

Is it the same as the “welfare dilemma” discussed in connection with the negative-income tax?

How would the dilemma be affected if the women were given cash that they could spend on day care or on anything else they might prefer to spend it on?

Source:  Thomas C. Schelling, Economic Principles and Public Policy (Harvard, Spring 1981). Exam Questions from Earlier Years. Photocopy reproduced in Economics Reading Lists, Course Outlines, Exams, Puzzles & Problems compiled by Edward Tower. Vol. 12 (July 1981): Public Finance Exams, Puzzles & Problems, pp. 18-38.

Image Source: File photo from 1983 Harvard News Office. The Weatherhead Center for International Affairs at Harvard University. “In Memoriam: Thomas C. Schelling, 1921–2016”

 

Categories
Exam Questions Harvard History of Economics

Harvard. History of economics, Pre-1848. Bullock, 1912-1913

Before he went off to the University of Wisconsin to study economics, Harvard’s professor of economics for public finance and the history of economics, Charles J. Bullock, taught high-school Latin and Greek. I wonder who would have been among the last American-born economists able to read Xenophon in the original. 

The mid-year and year-end exams for Bullock’s 1912-13 course is the new content transcribed for this post. The survey course was taken by seven graduate students.

________________________

FORMER WILLIAMS TEACHER IS DEAD
Prof. Charles J. Bullock,Retired Harvard Economist,
on Faculty Here at Century’s Turn.

The North Adams Transcript (March 20, 1941)

Dr. Charles Jesse Bullock, professor emeritus of economics at Harvard university, a nationally known tax authority and a former member of the Williams college faculty, died Monday at his home in Hingham. He was 72 years old.

From 1899 until 1903 when he went to Harvard, Dr. Bullock taught at Williams, first as an assistant professor of economics and sociology and then as Orrin Sage professor of history and political science. He became a full professor at Harvard in 1908 and continued to teach there until 1935 when he took the title of professor emeritus.

Prof. Bullock was the author of many books and articles on economics. In the presidential campaign year of 1936, after his retirement, he served as chief of the research division of the Republican National committee and conferred with Alfred M. Landon, the Republican candidate, on many occasions.

A native of Boston, Dr. Bullock was graduated from Boston university in 1889. He taught Greek and Latin in New England schools and served as principal of the Middlebury, Vt. high school before entering the University of Wisconsin to study economics. He earned a doctorate there in 1895.

Prof. Bullock returned to Williamstown in 1921 to receive an honorary degree of doctor of laws from Williams.

Dr. Bullock married Helena M. Smith of Washington in 1895 and they had one daughter, Grace Helena Bullock.

________________________

History of economics courses
pre-1911/12

Links to earlier course material for History of Economics at Harvard, 1883-84 through 1910-11.

_______________________

Economics 14
Course Description
1912-13

[Economics] 14 (formerly 15). History and Literature of Economics to the year 1848. Mon., Wed., and (at the pleasure of the instructor) Fri., at 11. Professor Bullock.

The purpose of this course is to trace the development of economic thought from classical antiquity to the middle of the nineteenth century. Emphasis is placed upon the relation of economics to philosophical and political theories, as well as to political and industrial conditions.
A considerable amount of reading of prominent writers will be assigned, and opportunity given for the preparation of theses. Much of the instruction is necessarily given by means of lectures.

Source: Harvard University. Division of History, Government, and Economics, Courses of Instruction, 1912–13, pp. 63-64.

_______________________

Economics 14
Course Enrollment
1912-13

Economics 14 (formerly 15). Professor Bullock. History and Literature of Economics to the year 1848.

Total 7: 7 Graduates.

Source: Harvard University. Reports of the President and the Treasurer of Harvard College, 1912-13, p. 58.

_______________________

ECONOMICS 14
Mid-year Examination
1912-13

  1. What significant analyses of economic structure and processes were made by the writers of ancient and mediaeval times?
  2. Discuss the following statement concerning Greek economic thought: “The military constitution of society, and the existence of slavery, which was related to it, turned away the habitual attention of thinkers from that domain.”
  3. In the same connection, discuss the following: “The practical economic enterprises of Greek and Roman antiquity could not, even independently of any special adverse influences, have competed in magnitude of scale or variety of resources with those of modern times.”
  4. Write a critical estimate of Xenophon’s treatise on “The Revenues of Athens.”
  5. To what extent were ancient and medieval economic thought influenced by the concept of an order of nature?
  6. What were Aristotle’s views concerning economic and political equilibrium?
  7. How far has our knowledge of mediaeval economic thought been advanced by the application of the doctrine of the relativity of economic thought?
  8. What justification is there for regarding the sixteenth century as the beginning of a new era in political and economic thought?

Source: Harvard University. Mid-year examinations, 1852-1943. Box 9, bound volume Examination Papers, Mid-Years 1912-13. 

_______________________

ECONOMICS 14
Year-end Examination
1912-13

  1. What significant analyses of economic structure and functions were made by the mercantilists?
  2. Discuss the development of economic opinions as reflected in the writings of Hales, Bodin, Montchrétien, Mun, Petty, Boisguilbert, Cantillon, Vanderlint, and Hume.
  3. Explain the structure and purpose of the “Wealth of Nations,” and give a brief analysis of the doctrines of the first two books.
  4. Discuss the treatment of the subject of population by Aristotle, the Schoolmen, Cantillon, Smith, and Malthus.
  5. At what points did the economic theories of Ricardo differ from those of Adam Smith?

Source: Harvard University Examinations. Papers set for final examinations in history, history of science, government, economics, philosophy, social ethics, education, fine arts, music in Harvard College (June 1913), p. 54.

Image Source: Xenophon. From the statue of Xenophon by Hugo Haerdtl that is located on the southern entry ramp to the Austrian Parliament (Dr.-Karl-Renner-Ring 3, im 1. Wiener Gemeindebezirk Innere Stadt).

________________________

Earlier versions of the course
by year and instructor

1899-1900. The History and Literature of Economics to the close of the Eighteenth Century. [William James Ashley]

1901-02. History and Literature of Economics, to the opening of the Nineteenth Century. [Charles Whitney Mixter]

1903-04. History and Literature of Economics to the opening of the Nineteenth Century [Charles Jesse Bullock]

1904-05. History and Literature of Economics to the year 1848. [Charles Jesse Bullock]

1905-06. History and Literature of Economics to the year 1848. [Charles Jesse Bullock]

1906-07. History and Literature of Economics to the year 1848 [Charles Jesse Bullock]

1907-08. History and Literature of Economics to the year 1848 [Charles Jesse Bullock]

1908-09. History and Literature of Economics to the year 1848 [Charles Jesse Bullock]

1909-10. History and Literature of Economics to the year 1848 [Charles Jesse Bullock]

1910-11. History and Literature of Economics to the year 1848
[Charles Jesse Bullock]

1911-12. History and Literature of Economics to the year 1848
[Charles Jesse Bullock]

Categories
Exam Questions Harvard Social Insurance Social Work Sociology

Harvard. Social Ethics Courses. Enrollments and Final Exams. Peabody et al., 1912-1913

 

Social Ethics 1-7
1912-13

Social Ethics 1. Social Problems in the Light of Ethical Theory
Social Ethics 2. Practical Problems of Social Service
Social Ethics 3. Criminology and Penology [omitted 1911-12]
Social Ethics 4. Social Problems of Immigration and Race
Social Ethics 5. The Housing Problem
Social Ethics 6. Social Amelioration in Europe
Social Ethics 7. Rural Social Development

The courses in this group are designed to apply philosophical principles to the modern problems of philanthropy, industry, and social life. They begin with a general introduction to Social Ethics and proceed to methods of applied ethics which approach those of a professional school. Students should have already elected courses both in Philosophy and in Economics, and should regard the courses in Social Ethics as concerned with the transition from academic to practical life.

Previously posted course material for social ethics at Harvard.

________________________

Social Ethics Instructors
1911-12

Jeffrey Richardson Brackett
Robert Franz Foerster
James Ford
Francis Greenwood Peabody

________________________

Social Ethics 1.
Poor-Relief, the Family, Temperance and the Labor Question

[Social Ethics] 1. The Problems of Poor -Relief, The Family, Temperance, and various phases of the Labor Question, in the light of Ethical Theory. Lectures, special researches, and prescribed reading. Tu., Th., Sat., at 10. Professor [Francis Greenwood] PEABODY, Dr. [James] FORD, and Dr. [Robert Franz] FOERSTER.

This course is an application of ethical theory to the social problems of the present day. It is to be distinguished from economic courses dealing with similar subjects by the emphasis laid on the moral aspects of the social situation and on the philosophy of society involved. In addition to lectures and required reading a special and detailed report is made by each student, based as far as possible on personal research and observation of scientific methods in industrial reform. These researches are arranged in consultation with the instructors; and an important feature of the course is the suggestion and direction of such personal investigation and the provision to each student of special literature and opportunities for observation. Students are advised, before beginning the study of Social Ethics, to take courses both in Economics and Philosophy; and must have taken a course, or the equivalent of a course, in one of these subjects.

Source: Official Register of Harvard University, Vol. IX, No. 16 (May 10, 1912). Division of History, Government and Economics, 1912-13, p. 69.

Course Enrollment

[Social Ethics] 1. Professor [Francis Greenwood] PEABODY, Dr. [James] FORD, and Dr. [Robert Franz] FOERSTER. — Social Problems in the light of Ethical Theory. Poor relief, the family, temperance, and the labor question.

Total 75: 16 Seniors, 25 Juniors, 13 Sophomores, 2 Freshmen, 19 Others.

Source: Report of the President of Harvard College, 1912-1913, p. 62.

Year-end Examination
SOCIAL ETHICS 1

So allot your time that you may answer all questions

  1. What advantages would be secured by each of the devices described by Seager for dealing with unemployment?
  2. Describe the method employed for dealing with industrial disputes in (a) England, (b) New Zealand. What are the respective advantages and disadvantages of these methods?
  3. Compare and contrast the Victorian and the Massachusetts Minimum Wage Laws.
  4. What was the case of Priestley vs. Fowler? What were its consequences? What are the provisions of the present British law by which the problem in question is dealt with?
  5. What are the difficulties and dangers in the application of “welfare work “? Under what conditions, if any, should “welfare work” be undertaken by employers? (Treat specifically (a) “welfare work within the factory; (b) provision of facilities for recreation.)
  6. Define industrial partnership, copartnership, workers ‘ cooperative production. Show in how far these terms overlap.
  7. Criticize the following:–
    1. “Co-operation is incapable of raising wages and shortening hours.”
    2. “The aim of co-operation is to abolish utterly the wage system.”
  8. “Syndicalism asks that each industrial group of workers should control the instruments of production which it uses the railway — men, the railways; the miners, the mines; and so on. “Is this a practicable program? Give argument and evidence in detail.
  9. Outline the history, aim, structure, and methods of the British Co-operative Union.

Source: Harvard University Examinations. Papers set for final examinations in history, history of science, government, economics, philosophy, social ethics, education, fine arts, music in Harvard College(June 1913), pp. 71-72.

 

___________________________________

Social Ethics 2.
Practical Problems of Social Service

* 2 2hf. Practical Problems of Social Service: Public Aid, Charity, and Neighborhood Work. Lectures, prescribed reading, and observation of work under skilled direction. Half-course (second half-year). Tu., Th., at 2.30. Dr. [Jeffrey Richardson] BRACKETT.

This course is for advanced students, especially for those who plan, as ministers, teachers, or as citizens, whatever their vocation, to be actively interested in charity, correction, or any form of social work. It is also an introduction to Social Ethics 20c, the School for Social Workers. It is a study of tendencies in Social Service, of law and custom, especially in England and the United States, bearing directly on such topics as neighborhood improvement, forms and sources of relief, modification of charitable trusts, treatment of special types of the needy, organization of charity, financial management, supervision of work by public and private agencies.

Source: Official Register of Harvard University, Vol. IX, No. 16 (May 10, 1912). Division of History, Government and Economics, 1912-13, pp. 69-70.

Course Enrollment

[Social Ethics] 2 2hf. Dr. [Jeffrey Richardson] BRACKETT. — Practical Problems of Social Service: public aid, charity, and neighborhood work.

Total 23: 3 Graduates, 7 Seniors, 7 Juniors, 2 Sophomores, 4 Others.

Source: Report of the President of Harvard College, 1912-1913, p. 62.

Year-End Examination
SOCIAL ETHICS 2
  1. “At the beginning of the study of the causes of poverty, the personal causes, as we have seen, were chiefly emphasized.”
    Explain this statement.
    What is the present tendency in weighing causes of poverty and misery?
    What is your judgment as to tendencies?
  2. You are asked what a social settlement is for. What is your answer?
  3. What are the places in modern philanthropy:–
    1. Of “volunteer” or unpaid workers, usually giving part time, as compared with
    2. The professional workers who are usually paid for full time service?
  4. Illustrate your view of the meaning of social work by the treatment of two of the following types of need:–
    1. The feeble-minded.
    2. The blind.
    3. Offenders.
    4. Dependent children.
  5. What should be the chief results of a well used confidential bureau for exchange of information of needy families?
  6. What arguments do you give
    1. For,
    2. Against, the use of public money for private charity?
  7. What are the chief lessons of value which you have learned from the field work which has been accepted as practice work for this course?

Source: Harvard University Examinations. Papers set for final examinations in history, history of science, government, economics, philosophy, social ethics, education, fine arts, music in Harvard College(June 1913), pp. 72-73.

___________________________________

Social Ethics 3.
Criminology and Penology

[* 3 1hf. Criminology and Penology. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and reports. Half-course (first half-year).]

Omitted in 1912-13.

Source: Official Register of Harvard University, Vol. IX, No. 16 (May 10, 1912). Division of History, Government and Economics, 1912-13, p. 70.

___________________________________

Social Ethics 4.
Social Problems of Immigration and Race

* 4 1hf. Social Problems of Immigration and Race. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and a research. Half-course (first half-year). Tu., Th., Sat., at 11. Dr. [Robert Franz] FOERSTER.

This course deals principally with immigration into the United States, in its international aspects and as an internal problem; secondarily with the American negro problem. Emigration from foreign countries is first studied — in its causes, its historical course, and its consequences for the countries from which it proceeds. Next are considered the history and changes of immigration into the United States; the condition of immigrants in this country; and the effects, transitory and permanent, upon the United States, under social, industrial, and racial aspects. Questions of American internal policy (contact, utilization, assimilation) and the question of national policy (restriction, non-restriction, selection, protection) are studied, partly in relation to emigration and immigration legislation of other countries. To the negro problem less time is devoted; yet the rural and urban populations, their economic and social changes in the post-slavery period, and the broad questions of public and private policy will be considered.

The method of the course will be as far as possible analytical rather than historical or descriptive. Special emphasis will be laid on the thesis and from time to time research conferences will be substituted for lectures.

Source: Official Register of Harvard University, Vol. IX, No. 16 (May 10, 1912). Division of History, Government and Economics, 1912-13, pp. 70-71.

Course Enrollment

[Social Ethics] 4 1hf. Dr. [Robert Franz] FOERSTER. — Social Problems of Immigration and Race.

Total 20: 6 Graduates, 8 Seniors, 2 Juniors, 1 Sophomore, 3 Others.

Source: Report of the President of Harvard College, 1912-1913, p. 62.

Mid-year Examination
SOCIAL ETHICS 4

So allot your time that you may answer all questions. Carefully indicate the reasons for your conclusions.

  1. Is there an instinct of migration? Are there other peculiarly psychological causes of emigration? What psychological factor is of noteworthy consequence after arrival of immigrants in this country?
  2. Show the connection of immigration with the problem of insanity in the United States. What is our present legislation in regard to insane aliens?
  3. “Recent immigration has not reduced the rates of wages, nor has it prevented an increase in the rates of wages; it has pushed the native and older immigrant wage-earners upward on the scale of occupations.” Discuss both of these propositions, giving in some detail reasons for the position you take.
  4. A Massachusetts congressman recently said: “The literacy test, as I have repeatedly shown, discriminates strongly against the class of laborers who are most needed in the United States.” By what argument would that position be supported? Indicate the grounds of your agreement or disagreement with the argument.
  5. Compare the occupational position of the negro in the rural South with that in New York City. Upon what grounds are the differences to be explained? What is Murphy’s solution of the occupational problem?
  6. What can be said of the effects of (a) race mixture, (b) environment, upon the future race stock of the United States?
  7. What are the effects of emigration upon Greece?

Source: Harvard University Examinations. Papers set for final examinations in history, history of science, government, economics, philosophy, social ethics, education, fine arts, music in Harvard College(June 1913), pp. 73-74.

___________________________________

Social Ethics 5.
The Housing Problem

* 5 1hf. The Housing Problem. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and research. Half-course (first half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 10. Dr. [James] FORD.

Primarily a course in social research. Each student is required to make an intensive original survey of housing conditions in a selected district, or to undertake detailed field work in some phase of the subject. The lectures and prescribed reading will deal with methods and results of existing housing surveys. Examination will be made of the causes and remedies of lot and room congestion, problems of construction, sanitation, and maintenance of tenements, lodging houses, and cottages. The agencies of improved construction of dwellings — philanthropic, coöperative and governmental — will be treated, together with methods of residential and industrial decentralization. The function of health and building codes, taxation, land reform, city planning, in the regulation and improvement of housing conditions, will be examined in detail.

Source: Official Register of Harvard University, Vol. IX, No. 16 (May 10, 1912). Division of History, Government and Economics, 1912-13, p. 71.

Course Enrollment

[Social Ethics] 5 1hf. Dr. [James] FORD. — The Housing Problem.

Total 6: 1 Graduate, 3 Seniors, 1 Sophomore, 1 Other.

Source: Report of the President of Harvard College, 1912-1913, p. 62.

Mid-year Examination
SOCIAL ETHICS 5
  1. State the arguments for and against the construction by philanthropic corporations of improved dwellings for the working classes. Under what conditions is the philanthropic construction of model tenements of net social advantage?
  2. State the present provisions in the New York Tenement House Act designed to prevent lot congestion. Show in detail how these provisions are socially justifiable.
  3. What do New York statistics show to be the most frequent places of origin of tenement house fires? How do such fires spread?
    State the provisions (a) of the New York Tenement Act, (b) of the Massachusetts Tenement House Act for towns, which are designed to prevent such fires.
  4. What are the sources of the gross business profits of British Copartnership Garden Suburbs? How are net profits distributed to tenant members?
  5. What social advantage is there in the construction of homes for employees by employers of labor? What are the disadvantages of such a plan to the employer? To the employee? How can each disadvantage be obviated?
  6. A criticism of Howard’s “Garden Cities of Tomorrow” :—
    1. What parts of the scheme are impracticable?
    2. What suggestions are practicable and of value?
  7. Could housing conditions in American cities be improved by the application of local zone systems? What principles should govern the determination of zone boundaries?
  8. What size and shape of lot would you advocate for the construction of suburban homes for wage-earners? Why?

Source: Harvard University Examinations. Papers set for final examinations in history, history of science, government, economics, philosophy, social ethics, education, fine arts, music in Harvard College(June 1913), p. 74.

___________________________________

Social Ethics 6.
Social Amelioration in Europe

* 6 2hf. Social Amelioration in Europe. — Lectures and prescribed reading. Half-course (second half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 11. Dr. [Robert Franz] FOERSTER.

This course is mainly concerned with schemes of social amelioration that have so far been little considered in the United States. Remedial methods of dealing with poverty will be treated only incidentally. Chiefly the course will make a comparative study of the preventive and constructive measures, public and private, of several countries. After a brief consideration of the place of thrift institutions, unemployment and the important recent efforts to meet it will be discussed at some length. The experience of several countries in providing for the indigent in case of accident, sickness, invalidity, and old age will, in turn, be examined. The course will close with a study of recent developments of legislation governing conditions of labor.

Source: Official Register of Harvard University, Vol. IX, No. 16 (May 10, 1912). Division of History, Government and Economics, 1912-13, p. 71.

Course Enrollment

[Social Ethics] 6 2hf. Dr. [Robert Franz] FOERSTER. — Social Amelioration in Europe.

Total 11: 3 Graduates, 4 Seniors, 1 Junior, 1 Sophomore, 2 Others.

Source: Report of the President of Harvard College, 1912-1913, p. 62.

Year-end Examination
SOCIAL ETHICS 6

So allot your time that you may answer all questions

  1. Suppose that in a country of 250,000 workmen the number of unemployed persons has been, over a long period of years, never less than 10,000. How far could the amount of unemployment be reduced by the following remedies (applied individually)?
    1. The erection of an industrial establishment by state authority, permitting the employment of 10,000 persons.
    2. Such a reduction of the hours of labor by law as would result in an undiminished output, if 10,000 more persons were to be employed.
  2. Point out the differences of the St. Gall and English schemes of unemployment insurance. Do these differences make for a difference of result?
  3. Describe the German system of sickness insurance in its present form in respect of:
    1. Source of financial support;
    2. Organization and administration;
    3. “Benefits” provided;
    4. Arrangements with physicians.
  4. What measures have the insurance authorities of Germany taken to reduce the extent of disease?
  5. How far is the workmen’s insurance of Germany a burden upon industry and how far is it not?
  6. “In Germany and other countries in which the system has been wholly or partly established, they [the socialists] work for the elimination of the workingmen’s contributions to the insurance funds on the theory that it is the duty of the state to insure the life and existence of the worker, without curtailing his wages for that purpose.” (Hillquit, “Socialism in theory and practice.”) What are the grounds of your own agreement or disagreement with the attitude of the socialists? How far does your knowledge of the instincts, as they are described by McDougall, affect your answer?
  7. What system of labor exchanges do you regard as the best? Why?

Source: Harvard University Examinations. Papers set for final examinations in history, history of science, government, economics, philosophy, social ethics, education, fine arts, music in Harvard College(June 1913), p. 75.

___________________________________

Social Ethics 7.
Rural Social Development

* 7 2hf. Rural Social Development. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and thesis. Half-course (second half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 10. Dr. [James] FORD.

This course will study the methods and results of rural social research. It will treat the social problems of rural communities — race composition, poverty, housing, health, recreation, labor, etc. The means of development of country life from without through “Back-to-the-Land” and other movements; and rural reconstruction from within through adaptation of existing local institutions, coöperative movements, and State activities will be considered.
The third hour of each week will be devoted to the discussion of prescribed reading or to direction of research.

Source: Official Register of Harvard University, Vol. IX, No. 16 (May 10, 1912). Division of History, Government and Economics, 1912-13, p. 72.

Course Enrollment

[Social Ethics] 7 2hf. Dr. [James] FORD. — Rural Social Development.

Total 15: 1 Graduate, 10 Seniors, 2 Juniors, 1 Sophomore, 1 Other.

Source: Report of the President of Harvard College, 1912-1913, p. 62.

Year-End Examination
SOCIAL ETHICS 7
  1. State in detail the possible sources of data for an exhaustive social survey of a New England rural township.
  2. Outline (a) the causes, (b) the local results of the rural exodus. State carefully in how far the causes can be eliminated by conscious social policy?
  3. Summarize the findings of the U. S. Immigration Commission with reference to the (a) economic status, (b) rapidity of assimilation, (c) contribution to community development, of immigrant farmers in the United States.
  4. Discuss:
    1. The conditions and results of marriage selection among the Hill Folk.
    2. The value of early placing-out of children as a means of meeting the social problem of a degenerate community (illustrate from the Hill Folk).
  5. What diseases may be transmitted through the farm water supply? State how each of the following may be contaminated: shallow wells; driven wells; cisterns. (Lipman “Bacteria,” and Ogden “Rural Hygiene.”)
  6. What powers for health control in rural communities reside in the best equipped State Boards of Health? Should any of these powers be left with local health officials and not with the State? Give reasons. (Fairlie and Lectures.)
  7. Name and classify the agencies of adult education in rural communities. Show the form and methods of university extension in rural communities, employed by State colleges of agriculture (especial reference to Massachusetts).
  8. State in detail the (a) organization, (b) business methods, of co-operative associations for disposal of eggs. What specifically is the importance of such associations in the betterment of rural social conditions? (Wolff and Lectures.)

Source: Harvard University Examinations. Papers set for final examinations in history, history of science, government, economics, philosophy, social ethics, education, fine arts, music in Harvard College(June 1913), p. 76.

Image Source: Room 2 of the Harvard’s Social Museum. Francis G. Peabody, The Social Museum as an Instrument of University Teaching. Publications of the Department of Social Ethics in Harvard University, Number 4 (Cambridge, MA: 1911).

_____________________________

Social Ethics à la Peabody
1888/89—1911/12

A short history of Harvard’s Department of Social Ethics through 1920.

Exam questions for late 19th century versions of Francis Greenwood Peabody’s course on the Ethics of Social Reform have been transcribed and posted:

1888-1889; 1889-1890; 1890-1891; 1892-1893; 1893-1894; 1894-1895; 1895-1896.

Earlier 20th century course material:

1902-03. Listed as Philosophy 5. Taught by Peabody and Ireland.
1904-05. Listed as Philosophy 5 and Ethics 1. Taught by Peabody and Rogers.
1906-07. Taught by Peabody and Rogers.
1907-08. Taught by Peabody and Rogers.
1908-09. Taught by Peabody, McConnell, Ford and Foerster.
1909-10. Taught by Peabody, McConnell, Ford, and Foerster.
1910-11. Taught by Peabody, McConnell, Ford, Foerster, and Brackett. [complete set of social ethics exams]
1911-12. Taught by Peabody, McConnell, Ford, Foerster, and Brackett. [complete set of social ethics exams]

Categories
Exam Questions Harvard Macroeconomics

Harvard. Final exam for Aggregate Economic Theory. Dorfman, 1962-1963

“Macro-economics” was explicitly named in the course description for the Harvard undergraduate economics tutorial [Economics 98b] in 1962-63. For the next several years, no course even included “macroeconomics” in its title. Instead graduate students were taught “aggregate economic theory”, an early and one might argue more felicitous name than “macroeconomics”.  In an earlier post the reading list for Robert Dorfman’s aggregate economic theory course has been transcribed. This post adds his final exam questions.

During the second term of 1958-1959 the same course content was taught by Dorfman as “Economics 241. Money and Banking”.

_________________________

Course Announcement

Economics 241. Aggregate Economic Theory

Half course (fall term). M., W., (F.), at 12. Professor Dorfman.

Source: Harvard University, Faculty of Arts and Sciences. Courses of Instruction for Harvard and Radcliffe, 1962-1963, p. 106.

_________________________

Course Final Examination

HARVARD UNIVERSITY
Department of Economics

Economics 241

Midyear Examination
January 30, 1963

Answer any THREE questions. Spend about an hour on each, and develop your discussion to corresponding fulness. In each answer include citations to the literature where relevant. Please write legibly. Indicate which questions you answered on the cover of your first book.

  1. Among the simplifying assumptions made by Keynes are:
    1. The rate of interest does not enter into the consumption function,
    2. The level of income does not enter into the marginal efficiency of capital function,
    3. The level of income does not enter into the liquidity preference function.

Discuss the consequences of relaxing these assumptions, singly and in combination, for the equilibrium analysis and stability of an economy that can be described by a Keynesian-type model.

  1. It is sometimes argued that the Keynesian theory is nothing but a classical theory where price-rigidities are permitted in certain markets and where the velocity of money circulation depends on the rate of interest. Defend or refute this position.
  2. Compare the Swedish theory of the cumulative process, as expounded by Wicksell or Ohlin, with Harrod’s explanation of dynamic instability. Bring out the elements common to the two theories as well as the contrasts between them.
  3. One of Gurley and Shaw’s main conclusions is that if a central bank “stipulates not only the nominal reserves of commercial banks but the reserve-balance as well … [it will be] able to regulate creation of nominal money and the price level. Nominal money, nominal bonds, and money prices of goods and labor are now determinate.” (pp. 261-262) Sketch their model and the argument leading to this conclusion.
  4. Appraise the importance of the interest rate as a determinant of (a) the level of investment and (b) the level of employment.

Source: Harvard University Archives. Final Examinations. January 1963. Social Sciences. (HUC 700.28, No. 144 of 284).

Image Source: See the 27 June 2002 Boston Globe obituary for Robert Dorfman.

Categories
Exam Questions Harvard Macroeconomics Microeconomics Theory

Harvard. Graduate General Exams in Micro- and Macro-Theory. Fall 1993

The following general examination for macroeconomic theory (Spring 1993) has been transcribed from a collection of general exams at Harvard from the 1990s provided to Economics in the Rear-view Mirror by Abigail Waggoner Wozniak (Harvard economics Ph.D., 2005). Abigail Wozniak was an associate professor of economics at Notre Dame before being appointed a senior research economist and the first director of the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis’ Opportunity & Inclusive Growth Institute. She is currently Vice-President of the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis.

Economics in the Rear-view Mirror is most grateful for her generosity in sharing this valuable material.

Because the “Wozniak collection” is over 90 pages long, it will take time for all the exams to get transcribed. To date the following general examinations have been transcribed and posted:

Spring 1991
Microeconomics; Macroeconomics

Spring 1992
Micro- and Macroeconomics

Fall 1992
Micro- and Macroeconomics

Spring 1993
Microeconomics; Macroeconomics

_________________________

HARVARD UNIVERSITY
DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS

GENERAL EXAMINATION
IN MICROECONOMIC THEORY
FALL 1993

Instructions:

You have FOUR hours.

Answer a total of FOUR questions, subject to the following constraints:

You must answer questions 1, 2, and 3. You must answer either question 4 or 5 (but not both).

Please use a separate blue book for each question.

Please put only your exam number on the blue book.

Good luck!

1. Indirect Utility (20 points)

This is a question on the indifference map of indirect utility functions.

There are two commodities. The utility function is U(x_1, x_2). Wealth is normalized to w=1, so that the indirect utility function has the form V(p_1, p_2).

Assume that U(x_1, x_2) is continuous and increasing in both arguments.

a) Draw an indifference map of the indirect utility function. Be sure that the axes are properly labelled, that the indifference curves have the proper shape and that the direction of increasing preference is clearly marked. (5 points)

b) Argue that if the utility function U(x_1, x_2) is not quasi-concave then some indirect indifference curve will exhibit a kink. (5 points)

c) Suppose that an indifference curve of the indirect utility function has a piece that is a straight line. What does this correspond to in the direct utility function? Why? (5 points)

d) Consider the slope of an indifference curve of the indirect utility function. Interpret it in terms of the demand function. Justify your answer. (5 points)

2. (20 points)

Consider an industry in which there are two firms: an incumbent and a potential entrant. In each of two periods, total inverse demand in the industry is given by

p = 5 - Q,

where Q is total output. The incumbent’s marginal cost of production c_I can either be “high” (c_I = 2) or “low” (c_I = 1). The incumbent knows the value of c_I, but the potential entrant knows only that the two values each have a 50% probability ex ante. In the first period, the incumbent chooses an output level q_{I1}. The entrant can observe q_{I1} (but not the incumbent’s profit). In the second period the two firms choose quantities q_{I2} and q_{E2} simultaneously. The entrant’s marginal cost c_E is 2. In addition, if the entrant chooses q_{E2} > 0, it incurs an “entry” cost of \frac{1}{2}. The two firms each maximize their (expected) profits (the incumbent maximizes the expected sum of its first- and second-period profits). The model and all its parameters are common knowledge (the value of c_I is not common knowledge, but the fifty-fifty prior distribution on 1 and 2 is common knowledge).

A. Suppose that the entrant concludes, after observing q_{I1}, that the incumbent’s costs are low (i.e., the entrant attaches posterior probability 1 to c_I = 1). Show that, in this case, the entrant will not enter. That is, show that q_{E2} = 0 in the unique continuation equilibrium starting in period 2. What are the incumbent’s second-period output and profit in this continuation equilibrium?

B. Suppose that the entrant concludes, after observing q_{I1}, that the incumbent’s costs are high (c_I = 2). Show that, in this case, the entrant will enter, i.e., choose q_{E2} > 0, in equilibrium. Find the second-period continuation equilibrium outputs and profits for both firms.

C. Using the results from parts (A) and (B), show that there exists a “separating” perfect Bayesian equilibrium for the two-period model in which (i) the incumbent chooses a “small” value of q_{I1} if c_I = 2 and a “big” value if c_I = 1, and (ii) the entrant enters if and only if q_{I1} was small. In particular, show that q_{I1} is at the high-cost monopoly level if c_I = 2 but strictly above the low-cost monopoly level if c_I = 1.

3. Gross Substitute Excess Demand (20 points)

Consider an excess demand system (f_1(p_1,\ldots,p_{L-1}),\ldots,f_{L-1}(p_1,\ldots,p_{L-1})). There is an Lth commodity for which price is 1 and for which demand is not explicitly recorded.

a) How would you determine the demand for the Lth commodity? (5 points)

b) Suppose that the excess demand system for all L commodities satisfies the gross substitute property (when the price of a single commodity goes up the excess demand of each of the other commodities increases). Argue that the competitive equilibrium is then unique. (5 points)

c) Suppose that the excess demand functions for all L commodities are differentiable and that as in (b) the gross substitute property holds. What is the sign pattern induced in the Jacobian matrix of price effects? (5 points)

d) Suppose that the excess demand functions for all L commodities are differentiable and satisfy the gross substitute property. Suppose now that there is a shock (if this is helpful you can limit yourself to a small shock) the effect of which is to decrease the demand for commodities 1 to L−1 at every vector of prices. What should be the effect of this shock on the equilibrium prices of commodities 1 to L−1? Give a justification of your answer which is as rigorous as possible. (5 points)

Part IV:
Answer ONE of the following two questions:

4. Suppose there is another energy shock and the world-market price of oil goes from its present price of under $20 per barrel to $100. Analyze the short and long term effects on growth and distribution from neoclassical, Marxian, and Keynesian perspectives on the simplifying assumption that all energy is imported at the world-market price.

5. Milton Friedman has argued (“The Methodology of Positive Economics”) that a theory should be judged not on the realism of its assumptions, but on its predictive power. What are the principal criticisms of Friedman’s view? How might Friedman respond to the criticisms?

_________________________

HARVARD UNIVERSITY
DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS

GENERAL EXAMINATION
IN MACROECONOMIC THEORY
FALL 1993

Instructions:

You have FOUR hours.

You will answer a total of SIX questions from four sections of the exam:

In section I, you must answer the one question given.
In section II, answer both questions.
In section III, answer one of the two questions.
In section IV, answer two of the three questions.

Please use a separate blue book for each question.

Please put only your exam number on the blue book.

Good luck!

PART I:

1. Suppose that each household-producer has the production function,

Y_i = AK_i \cdot (G/Y)^{\alpha},

where A>0, 0<\alpha<1. Y_i and K_i are the ith producer’s output and capital stock, respectively, G is the total of government purchases and public services, and Y is aggregate output. The output of all producers is identical and can be used on a one-for-one basis for consumption, investment, or government services. Each household seeks to maximize utility, given by the standard Ramsey expression,

\displaystyle U = \int_0^{\infty} \left(\frac{c^{1-\theta}-1}{1-\theta}\right) e^{-\rho t}\,dt,

where \theta>0, \rho>0, and c is consumption per person. The economy is closed, depreciation and population growth are zero, and no technological change occurs. The government finances its purchases by a proportional tax on output at the rate \tau:

G = \tau Y,

where \tau is constant over time.

a. What is the growth rate of Y? Does the model exhibit a convergence property? Why or why not?

b. How does the growth rate depend on \tau? What condition holds if \tau is chosen to maximize the growth rate?

c. Are the outcomes Pareto optimal if \tau is set to maximize the growth rate? How does this result relate to the usual view that lump-sum taxation is superior to proportional taxation?

PART II:
Answer BOTH questions:

2.—

a.) Under what assumptions does the permanent income hypothesis predict that consumption should follow a random walk?

b.) Derive explicitly the random walk of result (a).

c.) Discuss briefly what you know about the empirical evidence on the random walk.

d.) Consider a pre-announced future temporary tax cut. What are the effects on consumption of this policy before, during, and after the tax cut? Consider the cases of: (1) the life cycle model; (2) the life cycle model with bequests, (3) the Keynesian consumption function; (4) a life cycle model with liquidity constraints.

3. Consider a monopolistic trade union, that can unilaterally set the nominal wage. The union’s utility function is:

\displaystyle U = \left(\frac{w}{p}\right)^{\frac{1}{2}} + \beta N

Where: w is the nominal wage
p is the price level
N is employment
and \beta>0 is a parameter.

\displaystyle N = n_0 - \alpha\frac{w}{p},

where n_0>0 and \alpha>0 are parameters

1) Suppose first that p is fixed, and compute what is the nominal wage chosen by the union.

2) Suppose that a monetary authority can influence the price level with monetary policy, and suppose that the union can change the nominal wage at any time but with a small cost; that is, any change in the nominal wage has a very small administrative cost for the union. Discuss the effects of monetary policy in this model.

PART III:
Answer ONE of the following two questions:

4. Consider the case of a central bank conducting monetary policy in a standard fractional reserve banking system. The central bank can set either the short-term interest rate or the quantity of bank reserves (but not both simultaneously) to whatever level is chosen. What factors determine the central bank’s optimal choice of which one to set, under each of the following sets of circumstances?

(a) The central bank is trying to come as close as possible to hitting a target for the money stock (defined as public holdings of bank deposits).

(b) The central bank is trying to come as close as possible to hitting a target for real output.

In answering each part, show explicitly what difference (if any) it makes whether the economy is subject to aggregate supply shocks or whether demand-type disturbances are the only ones the economy faces.

5. Under what conditions can a central bank’s prior announcements of its policy actions influence the macroeconomic effect of those actions? If the central bank is free to conduct a politically independent monetary policy, what determines whether it will then actually implement the actions it has announced? Be explicit about the assumptions on which your answer relies.

PART IV:
Answer TWO of the following THREE questions:

6. Consider an unemployed worker searching for work. Each period she draws a wage offer w from a distribution F(w). Assume that there are no quits or layoffs so once the worker accepts a job, she works at it forever. Assume that wages in future periods are discounted by \beta.

(a) Write a Bellman equation that characterizes the value of an optimal search policy given a current offer of w.

(b) The optimal policy is to set a reservation wage. Explain what this means and write an equation that implicitly defines the reservation wage.

(c) Suppose that the worker only receives a wage offer with probability \phi each period. Explain in words or equations what happens to the reservation wage and why?

(d) Suppose that the worker receives two wage offers each period. Explain in words or equations what happens to the reservation wage and why?

7. Consider the following open economy macroeconomic model

(1) Y = f(K, L)
(2) W/P = f_L
(3) Y = C(Y) + G + NX(e, Y)
(4) e = EP^*/P
(5) M/P = L(Y)

Where asterisks denote foreign variables, NX is net exports, E is the nominal exchange rate and all other variables have their usual interpretations.

(a) What is the sign of \partial NX/\partial e? Explain.

(b) Suppose that workers and firms set nominal wage contracts:

W = \bar{W}

What is the effect of a change in M or in G on Y?

(c) Suppose that wages are indexed to the CPI:

W = \bar{w}P^{\alpha}(EP^*)^{1-\alpha}

What is the effect of a change in M or in G on Y?

8. Suppose that price in a market is initially equal to zero, but is expected to rise linearly with time:

p(t) = \alpha t.

Suppose that you have a machine that costs k to install and once installed produces a unit flow of output. Time is continuous and the date zero present value of a dollar at date t is e^{-rt}.

(a) At what date t should you have the machine installed in order to maximize profits?

(b) What is the present value of profits at the optimal time of investment?

(c) What is the value of Tobin’s Q at the optimal time of investment? What did Tobin argue should be the relationship between Q and investment? Speculate about what is special about the case considered here.

Source: Department of Economics, Harvard University. Past General Exams, Spring 1991-Spring 1999, pp. 84-88. Private copy of Abigail Waggoner Wozniak.

Image Source: Harvard University Economics PhD graduates from May 2025.