Categories
Exam Questions Johns Hopkins Undergraduate

Johns Hopkins. Final exams for undergraduate economics courses. 1911-1912

Six semester courses in political economy was Johns Hopkins University’s entire offerings for undergraduates interested in the field of economics in 1911-12.

_____________________________

Instructors of Political Economy
(Undergraduate)

JACOB H. HOLLANDER, Ph. D., Professor of Political Economy. A.B., Johns Hopkins University, 1891, Fellow, 1893-94, and Ph.D., 1894. Treasurer of the Island of Porto Rico, 1900-01; Special Commissioner Plenipotentiary to Santo Domingo, 1905-06; Financial Adviser of the Dominican Republic, 1908-10.

GEORGE ERNEST BARNETT, Professor of Statistics. A.B., Randolph-Macon College, 1891; Fellow, Johns Hopkins University, 1899-1900, and Ph.D., 1901.

_____________________________

UNDERGRADUATE COURSES

Political Economy 1.

[Political Economy 1 is required to later attend Polical Economy 2 and 3.]

(a) Economic History. The economic development of England from the tenth century to the present time and the most important experiences of the United States are studied.

Three hours weekly, first half-year.
Professor BARNETT.

(b) Elements of Economics. Particular attention is given to the theory of distribution and its application to leading economic problems.

Three hours weekly, second half-year.
Professor BARNETT.

Political Economy 2.

[Undergraduate Course 2 is open only to such students as have completed Course 1]

(a) Finance. The theory and practice of finance are considered, with particular reference to problems of taxation as presented in the experience of the United States.

Three hours weekly, first half-year.
Professor HOLLANDER.

(b) Money and Banking. The principles of monetary science are taught with reference to practical conditions in modern systems of currency, banking, and credit.

Three hours weekly, second half-year.
Professor BARNETT.

Political Economy  3.

[Save under exceptional circumstances, Course 3 only to students who have completed 1 and 2.]

(a) Statistical Methods. After a preliminary study of the value and place of statistics as an instrument of investigation, attention is directed to the chief methods used in statistical inquiry.

Three hours weekly, first half-year.
Professor BARNETT.

(b) Economic Theory. Critical study is made of recent economic theories.

Three hours weekly, second half-year.
Professor HOLLANDER.

Source: Programmes of Courses. Published in The Johns Hopkins University Circular, New Series, 1911, No. 6 (June 1911) Whole Number, 236.

____________________________

[December, 1911.]

POLITICAL ECONOMY I [a].

  1. Distinguish the one-field, two-field and three-field systems of agriculture.
  2. Describe the government of the craft guild in the fourteenth century.
  3. Discuss the growth of capitalism and its influence on the concept of usury.
  4. Describe the craft guild stage of industry and distinguish it from succeeding and preceding stages.
  5. What economic effects are traceable to the Black Death?
  6. What place did Fairs fill in the organization of economic life in the fifteenth century?
  7. What is meant by an economic unit?
  8. Describe the chief economic institutions which have their origin in the seventeenth century.
  9. Describe the chief mechanical inventions from 1738 to 1790.
  10. What relation is there between the extent or width of the economic unit and the form of industrial organization?

____________________________

[March, 1912.]

POLITICAL ECONOMY I [b].

  1. How far is saving economically justifiable?
  2. What are the advantages of the corporation as a form of business organization?
  3. Define elasticity of demand. Draw and explain two demand curves, one representing an elastic and one an inelastic demand.
  4. Is it correct to say that the demand for a commodity is greater than the supply?
  5. Explain what is meant by consumers’ surplus. Illustrate by a diagram.
  6. Under what circumstances would monopoly price be less than competitive price?
  7. Define cost of production. Under what conditions does the value of a commodity tend to equal its cost of production.
  8. State and illustrate the economic laws relating to (a) the size of the business unit and (b) the proportion of the factors of production.

____________________________

[June, 1912]

POLITICAL ECONOMY I [b].

  1. Trace the attachment of the entrepreneurial function through the different economic stages.
  2. At what period in economic evolution did capital become a claimant in distribution?
  3. What is the “principle of marginal productivity?” Explain the relation of this principle to the law of diminishing returns.
  4. Explain what is meant by the “marginal laborer.” Distinguish the marginal laborer and the marginal unit of labor.
  5. What is meant by “the differential principle?” Show to what parts of the theory of distribution this principle is applicable.
  6. Discuss the arguments for and against the single tax.
  7. What effect does the invention of machinery have on the rate of interest?
  8. Distinguish between the “annual product” and the “annual social dividend.”
  9. Distinguish competitive and monopoly profits.
  10. Would a tax on the value of agricultural land raise the price of farm products?

____________________________

December 16, 1911.

POLITICAL ECONOMY II [a].

  1. The scope of Public Finance, as a study, and its relation to the science of Political Economy.
  2. In what particulars does the economy of the state differ from the economy of the individual?
  3. What policy should influence the distribution of public expenditure upon education between central and local government?
  4. Show the importance of economic or quasi-private receipts as a source of revenue to the federal government in the United States and in Germany respectively.
  5. State the arguments for and against (a) proportional, and (b) progressive taxation.
  6. Discuss the merits and demerits of the taxation of incomes.
  7. Discuss the incidence of an excise tax on manufactured tobacco (cigars and cigarettes).

____________________________

[March, 1912]

POLITICAL ECONOMY II [b].

  1. Discuss the physical characteristics of a good medium of exchange.
  2. Under what circumstances does bad money drive out good money?
  3. What evils flow from instability in the value of the medium of exchange?
  4. State the quantity theory of money.
  5. Discuss Professor Scott’s objections to this theory.
  6. Explain the compensatory action of the bimetallic system. Illustrate by a series of diagrams.

____________________________

[June 1912]

POLITICAL ECONOMY II [b].

  1. What is the “unearned increment tax” and how can it be used in American municipal finance?
  2. What is the incidence of the high license tax on saloons in Baltimore City?
  3. Define money. Is a bank check money?
  4. Would it be possible to have a monetary system under which fluctuations in prices would not occur?
  5. Describe the governmental organization of the Bank of France.
  6. What advantages are there in a system of branch banks?
  7. What is the purpose of a bank reserve? Under what circumstances would a bank need no reserve?
  8. Compare the bank note circulation in the United States and France.
  9. Compare the methods used by the Bank of England and the Bank of France for the protection of their reserves against foreign drain.
  10. Explain the method by which in an emergency the Bank of England brings the market rate up to the bank rate? Why does it do this?

____________________________

[December, 1911.]

POLITICAL ECONOMY III [a].

  1. What is the distinction between cause and chance?
  2. What is a “crude” death rate? Explain in detail how the standard death rate is obtained.
  3. What is meant by a “measure of dispersion?” What is the most usual one?
  4. Define the field of investigation in which the statistical method is useful.
  5. Under what circumstances is the geometric mean a useful form of average?
  6. Define percentile, quartile, mode and arithmetic mean.
  7. Explain the two chief methods of gathering statistical information. Under what circumstances may each be properly used?
  8. Explain the theory of weighting.

____________________________

Note: no March 1912 examination for Political Economy III was found in the collection of examination

____________________________

May 31, 1912.

FINAL EXAMINATION
IN POLITICAL ECONOMY III.

  1. What has been the relation of statistical science to the development of insurance?
  2. What is the relation of statistics to economics?
  3. Discuss the economies incident to large scale production.
  4. What are the economic services, if any, of speculation?
  5. Monopoly value and the law which governs it.
  6. What defects in our national banking system might a central banking institution, of the European type, be expected to remedy?
  7. Discuss the theory of international trade.
  8. What is the function of the entrepreneur and what principle determines his share in distribution?

Source for the examination questions: The Johns Hopkins University, Eisenhower Library. Ferdinand Hamburger, Jr. Archives. Department of Political Economy. Series 5/6. Box 6/1. Folder “Exams, 1907-1924”.

Image Source: Johns Hopkins University seal on the floor of Gilman Hall, on the Johns Hopkins University campus in Baltimore, Maryland. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C.

Categories
Agricultural Economics Exam Questions Harvard

Harvard. Agricultural economics. Description, enrollment, final exam. Carver, 1912-1913

 

In 1911 Harvard economics professor Thomas Nixon Carver published a textbook Principles of Rural Economics  that undoubtedly encompassed the content of his course on agricutural economics first taught in 1903-04. Somewhat unusually his book is prefaced with an eight page bibliography.

________________________

Carver’s Earlier Courses
on Agricultural Economics

Links to earlier course material for agricultural economics at Harvard, 1903-04 through 1911-12.

_______________________

ECONOMICS 32
Course Description
1912-13

[Economics] 32 2hf (formerly 23 2hf). Economics of Agriculture, with special reference to American conditions. Half-course (second half-year). Tu., Th., and (at the pleasure of the instructor) Sat., at 9. Professor Carver.

A study of the relation of agriculture to the whole industrial system, the relative importance of rural and urban economics, the conditions of rural life in different parts of the United States, the forms of land tenure and methods of rent payment, the comparative merits of large and small holdings, the status and wages of farm labor, the influence of farm machinery, farmers’ organizations, the marketing and distribution of farm products, agricultural credit, the policy of the government toward agriculture, and the probable future of American agriculture.

Source: Harvard University. Division of History, Government, and Economics, Courses of Instruction, 1912–13, p. 67.

_______________________

ECONOMICS 32
Course Enrollment
1912-13

[Economics] 32 2hf (formerly 23 2hf). Professor Carver. — Economics of Agriculture, with special reference to American conditions.

Total 11: 8 Graduates; 2 Seniors; 1 Junior.

Source: Harvard University. Reports of the President and the Treasurer of Harvard College, 1912-13, p. 58.

_______________________

ECONOMICS 32
Year-end Examination
1912-13

  1. What are some of the larger characteristics which distinguish rural from urban life?
  2. Where would you draw the line between large scale and medium scale, and between medium scale and small scale farming, and what are the principal advantages and disadvantages of each?
  3. Exactly what is the distinction between intensive and extensive farming, and what are the advantages and disadvantages of each?
  4. To what system of culture does the horse as a draft animal belong, and what are some of the characteristics of that system?
  5. Where do we find the larger percentage of tenancy in this country, where land is highly productive or where its productivity is low? How would you explain the situation?
  6. Give your ideas as to the function of the middle-man, and to what extent and how that function may be performed by the farmers themselves.
  7. What are the advantages of diversified farming as compared with specialized farming?
  8. Give your ideas as to how country life may be made more attractive to men and women of education and culture.

Source: Harvard University Examinations. Papers set for final examinations in history, history of science, government, economics, philosophy, social ethics, education, fine arts, music in Harvard College (June 1913), p. 56.

Image Source: The American Farmer by Carl Wuermer (1930) at the Wichita Art Museum website.

________________________

Earlier material

ca. 1904 Problem set
1903-04 Final exam
1905-06 Final exam
1908-09 Description, enrollment, final exam
1910-11 Description, enrollment, final exam
1911-12 Description, enrollment, final exam

 

Categories
Development Exam Questions Harvard

Harvard. Economy of Latin America. Syllabus, Readings, Final Exam. Clague, 1965-1966

In preparing this post that features course materials from the second term of the 1965-66 academic year at Harvard for Christopher K. Clague’s “Economy of Latin America”, I ran across obituaries for his distinguished parents, Ewan Clague (Ph.D. Wisconsin, 1929. Thesis: Theory and Measurement of Physical Productivity, major professors Commons & Jerome) and Dorothy V. Whipple (M.D. Johns Hopkins, 1929. Pediatrician, syndicated columnist). Not only was Christopher Clague’s father a trained economist, he also served as the sixth Commissioner of the Bureau of Labor Statistics under Presidents Truman, Eisenhower, Kennedy, and Johnson. I have appended short bios for his mother and father as well as for his wife, Harvard trained political scientist, Monique F. Clague (Weston).

But the top of the post is reserved for a brief c.v. of Christopher Karran Clague, Harvard Ph.D. alumnus (1966). Following the stations of his distinguished career, Economics in the Rear-view Mirror provides transcribed copies of his course outline, assigned readings and final examination.

_______________________

Christopher Karran Clague

1938. Born May 28 in Washington, D.C. Parents: Ewan Clague  and Dorothy Vermilya Whipple.

Graduate of St. Alban’s School in Bridgeport, Ct.

1960. B.A. in political science (honors), magna cum laude, Swarthmore College. Phi Beta Kappa, Senior Class President.

1960. Married Monique Françoise Weston, June 9 in Cleveland, Ohio.

1966. Ph.D. in Economics. Harvard University. Thesis “Economic Efficiency in Peru and the United States.”

1965-67. Instructor in Economics. Harvard University.

1967-68. Senior staff economist. Council of Economic Advisers, Washington, D.C.

1968-71. Assistant Professor. University of Maryland.

1971-79. Associate Professor. University of Maryland.

1974-75. Visiting professor at Boston University’s Center for Latin American Development Studies.

1979-. Professor of Economics. University of Maryland [now emeritus]

1983. Visiting Professor at the University of California, Berkeley.

1983-89. National Bureau of Economic Research, member of executive committee, Conference on Research in Income and Wealth.

1990. Visiting Professor at the University of Hawaii at Manoa.

1990. Visiting Professor at the University of Nottingham.

_______________________

Economic 116.
The Economy of Latin America

Dr. Christopher Clague
Harvard University

Course Outline.

  1. International Trade and Economic Development
    Case Studies: Argentina, Uruguay, Venezuela.
  2. Capital Accumulation; Social and Political Factors; Economic Policy: The Price Mechanism versus Direct Controls.
    Case Studies: Chile, Brazil.
  3. Agriculture in Economic Development; Land Reform
    Case Studies: Mexico, Bolivia, Peru, Colombia.
  4. Inflation

Suggested Purchases. The number of pages to be read in each book is given in parentheses.

  1. Gerald M. Maier, Leading Issues in Development Economics. New York: Oxford University Press, 1964. (63 pages)
  2. John J. Johnson, Political Change in Latin America. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press, 1961. (135 pages)
  3. Martin C. Needler, editor, Political Systems of Latin America. Princeton, New Jersey: D. Van Nostrand Company, 1964. (Chapters on Colombia, Peru, Bolivia, Argentina, Uruguay. 145 pages.)
  4. Edwin Lieuwen, Venezuela. 2nd Edition revised. New York: Oxford University Press, 1965 (122 pages)
  5. A. O. Hirschman, Journeys Toward Progress. New York: Doubleday and Company (Anchor Books, paperback), 1965. (Chapters on Colombia and Chile. 168 pages).
  6. Celso Furtado, The Economic Growth of Brazil. Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1963. (152 pages).
  7. Theodore W. Schultz, Transforming Traditional Agriculture. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1964. (110 pages).
  8. Albert O. Hirschman, editor, Latin American Issues. New York: Twentieth Century Fund, 1961. (paperback). (83 pages).
  9. Lester R. Brown, Increasing World Food Output, Foreign Agricultural Economic Report No. 25, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Economic Research Service, Foreign Regional Analysis Division, April 1965. (Can be purchased from: Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C. 20402. Price $.45) (115 pages).
  1. International Trade and Economic Development
    1. The Contribution of Trade to Development
      1. — Meier, Leading Issues:
        — G. Haberler, “Dynamic Benefits of Trade”, pp. 352-358
        — R. Nurkse, “Patterns of Trade and Development”, pp. 358-363
        — A. Cairncross, “Contribution of Trade to Development”, pp. 363-371
        — R. Prebisch, “Center and Periphery”, pp. 339-344
        — G. Meier, “The Carry-Over Problem”, pp. 371-376
      2. — G. Haberler, “Terms of Trade and Economic Development”, in Howard S. Ellis, Economic Development for Latin America, pp. 275-297
    2. Case Studies of Trade and Development
      1. Argentina
        — Johnson, Political Change, Chapter 6.
        — J. Barager, “Argentina” in Needler, Political Systems.
        — A. Smithies, “Argentina and Australia”, American Economic Association Papers and Proceedings, May 1965, pp. 17-30.
        — S. Mosk, “Latin America and the World Economy, 1850-1914”, Inter-American Economic Affairs. (Hereinafter referred to as IEA), Winter 1948, pp. 53-82.

Suggested:
— UN, ECLA, Analyses and Projections of Economic Development: The Economic Development of Argentina.
— Arthur Whitaker, The U.S. and Argentina
— Aldo Ferrer, La Economia Argentina
— J. Black, “Observations on the Agriculture of Argentina”, Journal of Farm Economics, May 1957, pp. 468-477,

      1. Uruguay
        — Johnson, Chapter 4.
        — G. Lindahl, “Uruguay” in Needler.
      1. Venezuela
        — E. Lieuwen, Venezuela (1965 Edition), pp. 64-163, 177-200.
      1. Peru in the Guano Age
        — Jonathan V. Levin, The Export Economies, pp. 1-48, 77-91, 108-123.
  1. Capital Accumulation and Growth; Social and Political Policy: Price Mechanism versus Direct Controls.
    1. The Big-Push Theory
      1. — Meier, Leading Issues:
        — P. Rosenstein-Rodan, “The Theory of the ‘Big-Push,'” pp. 431-436.
        — R. Nurkse, “Balanced Growth”, pp. 250-254.
        — A. Hirschman, “Balanced Growth: A Critique”, pp. 254-259.

Suggested:
— E. Hagen, On the Theory of Social Change, Chapter 3, pp. 36-52.

    1. Political Obstacles to Growth
      1. — Paul Baran, “On the Political Economy of Backwardness”, in Agarwala and Singh, The Economics of Underdevelopment, pp. 75-93 (orginally in The Manchester School, January, 1952).
    2. Economic Policy: Price Mechanism versus Direct Controls
      1. — Meier, Leading Issues:
        — P. Rosenstein-Rodan, “The Flaw in the Mechanism of Market Forces”, pp. 416-18.
        — H. Johnson, “The Market Mechanism as an Instrument of Development”, pp. 425-431
        — G. Meier, “Import Substitution and Industrial Protection”, pp. 297-304.
      1. — T. Balogh, “Economic Policy and the Price System”, Economic Bulletin for Latin America, March 1961.
      2. — W. Baer, “The Economics of Prebisch and ECLA”, Economic Development and Cultural Change, January 1962, pp. 169-182 (hereinafter referred to as EDCC.)

Suggested:
— J. Marshall, “Exchange Controls and Economic Development”, in H. Ellis, ed., Economic Development, pp. 430-451; also comment by Hirschman, pp. 457-465.

    1. Case Studies:
      1. Chile
        — Johnson, Chapter 5.
        — David Felix, “Chile” in Adamantios Pepelasis et al, Economic Development, pp. 288-323.
        — Eric Baklanoff, “Chilean Experience with Multiple Exchange Rates”, IEA, Summer, 1959.
        — A. Hirschman, Journeys Toward Progress, Chapter 3, pp. 215-293.

Suggested:
— P. T. Ellsworth, Chile, An Economy in Transition (1945)
— Ernst Halperin, Nationalism and Communism in Chile (1965).

— See also the section on Inflation.

      1. Brazil
        — Johnson, Chapter 8.
        — H. Spiegel, “Brazil: The State and Economic Growth”, in Simon Kuznets et al, editors, Economic Growth: Brazil, India, Japan.
        — Celso Furtado, The Economic Growth of Brazil, pp. 97-249

Suggested:
— Other articles on Brazil in the volume edited by Kuznets.
— W. Baer, Industrialization and Economic Growth in Brazil (1965).
— W. Baer, “Regional Inequality and Economic Growth in Brazil”, EDCC, April 1964.

  1. The Role of Agriculture; Land Reform
    1. Agriculture and Economic Development
      1. — T. W. Schultz, Transforming Traditional Agriculture, pp. 1-110.
      2. — Johnston and Mellor, “The Role of Agriculture in Economic Development”, American Economic Review, September 1961, pp. 566-591.
      3. — J. Mellor, “The Process of Agricultural Development in Low-Income Countries”, Journal of Farm Economics, August 1962, pp. 700-17.
      4. — Thomas Carroll, “The Land Reform Issue in Latin America”, in Hirschman, Latin American Issues, pp. 161-200.
      5. — Lester Brown, Increasing World Food Output, pp. 1-115
    2. Case Studies
      1. Mexico
        — Johnson, Chapter 7.
        — Robert Edminster, “Mexico”, in Adamantios Pepelasis, Economic Development, pp. 326-364.
        — Raymond Vernon, The Dilemma of Mexico’s Development, Chapters 1-4; Chap. 7.
        — Richard Parks, “The Role of Agriculture in Mexican Economic Development”, IEA, Summer 1964.

Suggested:
—  A. Sturmthal, “Economic Development, Income Distribution, and Capital Formation in Mexico”, Journal of Political Economy, June 1955.
— R. Scott, Mexican Government in Transition, esp. pp. 56-95.

      1. Bolivia
        — Robert Alexander, “Bolivia”, in Needler

Suggested:
— Richard Patch, “Bolivia: U.S. Assistance in a Revolutionary Setting”, in Council on Foreign Relations, Social Change in Latin America Today, pp. 108-176

      1. Peru
        — Rosendo Gomez, “Peru”, in Needler
        — Allan Holmberg, “Changing Community Attitudes and Values in Peru: A Case Study in Guided Change” in Social Change (see reference under Bolivia), pp. 63-107.
      1. Colombia
        — J. Martz, “Colombia”, in Needler
        — A. Hirschman, Journeys Toward Progress, Chapter 2, pp. 131-214.

Suggested:
— V. L. Fluharty, Dance of the Millions, 1930-1956.
— J. D. Martz, Colombia, A Contemporary Political Survey.
— Everett Hagen, On the Theory of Social Change, Chapter 15 (on Colombia), pp. 353-385.
— UN, ECLA, Analyses and Projections of Economic Development, III. The Economic Development of Colombia (1957).

  1. Inflation
    1. Causal Theory of Inflation: Structuralists and Monetarists
      1. — Hirschman, Latin American Issues: articles by Felix and Grumwald, pp. 95-125.
      2. — Meier, Leading Issues: R. Prebisch, pp. 207-210.
    2. The Effects of Inflation and How to Combat It
      1. — Meier, Leading Issues:
        ECAFE, “Inflation and Capital Formation”, pp. 170-174.
      2. — W. Baer, “Inflation and Growth in Brazil”, EDCC, October 1962, pp. 85-97.
      3. — E. Bernstein and I. Patel, “Inflation in Relation to Economic Development”, IMF Staff Papers, November 1952.
      4. — R. Campos, “Inflation and Balanced Growth” in H. Ellis, ed., Economic Development, pp. 82-103.
      5. — G. Dorrance, “The Effect of Inflation on Economic Development”, IMF Staff Papers, March 1963, pp. 1-44.
      6. — D. Felix, “A Critical Appraisal of the Monetarist-Structuralist Controversy”, in W. Baer and I. Kerstenetsky, editors, Inflation and Economic Growth, pp. 370-385. (Do not bother with the last part of the article.)

Suggested:
Other articles in the volume edited by Baer and Kerstenetsky.

Source: Harvard University Archives. Syllabi, course outlines and reading lists in Economics, 1895-2003. Box 9. Folder “Economics, 1965-1966 (1 of 2)”.

_______________________

Final Examination
Economics 116

June 4, 1966
Dr. Clague

Answer four questions.  Select one from each part.  (Those who have written papers may select four questions either from Parts I, II, and III, or from Parts I, II, and IV.)

I.
  1. Discuss one of the articles in the Reading Period assignment. Pick an article that you found especially interesting or significant.
    Add your own comments on the issue the author discusses.
  2. Which do you think are the most important valid arguments for tariff protection of industry in Latin American countries? Explain each argument in enough detail to make it evident that you understand it.
II.
  1. What are the obstacles to Chile’s exporting manufacturing products? Why might such exports be important for future economic growth?
  2. Discuss the Baran thesis in relation to Chile and Brazil in the twentieth century. To which country is it more applicable?  How have political alignments affected economic growth?
III.
  1. W. Schultz (in Transforming Traditional Agriculture) argues that peasants in traditional agriculture are thrifty, hardworking, and economically motivated. Yet they fail to adopt the new practices that would make their farms much more productive.  How does he reconcile these two propositions?  Do you agree?
  2. You are an economic adviser to President Belaunde Terry of Peru. He asks you to write a memorandum on land reform policy.  In particular, he wants to know what lessons, of relevance to Peru, might be drawn from the experience with land reform of Mexico, Bolivia, and Colombia.
    President Belaunde is interested in the growth of Peru’s per capita income, the welfare of the peasants, and his continuance in power.
IV.
  1. Explain how inflation could be used by the government to increase the rate of capital formation. What are the arguments against such a policy?
  2. Consider the following two propositions:
      1. Inflation is inevitable in an underdeveloped country that is attempting to industrialize.
      2. It follows from (i) that monetary stabilization programs, such as those proposed by the International Monetary Fund, are doomed to failure.

To what extent do you agree with each of these statements?

Source: Harvard University Archives. Harvard Faculty of Arts and Sciences. Papers Printed for Final Examinations in History, History of Religions, Government, Economics,… June 1966.

Image Sources: Ewon Clague portrait from The First Hundred Years of the Bureau of Labor Statistics by Joseph P. Goldberg and William T. Moye. September 1985, Bulletin 2235. Senior year portrait of Christopher K. Clague in the Swarthmore yearbook Halcyon 1960.

_______________________

Father: Ewan Clague

Born Dec. 27 1896 in Prescott, Washington. He married Dorothy Vermilya Whipple on June 14, 1924 in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. He died in April 12, 1987.

Ewan Clague, born in Prescott, Washington in 1896, was the sixth Bureau of Labor Statistics Commissioner. His education included the University of Washington and, after serving as an ambulance driver in World War I, the University of Wisconsin. Clague’s teacher, John R. Commons, recommended him to Commissioner Ethelbert Stewart, who hired Clague in 1926 to help develop productivity indexes. After finishing his project at the Bureau, Clague moved on to several other jobs, including working at the Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, studying the effects of mill closures for the Institute of Human Relations at Yale University, and serving as director of research and professor of social research at the Pennsylvania School of Social Work. In 1936, he was hired as Associate Director of Research and Statistics of the new Social Security Board, and was subsequently promoted to Director. In 1940, he became Director of the Bureau of Employment Security. When Clague was appointed Commissioner of the Bureau of Labor Statistics in 1946, he came to the office as a trained economist and experienced civil servant. [Retired from office on September 14, 1965 during his fifth term as Commissioner]

Source: https://www.bls.gov/bls/history/commissioners/clague.htm

 

Mother: Dorothy Vermilya Whipple

Born November 22, 1900 in Toledo Ohio. Died May 5, 1995 in Washington, D.C.

Speed skater at the University of Wisconsin, where she earned her B.A. and M.A. First married woman admitted to Johns Hopkins Medical School (M.D., 1929). Pediatrician. Published Our American Babies (1944). Most of the revisions in the 1942 Federal pamphlet Infant Care  were prepared by her and Dr. Marian M. Crane. Syndicated weekly newspaper column on child care. Two other books: Euthenic Pediatrics and Q: Is the Grass Greener? Answers to Questions About Drugs (1971).

Obituary by David Stout in the New York Times, May 8, 1994.

Wife: Monique Françoise Weston

Born March 5, 1937 and grew up in Shaker Heights, Ohio. Graduated Shaker Heights High School, Ohio, 1955. College Junior year abroad at the London School of Economics in 1957-58. B.A. magna cum laude in Political Science at Swarthmore 1959, Phi Beta Kappa. Woodrow Wilson Fellowship for graduate study at Columbia University. Ph.D. Harvard 1969. Thesis: Heroic Leadership and Legalism: The Case of De Gaulle’s Légalité.” Professor of Education Policy, Planning, Administration at the University of Maryland [now emerita].

Categories
Exam Questions Harvard Public Finance

Harvard. Advanced Public Finance. Description, enrollment and final examination. Bullock, 1912-1913

Adam Smith appears in eight of the seventeen semester examination questions for Charles Jesse Bullock’s course on comparative public finance in 1912-13.

________________________

Earlier Advanced Public Finance

Links to earlier course material for advanced course in public finance from Harvard, 1905-06 through 1911-12.

_______________________

ECONOMICS 31
Course Description
1912-13

[Economics] 31 (formerly 16). Public Finance. Mon., Wed., and (at the pleasure of the instructor) Fri., at 10. Professor Bullock.

The course is devoted to the examination of the financial institutions of the principal modern countries, in the light of both theory and history. One or more reports calling for independent investigation will ordinarily be required. Special emphasis will be placed upon questions of American finance. Ability to read French or German is presupposed.

Source: Harvard University. Division of History, Government, and Economics, Courses of Instruction, 1912–13, p. 67.

_______________________

ECONOMICS 31
Course Enrollment
1912-13

[Economics] 31 (formerly 16). Professor Bullock. — Public Finance.

Total 7: 6 Graduates; 1 Junior.

Source: Harvard University. Reports of the President and the Treasurer of Harvard College, 1912-13, p. 58.

_______________________

ECONOMICS 31
Mid-year Examination
1912-13

  1. In estimating the pressure of public expenditures what considerations need to be taken into account?
  2. State and discuss the so-called laws of the increase of public expenditures.
  3. Discuss critically Smith’s, Wagner’s, Cohn’s, and Seligman’s classifications of public revenues.
  4. In what branches of expenditures may a decrease be expected either immediately or ultimately? Give reasons.
  5. Compare the opinions of Smith and Bastable concerning revenue from domains.
  6. Compare the opinions of Smith and Mill concerning justice in taxation.
  7. Compare the opinions of Smith and Mill concerning the best system of taxation for Great Britain.
  8. What is the opinion of Leroy-Beaulieu concerning the present and future of revenues from (a) domains, (b) public industries?
  9. What is the opinion of Eheberg concerning the present and future of revenues from (a) domain, (b) public industries?

Source: Harvard University. Mid-year examinations, 1852-1943. Box 9, bound volume Examination Papers, Mid-Years 1912-13. 

_______________________

ECONOMICS 31
Year-end Examination
1912-13

  1. How far does the present British system of taxation conform to the maxims of Adam Smith?
  2. How far does the present French system of taxation conform to Smith’s maxims?
  3. How far does the present Prussian system of taxation conform to Smith’s maxims?
  4. How far would the single tax on land values conform to Smith’s maxims?
  5. Compare the general property tax in Switzerland with the same tax in the United States.
  6. What changes in the general property tax have occurred in the United States in recent years?
  7. Discuss fully the opinions of Leroy-Beaulieu or Eheberg concerning the income tax.
  8. Discuss fully the opinions of Leroy-Beaulieu or Eheberg concerning the inheritance tax.

Source: Harvard University Examinations. Papers set for final examinations in history, history of science, government, economics, philosophy, social ethics, education, fine arts, music in Harvard College (June 1913), pp. 55-56.

Image Source: Beginning of Chapter II, Part II of Book V of Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations. This is where to find Smith’s four maxims on taxation.

________________________

Earlier Advanced Public Finance Courses

1905-06. Public Finance (advanced course).
1908-09. Public Finance (advanced course).
1910-11. Public Finance (advanced course).
1911-12. Public Finance (advanced course).

Categories
Exam Questions Harvard Public Finance Suggested Reading Syllabus

Harvard. Public Investment. Description, enrollment, exam. Marglin et al. 1966-1967

The scope of this interdisciplinary course from the mid-1960s is genuinely breathtaking. With his Harvard Ph.D. (1965) still fresh [Thesis: “Decentralized Resources Allocation With a Modicum of Increasing Returns.”], Stephen Marglin was on his famed meteoric rise to tenured professorship when he co-taught the following course on public investmen with political scientists and civil engineers.

For a later observation on his intellectual journey, see the brief profile article in The Harvard Crimson (14 November 2019) on “The Black Sheep of Harvard Economics” from which the image above has been clipped. He’s come a long way.

_______________________

Course Announcement

Economics 112 (formerly Government 257a). Public Investment: Techniques for Relating Economic Objectives, Engineering Analysis, and Government Planning (Offered Jointly with the Graduate School of Public Administration)

Half course (fall term). Th., 2-4, and a two-hour meeting to be arranged.
Assistant Professor S. Marglin and Professors Arthur Maass and H. A. Thomas.

New methods of economic, engineering, and governmental analysis in public investment planning. Techniques include those for converting broad community objectives into specific criteria used to design public projects. Emphasis on systems analysis.

Source:  Harvard University, Faculty of Arts and Sciences. Courses of Instruction for Harvard and Radcliffe, 1966-1967, p. 110.

_______________________

Course Instructors

Stephen Alan Marglin (1938- ) Assistant Professor of Economics.

Arthur Aaron Maass (1917-2004), Frank G. Thomson Professor of Government.

Harold A. Thomas, Jr. (1913-2002), Gordon McKay Professor of Civil and Sanitary Engineering.

Peter P. Rogers (1937-2018) (Ph.D. in Engineering 1966) Lecturer in Systems Analysis in the Graduate School of Design and a research associate in the Center for Population Studies.

George Herman Quester (1936-2023), Instructor of Government.

Henry D. Jacoby (1935-), Harvard economics Ph.D. 1967. Instructor of Economics.

_______________________

Fall Term
1966-67

Economics 112

PUBLIC INVESTMENT: TECHNIQUES FOR RELATING ECONOMIC OBJECTIVES, ENGINEERING ANALYSIS, AND GOVERNMENT PLANNING.

Assistant Professor S. Marglin, Professors A. Maass and H. A. Thomas, Drs. P. Rogers and G. Quester, and Mr. H. Jacoby.

Course Outline

A.    Formulating Public Investment Criteria Date
1. Introduction SM Sep. 29
2. Production and the Theory of the Firm HJ Oct. 4
Objectives: National Income and Its Distribution SM Oct. 6
3. Consumption and the Theory of the Household HJ Oct. 11
Selection of the Unit of Analysis and the Definition of Benefits and Costs HJ Oct. 13
4. Intertemporal Criteria HJ Oct. 18
Interest Rates and Uncertainty SM Oct. 20
5. Markets, Economic Efficiency and Welfare HJ Oct. 25
The Design Process: Methods of Analysis and Problems of Measurement HJ Oct. 27
B.     Objectives of Public Investment
1. Alternative Concepts of the Public Interest GQ Nov. 1
Multiple Objectives in Public Investment Programs AM Nov. 3
2. Concepts of Decision Making GQ Nov. 8
The Weighting of Objectives in the Political Process AM Nov. 10
C.     Applying Criteria in Project Design
1. The Mathematics of Optimization PR Nov. 15
Mathematical Models: Deterministic Models HAT Nov. 17
2. The Techniques of Systems Analysis PR Nov. 22
(To be announced) Nov. 29
Mathematical Models: Stochastic Models HAT Dec. 1
3. Computation Laboratory PR Dec. 6
Simulation HAT Dec. 8
(To be announced) Dec. 13
D.    Summary and Conclusions All Dec. 15
Problem Sets

Problem set #1 is due on November 1.
Problem set #2 is due on December 1.
Problem set #3 is due on January 12.

Source: Harvard University Archives. Syllabi, course outlines and reading lists in Economics, 1895-2003, Box 9, Folder “Economics, 1966-1967”.

_______________________

Fall Term
1966-67

Economics 112

PUBLIC INVESTMENT:
TECHNIQUES FOR RELATING ECONOMIC OBJECTIVES, ENGINEERING ANALYSIS, AND GOVERNMENT PLANNING.

Reading List

Recommended for purchase:

Maass, Hufschmidt, Dorfman, Thomas, Marglin, Fair, Design of Water-Resource Systems (1962).

All other readings on Reserve at Littauer or Lamont Libraries
Optional readings are starred

Readings for October 4:

P. Samuelson, Economics (4th or 5th edition), Chapters 24 & 26 (including appendices).

R. Dorfman, The Price System, Chapters 1 & 2 (1964).

Readings for October 6:

K. Boulding, “The Economist and the Engineer: Economic Dynamics of Water Resource Development,” in S. Smith and E. Castle (eds.) Economics and Public Policy in Water Resource Development (1964).

W. Heller, “Reflections on Public Expenditure Theory,” in Edmund Phelps, ed., Private Wants and Public Needs(1962).

J. Krutilla and O. Eckstein, Multiple Purpose River Development, Chapter 2 (1958).

J. Krutilla, “Welfare Aspects of Benefit-Cost Analysis,” 69 Journal of Political Economy 226-235 (1961).

S. Marglin, Public Investment Criteria, pp. 1-36 (1965).

Readings for October 11:

R. Dorfman, The Price System, Chapter 3 (1964).

T. Scitovsky, Welfare and Competition, Chapter IV, pp. 51-65 (1951).

Readings for October 13:

S. Marglin, Public Investment Criteria, pp. 37-46, 91-100 (1965).

R. Haveman, Water Resource Investment and the Public Interest, Chapters 3, 4, 5 (1965).

J. Tinbergen, The Design of Development, pp. 36-41, 76-87 (1958).

*Maass, Hufschmidt, et. al., Design of Water-Resource Systems, pp. 40-87 (1962).

Readings for October 18:

P. Samuelson, Economics (4th or 5th edition), Chapter 29 (including appendix).

I. Fisher, The Theory of Interest, Chapters V & VI (1930).

H. Bierman and S. Smidt, The Capital Budgeting Decision, Chapters 2 & 3 (1960).

Readings for October 20:

S. Marglin, Public Investment Criteria, pp. 46-77 (1965).

J. Krutilla and O. Eckstein, Multiple Purpose River Development, Chapter 2, pp. 32-40, and Chapter 4 (1958).

R. McKean, Efficiency in Government Through Systems Analysis, Chapter 4 (1958).

Maass, Hufschmidt, et. al., Design of Water-Resource Systems, pp. 129-158 (1962).

J. Hirshleifer, “Efficient Allocation of Capital in an Uncertain World,” 54 AER 77-85 (1964), and comment by P. Samuelson, 95-96.

*J. Hirshleifer, “Investment Decision Under Uncertainty — Choice-Theoretic Approaches,” 79 QJE 509-536 (1965).

*J. Hirshleifer, “Investment Decisions Under Uncertainty: Applications of the State-Preference Approach,” 80 QJE 252-277 (1966).

Readings for October 25:

P. Samuelson, Economics (4th or 5th edition), pp. 678-689.

R. Dorfman, The Price System, Chapters 4-6 (1964).

J. Graaff, Theoretical Welfare Economics, Chapters 1-3 (1957).

Readings for October 27:

Maass, Hufschmidt, et. al., Design of Water-Resource Systems, Chapter 3, pp. 88-118, and Chapter 5 (1962).

J. Rothenberg, “Urban Renewal Programs” in R. Dorfman, ed., Measuring Benefits of Government Investments(1965). Also skim the other articles in this collection.

Readings for November 1:

C. Friedrich, Constitutional Government and Democracy, Chapter 14.

R. Dahl and C. Lindblom, Politics, Economics and Welfare, pp. 25-56.

A. Downs, An Economic Theory of Democracy, pp. 3-74, 279-300.

Madison, The Federalist, No. 10.

D. Truman, The Governmental Process, Chapters 1, 2, 12 & 16.

Readings for November 3:

Maass, “Benefit-Cost Analysis: Its Relevance to Public Investment Decisions,” 80 QJE 208-226 (1966). Readpp. 208-218.

R. Musgrave, “The Public Interest: Efficiency in the Creation and Maintenance of Material Welfare,” Chapter 9 in Nomos 5: The Public Interest, C. Friedrich, ed. (1962).

G. Colm, “The Public Interest: Essential Key to Public Policy,” Chapter 10 in Nomos 5 (1962).

Maass, Hufschmidt, et. al., Design of Water-Resource Systems, Chapter 15 (1962).

C. Lindblom, “Decision-Making in Taxation and Expenditures” and Comments by A. Bergson and G. Colm, in Public Finances: Needs, Sources and Utilization (NBER Conference) pp. 295-336 (1961).

Readings for November 8:

R. Dahl and C. Lindblom, Politics, Economics, and Welfare, pp. 57-88, 294-368.

A. Downs, An Economic Theory of Democracy, pp. 114-163, 260-276.

E. Banfield, Political Influence, Chapter 12.

Readings for November 10:

A. Maass, “Benefit-Cost Analysis: Its Relevance to Public Investment Decisions,” 80 QJE 208-226. Read pp. 218-226.

D. Major, Decision Making for Public Investment in Water Resources Development, Chapters 2 & 6 (1965).

S. Dola, Passaic Valley Flood Control, mimeo (1965).

Readings for November 15:

R. Dorfman, “Mathematical or ‘Linear’ Programming: A Non-Mathematical Exposition,” 43 AER 797-825 (1953).

G. Hadley, Linear Programming, Chapter 1, pp. 1-21 (1962).

S. Gass, Linear Programming (2nd edition), Chapter 1, pp. 3-19 (1964).

*J. Henderson and R. Quandt, Microeconomic Theory, Appendices A2 & A3 (1958).

*P. Rogers, “A Note on Maximization,” mimeo (1964).

Readings for November 17:

H. A. Thomas and R. Revelle, “On the Efficient Use of High Aswan Dam for Hydropower and Irrigation,” in Management Science, Vol. 12, No. 8 (1966).

R. Dorfman, “Mathematical Analysis: Design of the Simple Valley Project,” in G. S. Tolley and F. E. Riggs (eds.) Economics of Watershed Planning (1960).

D. Kendrick, “Programming Investment with Interdependent Projects,” Center for International Studies, M.I.T., mimeo, pp. 1-16 (Jan. 1966).

Readings for November 22:

Maass, Hufschmidt, et. al., Design of Water-Resource Systems, Chapter 3, re-read pp. 129-158, and Chapter 12 (1962).

J. Kemeny and J. Snell, Mathematical Models in the Social Sciences, Appendix C, pp. 128-131.

*G. Hadley, Nonlinear and Dynamic Programming, Chapter 10, pp. 350-375 (1964).

*J.D.C. Little, “The Use of Water Storage in a Hydroelectric System,” J. Oper. Res. Soc. Am. 187 (1955).

*P. Massé, Optimal Investment Decisions, Chapter 7, pp. 320-335 (1962).

Readings for December 1:

Maass, Hufschmidt, et. al., Design of Water-Resource Systems, Chapter 13, pp. 524-539, and Chapter 14 (1962).

M. B. Fiering, “The Nature of the Storage-Yield Relationship,” Symposium on Streamflow Regulation for Quality Control, U.S.D.H.E.W., pp. 243-253 (June 1965).

Readings for December 6:

R. Fano and F. Corbató, “Time Sharing on Computers,” in Scientific American, Sept. 1966, pp. 128-148. Also flip through other articles in this issue.

Readings for December 18:

Maass, Hufschmidt, et. al., Design of Water-Resource Systems, Chapter 10 (1962).

G. Orcutt, “Simulation: A Symposium,” 50 AER 893-907 (1960).

G. Orcutt et. al., Microanalysis of Socioeconomic Systems, Chapters 1, 2 & 14 (1961).

M. Hufschmidt and M. B Fiering, Simulation Techniques for Design of Water-Resource Systems, Chapter 2 (1966).

Source: Harvard University Archives. Syllabi, course outlines and reading lists in Economics, 1895-2003, Box 9, Folder “Economics, 1966-1967”.

_______________________

HARVARD UNIVERSITY
Department of Economics

Final Examination
Economics 112

February 1, 1967

Answer any four of the following six questions.  All questions are of equal weight.  Please place each of your answers in a separate bluebook, and put your name on the cover of each book.

  1. “If lump sum transfers were administratively feasible, governments would be well advised to plan all investments to maximize profits, counting profits in the same way that private enterprise does.”
    Comment in the light of income redistribution and merit-want objectives, market imperfections (such as monopoly) and other considerations you think relevant.
  1. “If the government’s social rate of interest based on time preference differs from the marginal productivity of investment in the private sector, it is wrong to use the social rate of interest to plan public investment. The error arises from the fact that using the social rate of interest precludes the government from taking into account the value of private alternatives to public investment.”
    Comment.
  1. The problem is to compare and evaluate two ways of designing and authorizing public works projects:

(1) There are no useful legislated standards, so that engineers must use their engineering judgment for design. Projects so designed are then considered by policy makers (President and Congress) for inclusion in omnibus authorizing bills.

(2) Policy makers initiate, debate, and adopt standards for design of projects.  Engineers design them, and any projects that conform to the standards are considered to be authorized.

Assume that partisan mutual adjustment is the criterion for comparing and evaluating the two design methods — i.e., that “bargaining is at the heart of the governmental process.”  Compare and evaluate the design methods using the criterion given.

Evaluate the utility of partisan mutual adjustment as the evaluative criterion for this specific problem.

  1. Economists assume that the individual behaves selfishly on issues relevant to his monetary income; yet they ask political scientists to define an explicit public interest function as if such a function were of more than academic significance for participants in the legislative process.Is this inconsistent, or is there some political value to specifying an explicit public interest to be contrasted with the personal preferences of individuals?
  1. “Simulation methods are more useful for the planning of large scale public investment projects than the analytic methods of mathematical programming.”
    Discuss this statement and give your reasons for agreeing or disagreeing with it.
  1. The following simple model of a water resource system involves two reservoirs and two uses.One use is for domestic water supply for which no monetary benefit function is available but a water requirement is specified; the other use is one for which there is a direct market value.

The two reservoirs are shown in the sketch together with outflow vectors.  The outflow from Reservoir A can only be used for meeting the water supply requirement.  The outflow from Reservoir B can be routed to either or both uses.  All flows are assumed to be non-stochastic.  The following cost and benefit functions are assumed:

cost function for reservoir A                C1 = a+x2 dollars,

cost function for reservoir B                C2 = b+½(y+z)2 dollars,

benefit function for other use               B = pz dollars,

where

x = safe yield of reservoir A,

y = portion of safe yield of reservoir B diverted to municipal supply,

z = portion of safe yield of reservoir B diverted to other use,

p = price per unit of flow to other use, and

a,b = the given constants.

The municipal water requirement is

R = x+y .

The problem is to find the sizes of x, y and z which maximize the net economic benefits of the system subject to the water supply constraint.  Write the Lagrangean function for the constrained optimization and indicate how you could find the optimal design of the system and the marginal imputed value of municipal water supply.

Would the design be different if we merely asked for a least cost design?

Source: Harvard University Archives. Papers Printed for Mid-Year Examinations. History, History of Religions, Government, Economics, …. January 1967.

Categories
Exam Questions Harvard Methodology

Harvard. Graduate Economic Theory, Scope and Methods. Carver, 1912-1913

He who can, does; he who cannot, teaches; he who cannot do or teach, teaches methodology. Just kidding…Professor Thomas Nixon Carver taught just about everything in the Harvard economics department except for economic history, money and banking, public finance, and international trade. Economic theory, agricultural economics, distribution, social policy, sociology, and scope/methods were all in his teaching portfolio.

_______________________

Links to previous Harvard exams methods and scope of economics
1895-96 to 1907-08.

_______________________

Economics 12
Course Description
1912-13

[Economics] 12 1hf. (formerly 13). Scope and Methods of Economic Investigation. Half-course (first half-year). Hours to be arranged with the instructor. Professor Carver.

Course 12 will examine the methods by which the leading writers of modern times have approached economic questions, and the range which they have given their inquiries; and will consider the advantage of different methods, and the expediency of a wider or narrower field of investigation. Methods of reasoning, methods of investigation, and methods of exposition will be considered separately. Selected passages from the works of a considerable number of writers will be studied, with a view to analyzing the nature and scope of their reasoning.

Source: Harvard University. Division of History, Government, and Economics, Courses of Instruction, 1912–13, p. 64.

_______________________

Economics 12
Course Enrollment
1912-13

Economics 12 lhf (formerly 13). Professor Carver. Scope and Methods of Economic Investigation.

Total 3: 2 Graduates, 1 Radcliffe.

Source: Harvard University. Reports of the President and the Treasurer of Harvard College, 1912-13, p. 57.

_______________________

ECONOMICS 12
Mid-year Examination
1912-13

  1. Explain verbally, and show by means of an outline, the relation between private and public economics and the main subdivisions of each.
  2. Into what main departments would you subdivide the subject of economics if you were going to write a general text book for college classes. Give your reasons.
  3. What are the characteristic methods of reasoning, methods of collecting information, and methods of exposition in economics? Mention examples, or give illustrations of each. What are the special advantages of each? To what class of problems is each especially adapted?
  4. Comment upon the following: —

“The economist may thus be considered at the outset of his researches as already in possession of those ultimate principles governing the phenomena which form the subject of his study, the discovery of which in the case of physical investigation constitutes for the inquirer his most arduous task; but, on the other hand, he is excluded from the use of experiment.” (Cairnes, pp. 89-90.)

  1. What, according to Warner, are the characteristic methods of determining the causes of poverty? What are the merits and defects of each method? Give illustrations.
  2. Comment upon the statement that “political economy depends more upon reasoning than on observation.” Is this the same as saying that the greatest present need is for sound reasoners rather than for close observers? Would either statement apply to all possible conditions and to all classes of problems?
  3. Discuss Clark’s reasons for describing capital as a sum of money.

Source: Harvard University. Mid-year examinations, 1852-1943. Box 9, bound volume Examination Papers, Mid-Years 1912-13.  Also published in: Harvard University Examinations. Papers set for final examinations in history, history of science, government, economics, philosophy, social ethics, education, fine arts, music in Harvard College(June 1913), p. 53.

Image Source: Portrait of Thomas Nixon Carver (colorized by Economics in the Rear-view mirror) from The Harvard Album 1913.

__________________________

Exams from other years

Economics 13 (Scope and Methods) in 1895-96, Taussig.

Economics 13 (Scope and Methods) in 1896-97, Not Offered.

Economics 13 (Scope and Methods) in 1897-98, Ashley.

Economics 13 (Methods) in 1898-99, Taussig.

Economics 13 (Methods) in 1899-1900, Not Offered.

Economics 13 (Methods) in 1900-01, Carver.

Economics 13 (Methods) in 1902-03, Carver.

Economics 13 (Methods) in 1903-04, Carver.

Economics 13 (Methods) in 1904-05, Carver.

Economics 13 (Methods) in 1905-06, Not Offered.

Economics 13 (Methods) in 1906-07, Not Offered.

Economics 13 (Methods) in 1907-08, Carver.

Economics 13 (Methods) in 1908-09, Not Offered.

Economics 13 (Methods) in 1909-10, Not Offered.

Economics 13 (Methods) in 1910-11, Not Offered.

Economics 13 (Methods) in 1911-12, Carver (Exam not found).

Economics 12 (Scope and Methods) in 1914-15. Carver.

Categories
Accounting Exam Questions Harvard

Harvard. Principles of Accounting. Description, Enrollment, Final Exams. W. M. Cole, 1912-1913

A highly popular vocational course offering for Harvard undergraduates was William M. Cole’s principles of accounting. This post provides us with the course description, enrollment figures, and semester exams for the 1912-13 academic year.

________________________

Principles of Accounting
pre-1912/13

Links to earlier course material for Principles of Accounting from Harvard, 1900-01 through 1911-12.

________________________

William M. Cole
His Textbook

Accounts. Their Construction and Interpretation for Business Men and Students of Affairs. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1908.

_______________________

Economics 9
Course Description
1912-13

[Economics] 9 (formerly 18). Principles of Accounting. Mon., Wed., Fri., at 11. Asst. Professor Cole, assisted by Messrs. —— and ——.

This course is designed to show the processes by which the earnings and values of business properties are computed. It is not intended primarily to afford practice in book-keeping; but since intelligent construction and interpretation of accounts is impossible without a knowledge of certain main types of book-keeping, practice sufficient to give the student familiarity with elementary technique will form an important part of the work of the course. The chief work, however, will be a study of the principles that underlie the determination of profit, cost, and valuation. These will be considered as they appear in several types of business enterprise. Published accounts of corporations will be examined, and practice in interpretation will be afforded. The instruction will be chiefly by assigned readings, discussions, and written work.

Course 9 is not open to students before their last year of undergraduate work. For men completing their work at the end of the first half-year, it will be counted as a half-course. It is regularly open only to Seniors and to Graduates who have passed in Economics 1. Students intending to enter the Graduate School of Business Administration are expected to take this course in preparation for the advanced courses in accounting.

Source: Harvard University. Division of History, Government, and Economics, Courses of Instruction, 1912-13, p. 63.

_______________________

Economics 9
Course Enrollment
1912-13

Economics 9. Principles of Accounting. Asst. Professor Cole, assisted by Mr. Eliot Jones.

Total 276: 7 Graduates, 8 Graduates of Applied Sciences, 62 Graduates of Business School, 147 Seniors, 50 Juniors, 2 Sophomores.

_______________________

ECONOMICS 9
Mid-year Examination
1912-13

  1. Indicate, in the form of journal entries, what should be debited and what credited, on your books, for the following:—
    1. You sell goods ($500 net selling price), and receive in exact payment a note bearing interest, at 6%, dated two months ago.
    2. You buy stationery (price $100), and give in return a draft which has been sent to you and has been already accepted by those upon whom it was drawn.
    3. You sell goods to Dombey & Son for $1,000, terms 6% — 10 ds., 5% — 30 ds., net — 60 ds., and to Stalky & Co. for $2,000, on the same terms.
    4. You discount at a bank a note receivable, face $1,500, for $1,492.50.
    5. Dombey & Son pay their bill, taking the discount at 5%.
    6. Stalky & Co., fail to pay their bill when due, but agree to pay 6% interest for the delayed time, and you send them a new bill with interest for 60 days.
    7. Stalky & Co. go into bankruptcy and pay 50 cents on the dollar. You collect your share.
    8. You receive subscriptions, payable in two instalments of $25,000 each, for capital stock to be issued at par.
    9. You issue $25,000 of capital stock for $30,000 in cash.
      Show the trial balance for these transactions.
  2. Explain the purpose of each of the following, and tell how that purpose is accomplished:—
    1. a special column in a book of original entry.
    2. a controlling account.
    3. a six-column statement.
    4. accomplished.
    5. an amortisation table.
  3. The profit and loss account for a year is as follows:—

PROFIT AND LOSS

Rent

$7,000

Interest

$50

Wages

40,000

Commission

1,500

Taxes

500

Merchandise

78,000

Stationery

300

Advertising

700

Expense

500

Allowance for Bad Debts

1,500

Reserve for Bad Debts

5,000

Dividends

5,000

Permanent Surplus

19,050

How many of these items affect the balance sheet, and how?

  1. The annual wear and tear on a certain piece of property is estimated at $2,000. In 1910, $1,500 was spent for maintenance, in 1911, $2,000, in 1912, $2,500. What are the consequences of these facts on the income sheet and on the balance sheet for each of the three years. (Show actual figures in tabular form.)
  2. Would the following appear on the income sheet or on the balance sheet? Under what name in either case?
    1. Cost of a patent bought.
    2. Rent for storage of new machinery ordered from different firms and delivered at different times, but to be installed together, as soon as all arrives, in a new shop.
    3. Author’s royalty on a copyrighted story printed and distributed in an extended advertising campaign.
    4. Cost of heating during permanent interior decoration of a new store.
  3. How far are the following statements true?
    1. A balance sheet is a statement of resources and liabilities.
    2. An income sheet is a statement of earnings and expenses.
    3. A trial balance is a summary statement of the business.

If any of these statements need amendment, illustrate your amendment by concrete items.

  1. Two clerks in an office, A and B, were asked to find the value of a $10,000 bond, payable in 3 years, bearing interest at 5%, on a market basis of 4.67%. A obtained a figure of $10,090.42; B, of $10,089.86. They both used interest tables showing the following present worths and the following amounts.

Present worth of $1.00

Payable in

4.67%

5%

1 year

.955384

.952381

2 years

.912758

.907029

3 years

.872026

.863838

Amount of $1.00

In

4.67%

5%

1 year

1.046700

1.050000

2 years

1.095580

1.102500

3 years

1.140828

1.157625

    1. Was either right? If so, which? Show your figuring.
    2. Show the amortisation table.

Source: Harvard University. Mid-year examinations, 1852-1943. Box 9, bound volume Examination Papers, Mid-Years 1912-13.

_______________________

ECONOMICS 9
Year-end Examination
1912-13

Save one hour for the last question. It will count as one-third of the paper.

  1. Show by journal entries what should be debited and what credited for the following transactions:
    1. Granting a discount to a customer, for early payment of a bill, so that, though the amount of the bill was $100, he pays but $95.
    2. Paying a lawyer $50 for trying to collect a bill that proves uncollectible, and writing off the debt ($250) as bad.
    3. Collecting $75 as full payment, including interest to the amount of $17, for a debt previously written off as bad.
    4. Giving a friend whose credit at banks is not very good, because he is a new-comer in town, and for whom, therefore, you do not wish to endorse notes, your own note for $1000, with the understanding that he will discount it at a bank, and taking in exchange your friend’s note (for the same amount and time) which you intend to keep until maturity.
    5. Discounting at a bank your friend’s note mentioned in (d), because you find his credit has improved in the public mind and you need the money. [Discount $7.]
    6. Returning to the manufacturers, as unsatisfactory, goods billed at $500 and bought to be sold at $650.
    7. Delivering goods from the store as part payment of clerks’ wages, and allowing 5% discount to clerks. [Retail price $50, clerks’ price $47.50.]
    8. Issuing a stock dividend of $50,000.
    9. Selling a new $2,000,000 issue of stock for $2,100,000. [Corporation’s books.]
  2. A bond table gives the value of $10,000 of bonds for January 1 as $10,366.27, and for July 1 as $10,323.60. On the latter day you collect $250 interest. What entry shall you make for the interest?
    Assuming that the valuation of the bonds was determined on a 4% basis, how could you prove the correctness of the July 1 valuation if you knew that the valuation for January 1 was correct?
  3. Define and discuss the purpose of the following: —
    1. a machine rate,
    2. a life-insurance reserve,
    3. a national-bank redemption fund,
    4. a stores ledger,
    5. a machine ledger,
    6. a controlling account.
  4. Would expense burden enter into a plan of cost accounting for (a) a department store, (b) a hospital, (c) a college, (d) a gas company? Explain briefly how, or why not, in each case.

Remember in solving problems that time and confusion are often saved by the use of journal entries as guides in determining which accounts are affected.

  1. The balance sheet a year ago was as follows: —
Plant $125,000 Capital Stock $140,000
Accounts Receivable 33,000 Bills Payable 10,000
Merchandise 19,000 Accounts Payable 24,000
Cash 5,000 Surplus 8,000
$182,000 $182,000

An abbreviated tentative income sheet for the year just closing gave the following figures: —

Wages $85,000 Other Expenses $71,000
Materials 54,000 Gross Income 240,000

No items relating to the care of property were included in the “other expenses,” and they are now to be provided for. Such items are found on the debit side of the trial balance as follows:—

Depreciation $5,000 Replacement $4,000
Repairs 8,000 Additions 12,000

Supposing the only changes in the balance sheet are those caused by the items shown above (profit or loss and care of property) and that cash absorbs the net effect of changes not otherwise indicated, show the income sheet and the balance sheet for the new year.

  1. Prepare such a tabular statement or statements as an accountant should give to his employers or clients for a business yielding the following figures on three trial balances (of ledger balances) taken at the times indicated.
Trial balance at the opening of business, Jan. 1, 1912 Trial balance, Dec. 31, 1912, before the books are closed Trial balance at the opening of business, Jan. 1, 1913
Dr. Cr. Dr. Cr. Dr. Cr.
Capital Stock $200,000 $200,000 $200,000
Bills Payable 30,000 40,000 40,000
Accounts Payable 35,000 37,500 37,500
Surplus 7,000 7,000 9,000
Dividends declared 10,000 10,000
Real Estate and Plant $135,000 $137,500 $137,000
Accounts Receivable 88,200 80,200 80,200
Goods in process 17,000 17,000 20,000
Finished Goods 25,000 25,000 23,000
Raw Materials Inventory 15,000 15,000 35,000
Raw Materials 57,000
Wages 7,000 52,000 2,000
Taxes 200 2,300 200
Insurance 1,000 2,200 1,000
General Expenses 7,500
Sales 113,200
Cash 8,000 2,000 2,000
$289,200 $289,200 $397,700 $397,700 $298,700 $298,700

If you give more than one statement, prepare one at a time, and leave the reconciliation between statements until all are complete.

Categories
Chicago Exam Questions Theory

Chicago. Graduate preliminary examination in economic theory, incomplete. Winter, 1956

 

Artifacts displayed in museums, especially ancient artifacts, are perhaps more often as not, flawed. So too with the documentary record. Sometimes we have gaps. Rather than mourn the missing documents, we celebrate what we have gotten our hands and eyes on. And so this post gives us the True-False-Uncertains questions of the winter quarter 1956 economic theory prelim exam from the department of economics at the University of Chicago.

_____________________

Links to previously posted Chicago prelim exams.

_____________________

ECONOMIC THEORY
Preliminary Examination
Winter Quarter 1956
(incomplete)

Write your number, and not your name, on your examination paper.
Answer all questions.
Time: 4 hours.

  1. (40 points) True, False or Uncertain. Explain your answer.
    1. Since the costs of finding oil are virtually constant over the relevant range of exploration now going on, the depletion allowance which amounts to a subsidy to companies which extract the oil they find is purely a device which increases the profits of the oil companies at the expense of the taxpayer.
    2. A minimum wage law may reduce the demand for labor by some firms and may have no effect on the demand by other firms, but will never increase it.
    3. The sum of the income elasticities of demand for all commodities (by a single consumer) is unity, while the sum of their price elasticities is zero.
    4. If the marginal utility of each commodity diminishes with increases in the rate of consumption, then no commodity will be an inferior commodity.
    5. The fact that new commodities are typically introduced into a consumer’s budget when his income rises implies that the marginal utility of the commodities he was already consuming must have been falling.
    6. Although the demand schedule for a productive service by a firm buying competitively must have a negative slope, the demand schedule for a productive service by a monopsonistic firm may have either a positive or negative slope.
    7. The futures price of a commodity equals the current spot price plus the cost of storing the commodity for the length of the futures contract.
    8. The existence of effective rent control on old dwellings decreases the demand for new dwellings.
    9. Family size has declined in the United States from 1900 to 1950; yet per capita income has increased. If there were no change in tastes, this would imply that children are an inferior commodity.
    10. The existence of firms of different sizes in the same industry implies that there is a horizontal marginal cost curve for firms in the industry.
    11. Immigration to the United States of a million unskilled laborers from abroad would increase the average per capita income of everyone previously living in the United States.
    12. The fact that managers of many large corporations in the United States own a small fraction of the common stock of these corporations implies that the policies of these corporations are often not in the best interests of the stockholders.
    13. The figures for national income show that during the 20th century, per capita national income has grown at a faster rate in the United States than in India. This implies that Indians have been saving a smaller fraction of their incomes.
    14. If we replaced the income tax in the United States by a sales tax, the change would induce persons to shift away from occupations that have large nonpecuniary advantages.
    15. The competitive firm attempts to equalize marginal cost, average cost and price.
    16. When a firm’s average cost is decreasing, its marginal cost is decreasing and is less than average cost.
    17. Between 1951, and 1956 farm product prices (relative to prices paid by farmers) fell by about 20 percent; farm output increased by about 9 percent. This implies that the supply function for farm products is backward bending.
    18. If all firms paid each factor the value of its marginal product and if all product prices were equal to their respective marginal costs, it would not be possible to increase the output of one product without decreasing the output of some other product.
    19. Two products are produced in fixed proportions. An increase in the demand for one of the products would result in a fall in the price of the other product and, all other things constant, the fall in the price of the second product will be the greater, the greater the relative importance of the second product in the total receipts derived from producing the two joint products.
    20. The existence of overtime pay at premium rates proves that the supply of labor is backward bending.

Source: Harvard University Archives. Papers of Zvi Griliches. Box 129. Folder “Preliminary Examinations, 1955-1957”.

Image Source: Coat of arms of the University of Chicago.

The University Coat of Arms, a shield displaying the phoenix below and the book and motto above, was adopted by the Board of Trustees on August 16, 1910. The University motto Crescat scientia; vita excolatur was adopted by the Board on January 17, 1911 and added to the Coat of Arms on the pages of the open book.
The Coat of Arms was designed by Pierre de Chaignon la Rose, a heraldic specialist in Boston working under contract to the Board of Trustees. No surviving documents make clear precisely why the phoenix was adopted as the central element on the Coat of Arms, but the most probable assumption is that the phoenix can be seen as a symbol of the city of Chicago, which was seriously damaged by the great Chicago Fire of 1871 and then was successfully rebuilt, or reborn, within just a few years.

__________________________

Preliminary and Field Exams from the economics graduate program of the University of Chicago

Note: The chronological ordering of quarters at the University of Chicago during a calendar year goes Winter, Spring, Summer, Autumn. For this reason the following is arranged chronologically.

Categories
Distribution Exam Questions Harvard

Harvard. Distribution Theories and Distributive Justice. Description, enrollment, exams. Carver, 1912-1913

As was the case for Charles Jesse Bullock’s two semester sequence of public finance and taxation courses being merged into a single two semester course, two of Thomas Nixon Carvers’s semester courses were merged into a single one year course starting in the academic year 1912-13.

_______________________

Links to previous Harvard exams on distribution and
schemes for distributive justice
1904-05 to 1911-12.

_______________________

ECONOMICS 7
Course Description
1912-13

[Economics] 7 (formerly 14a and 14b). Theories of Distribution and Distributive Justice. Tu., Th., Sat., at 10. Professor Carver, assisted by Mr. ——.

Course 7 undertakes an analysis of the laws of value, as applied to consumable goods and to agents of production, and an examination of the relation of the laws of value to the problem of social adjustment; also a critical reading of various works on the distribution of wealth, on socialism, on the single tax, and other special schemes for attaining the ideals of economic justice.

Source: Harvard University. Division of History, Government, and Economics, Courses of Instruction, 1912–13, p. 62.

_______________________

ECONOMICS 7
Course Enrollment
1912-13

Economics 7. (formerly 14a and 14b). Professor Carver. Theories of Distribution and Distributive Justice.

Total 25: 3 Graduates, 7 Seniors, 13 Juniors, 1 Sophomore, 1 Other.

Source: Harvard University. Reports of the President and the Treasurer of Harvard College, 1912-13, p. 57.

_______________________

ECONOMICS 7
Mid-year Examination
1912-13

Consider the questions very carefully. Make your answers accurate and complete. Beware of omitting important points.

  1. Define goods, utility, economy, scarcity, productivity, capital, property, wealth.
  2. Why are prices determined by the law of demand and supply, (a) in the case of consumers’ goods; (b) in the case of producers’ goods.
  3. What, precisely, is self interest? How would you describe a benevolent as contrasted with a selfish person?
  4. Why are wages high in some occupations and low in others?
  5. Compare the Ricardian law of rent with the theory that the rent of a given piece of land is equal to its specific productivity.
  6. Why does a piece of capital normally return to its owner more than enough to repay the cost of producing it?

Source: Harvard University. Mid-year examinations, 1852-1943. Box 9, bound volume Examination Papers, Mid-Years 1912-13.

_______________________

ECONOMICS 7
Year-end Examination
1912-13

  1. Explain and illustrate the principle of marginal utility and its relation to the value of consumers’ goods.
  2. Explain and illustrate the law of variable proportions and its relation to the value of the factors of production.
  3. Discuss the various criteria of justice in the distribution of wealth.
  4. Explain and illustrate exactly what you understand by self-interest.
  5. How would the single tax probably affect the demand for labor? Would its effect probably be stronger on unskilled than on skilled labor? On skilled labor than on business talent?
  6. How do mechanical inventions affect the demand for capital and for different grades of labor?
  7. Describe one communistic society, giving some account of its origin, the causes of its success if it succeeded and of its failure if it failed.
  8. Outline a program for raising the wages of all the lower grades of labor.

Source: Harvard University Examinations. Papers set for final examinations in history, history of science, government, economics, philosophy, social ethics, education, fine arts, music in Harvard College (June 1913), p. 47.

Image Source: J. S. Pughe, The socialists’ theory, and how it would work out. Centerfold in Puck, vol. 45, No. 1162 (14 June 1899). Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C.

Uncle Sam, on the left, giving a bag of money to a man labeled “Socialist” and a bag of money to a man labeled “Businessman”, he tells them “Gentlemen, I have divided the wealth of the country equally among all the people. Here are your shares, now go ahead and be happy!” At center, “The Start”, the two men part ways with the socialist taking the path “To Idleness and Extravagance” and the businessman taking the path “To Industry and Thrift”. On the right, at “The Finish”, the two men again stand before Uncle Sam, this time the businessman is holding two bags of money and the dejected socialist is showing that his pockets are now empty.

__________________________

From Earlier Income Distribution Courses

1904-05
1905-06
1907-08
1908-09
1909-10
1910-11
1911-12

’The course content is undoubtedly captured in Carver’s 1904 book The Distribution of Wealth which was reprinted several times during his lifetime.

From  Earlier Social Reform Courses

Pre-Carver
Carver’s courses
Categories
Cambridge Exam Questions

Cambridge. The Economics Tripos, 1924

In 1903 Alfred Marshal, the first Professor of Political Economy at Cambridge University, established what was to become the Economics Tripos as an undergraduate degree course at the Faculty of Economics and Politics. Economics in the Rear-view Mirror is on the lookout for these examinations. The 1924 Economics Tripos is the seventh transcribed and posted thus far.

____________________________

Economics Tripos Papers
Previously posted

1921
1922
1923
1931
1932
1933

Also of interest, 

Guide to Moral Sciences Tripos 1891

Report of the Faculty Board of Economics and Politics on amendments to the regulations for the Economics Tripos (October 2001)

____________________________

1924 Economics Tripos Papers

Part I

Examiners. A. W. Flux, M.A. (St. John’s); Leonard Alston, M.A. (Christ’s); T. H. Marshall, M.A. (Trinity); Donald Knoop, M.A. (Manchester).

Part II

Examiners. J. R. M. Butler, M.A. (Trinity); D. H. Robertson, M.A. (Trinity); F. Lavington, M.A. (Emmanuel); P. E. Gregory, D. Sc.

____________________________

[p. 58]

PART I

ENGLISH ECONOMIC HISTORY.

MONDAY, June 2, 1924.  9—12.
  1. Explain and criticise British colonial policy during the eighteenth century.
  2. What principles governed Walpole’s financial policy, and what were the main sources of public revenue at his disposal?
  3. Examine the nature of the service rendered by Arthur Young to the cause of agricultural progress.
  4. Outline the history of the part played by the Joint Stock Company in English trade and industry since 1688.
  5. Why, and with how much justice, are Malthus and Ricardo referred to as “Pessimists”?
  6. Compare the conditions prevailing in the Lancashire cotton industry and the Yorkshire woollen industry at the close of the Napoleonic wars.
  7. Compare the agricultural depression that followed the Napoleonic wars with that which followed the war of 1914—1918.
  8. Compare the character and aims of the trade-union movement in the period 1830—1840 and in the period 1880—1900.
  9. “Both Huskisson and Gladstone have, in a sense, a right to be called ‘Free Traders.’”
    Compare their policies and achievements from the standpoint of this dictum.
  10. “The prosperity of the fifties and the depression of the seventies were both closely connected with improvements in the methods of transport.”  Discuss this statement.
  11. Examine historically the effect of industrial changes since 1750 on the parts played in industry by capital and by personal ability respectively.
  12. In what ways has State action for the promotion of the welfare of the wage-earning class been extended in the last half century?

____________________________

[pp. 59-60]

INDUSTRY AND LABOUR.

MONDAY, June 2, 1924.  1.30—4.30.
  1. What influences govern the introduction of labour-saving machinery into industry?  Why is it more used in some countries than in others?
  2. “The only trades which is seems possible for a joint stock company to carry on successfully, without an exclusive privilege, are those of which all the operations are capable of being reduced to what is called a routine….Of this kind is, first, the banking trade; secondly, the trade of insurance…; thirdly, the trade of making or maintaining a navigable cut or canal; and fourthly, the similar trade of bringing water for the supply of a great city.”  (ADAM SMITH.)
    Joint Stock Companies appear to operate successfully in many spheres to-day.  How do you account for this development?
  3. What do you understand by the phrase “economy of high wages”?  How can it be economical for an employer to pay high wages?
  4. “The notion we can secure real stability in enterprise and freedom from unemployment, even if the stabilization of the general price level were entirely successful, might bring with it grave disappointment.”  (HARTLEY WITHERS.)
    Examine this contention.
  5. Discuss the various methods, in use in this country, of preventing or settling industrial disputes.
  6. Compare and classify the different types of industrial combinations.
  7. Examine these suggestions.
      1. “Wages should vary with movements in the price of the commodity which the wage-earner helps to produce.”
      2. “Wages should vary with movements in the Ministry of Labour cost of living figures.”
      3. “Wages should vary with movements in the general level of prices.”
  1. Discuss the argument that such schemes as profit-sharing, co-partnership, etc., are socially undesirable because they reintroduce into the workers’ lives an element of fluctuating uncertainty from which the ordinary wage system relieves them.
  2. Distinguish between “craft unionism” and “industrial unionism” and show the importance of this distinction in modern Trade Union development.
  3. Is it true that a margin of unemployed labour is essential to the satisfactory working of the present system of economic organization?  State reasons for your answer.
  4. “The government is right in doing what it can to assist co-operative societies established either for the manufacture of agricultural products or for joint marketing….In the case of agricultural credit societies certainly the experience in Europe has been that their success has varied inversely with the amount of assistance they have received from the State.”
    State the case for agricultural co-operation in this country.

____________________________

[pp. 60-61]

ECONOMIC THEORY
(VALUE AND DISTRIBUTION).

TUESDAY, June 3, 1924.  9—12.
  1. “Cheap capital and cheap labour are essential conditions of a rapid growth of national wealth.”  Comment.
  2. “The law of diminishing returns, emphasizing as it does the tendency of land to deteriorate under use, resembles the allowances that industrialists make for the annual depreciation of machinery.”  Consider whether the suggested analogy is justified.
  3. Is there loss of national wealth if an invention appears which suddenly renders obsolete great masses of expensive machinery?
  4. What are the chief qualifications to be made to the assumption that it is desirable that all new capital should be free to flow into the channels most profitable to the owner of the capital?
  5. “The evils of Monopoly are not greater than the evils of unrestrained Competition.”  Discuss this point.
  6. How are rising rates of interest related to the prosperity of the wage-earning class?
  7. Discuss the connexion between the rate of interest and the accumulation of Capital.
  8. What are the strongest reasons that can be adduced in justification of the continuance of substantial inequalities in the distribution of wealth?
  9. Discuss the relation between the Standard of Life and the growth of population, bringing out clearly what you understand by the “Standard of Life.”
  10. Discuss various applications of the term “Speculation,” showing in what respects activities that are classed as “speculative” may be socially beneficial or injurious.
  11. What truth is there in the view that heavy national taxation is a burden upon the production of wealth and a cause of unemployment?

____________________________

[p. 61]

SUBJECTS FOR AN ESSAY.

TUESDAY, June 3, 1924.  1.30—4.30.

Write an essay on one of the following subjects:

  1. Twentieth Century Imperialism.
  2. Problems of emigration and immigration.
  3. “The forward march of economic progress that marked the Nineteenth Century cannot be expected to continue.”
  4. The formation of an Index of Prosperity.
  5. “Contentment spells stagnation; while discontent breeds friction.”
  6. The English Poor Law.
  7. “Scientific Management.”

____________________________

[pp. 62-63]

TRADE AND FINANCE.

WEDNESDAY, June 4, 1924.  9—12.
  1. Give some account of (a) the reasons for, and (b) the extent of, the changes in English legal tender money (standard and token) since July, 1914.  Could these changes have been avoided?
  2. “It has been asserted that the rise of prices in the United States during the greenback depreciation was not due to the quantity of the greenbacks, but to the public distrust of greenbacks.”
    Explain the principle enunciated in this statement and illustrate from recent experience in Europe.
  3. “The general rate of interest will be raised by a gradual and anticipated fall in the value of currency relatively to commodities, and will be lowered by a rise in that value.”
    Examine this statement and consider its bearing on the use of the discount rate as a means of controlling price movements.
  4. The excess of our imports over our exports is partly balanced by the services of British shipping.  Show by an illustration how this is effected, and discuss its importance in a period when shipping is being operated at a loss.
  5. Explain generally the means by which, during 1916, 1917 and 1918, the exchange between New York and London was maintained at a steady rate.  Why was it necessary to abandon the fixed rate in 1919?
  6. Consider the following case: A country possesses abundant resources of water-power readily accessible.  The development of science and engineering enables these resources to be exploited so as to furnish industrial power at a cheaper rate than in other countries.  What will be the nature of the effect on the foreign trade of such a country of so utilising the water-power?
  7. A large part of the bank deposits in this country result from loans, and so do not add to the bank’s resources.  Explain this, and consider particularly the case of loans of the character of “Ways and Means” advances to the Government.
  8. Explain what is meant by proportional, progressive and degressive taxation.  Distinguish carefully between the application of these terms to particular taxes and to the tax system as a whole.  Illustrate from modern practice in this country.
  9. “Generally, though not necessarily, the burden of the rich is lessened, that of the poor increased, by the use of loans rather than taxes.”  Examine the validity of this statement.
  10. In what sense is it possible to measure the general level of prices by means of an index number?
    Discuss briefly the inclusion of wage rates and stock exchange quotations among the elements to be used in the calculation of the index number.
  11. In what way can it be possible for a nation to expend upon a war a greater sum year by year (in addition to the proceeds of any loans raised abroad) than would represent the annual savings of the same nation during a period of peace and prosperity?

____________________________

[pp. 63-64]

RECENT ECONOMIC AND GENERAL HISTORY OF EUROPE.

WEDNESDAY, June 4, 1924.  1.30—4.30.

  1. “The Berlin Decree of 1806 not only was, but was intended to be, a self-denying ordinance.”  Discuss this view of Napoleon’s intentions in devising the Continental System.
  2. Napoleon’s overthrow marked “the victory of the national spirit over the alien tyranny which educates and fosters its destroyer.”  Explain and comment on this statement.
  3. Give a sketch of the condition of French agriculture and land tenure in 1815, noting how they had been affected by the Revolution.
  4. By what steps did Germany acquire a system of State railways, and why?
  5. Give a critical analysis of French commercial policy from 1815 to the Anglo-French commercial treaty of 1860.
  6. Compare the Greek and Italian movements for national independence, showing what each owed to European diplomacy and to intervention by Powers not directly concerned.
  7. Bismarck, referring to his opinions in 1866, said, “I did not doubt that a Franco-German war must take place before the construction of a United Germany could be realised.”  Discuss the causes of the war of 1870—1871 in the light of this statement.
  8. Show how the “scramble for Africa” inaugurated a new period in the history of the relations between the Great Powers.
  9. Give some account of trade-union organization in pre-war France, and of the methods and doctrines of French syndicalism.  How do you explain the weakness of trade-unionism in France?
  10. Compare the banking systems of England and Germany, with special reference to the influence exerted by the banks over industry.
  11. What part has been played by Kartells in the development of German industry?
  12. What are the main points of resemblance and difference between the attempt to regulate the affairs of Europe by Congress from 1815 to 1823 and the similar attempt after the peace of 1919?

____________________________

[pp. 64-65]

RECENT ECONOMIC AND GENERAL HISTORY OF THE BRITISH EMPIRE
AND THE UNITED STATES.

THURSDAY, June 5, 1924.  9—12.
  1. “It will always be more easy for the State governments to encroach upon the national authorities, than for the national government to encroach upon the State authorities.” FEDERALIST.
    How far does the history of the United States confirm this view?
  2. Give some account of the most striking features in the history of the American mercantile marine prior to 1914.
  3. Examine the main political and economic forces that influenced the tariff policy of the United States from 1789 to 1860.
  4. Account for the rapid development of the American “Middle West” and describe the chief characteristics of its economic life.
  5. “The Monroe Doctrine has become out of date, owing to the increasing importance in international affairs of economic, as against purely political, relations.”  Explain the origin and purpose of the Monroe Doctrine, and discuss this view of its importance in the modern world.
  6. Estimate America’s debt to Abraham Lincoln.
  7. Compare the consequences, both local and general, of the gold discoveries in (a) California, (b) South Africa.
  8. What do you understand by “Canadian Reciprocity”?  Outline the history of the controversy on this question since 1841, showing how it involved the problem of the relations between Canada and the United Kingdom.
  9. What circumstances have, up to the present time, determined the character, growth and distribution of the population of Australia?  How has the distribution affected the problem of transport?
  10. What examples do the British Dominions afford of the use of conciliation and arbitration in industrial disputes, and what lessons would you draw from their experience?
  11. Compare the cotton industries of India and Lancashire in respect of their history, their organization and the social and economic problems that confront them.
  12. “Dyarchy should lead to Federalism, and Federalism to Home Rule.”  Explain clearly the meaning of the above terms, and discuss this comment on the Government of India Act of 1919.

 

____________________________

PART II

[pp. 66-67]

PUBLIC FINANCE.

MONDAY, June 2, 1924.  9—12.
  1. Discuss the economic and administrative advantages and disadvantages of the substitution of a single tax on incomes for all existing forms of taxation.
  2. Discuss the view that death duties destroy “capital.”  Contrast the effects on the annual volume of savings of raising a given amount of revenue (a) from death duties, (b) from income taxes.
  3. Discuss the contention that (a) beneficial rates are borne by the occupier, (b) onerous rates are borne by the landlord.  Indicate to what extent these doctrines are applicable to the incidence of (a) the education rate, (b) the poor rate.
  4. Discuss critically the “Principle of Minimum Sacrifice” as the true canon of taxation.  To what extent is the doctrine operative in British Public Finance at the present time: what further extensions do you think practicable?
  5. To what extent, if at all, is it true that domestic loans are to be preferred to foreign loans?  Apply any general principles you may lay down to the case of (a) British borrowing in the U.S.A. during the War, (b) the International Loan to Austria.
  6. Should the Post Office yield a profit to the State?
  7. Discuss the views that a Capital Levy is unworkable without (a) causing injurious deflation, (b) causing injurious inflation.
  8. Discuss the effects (a) of a uniform customs duty, (b) of a customs duty varying with the country from which the article comes, imposed on an article, (1) not produced at all within the country imposing the duty, (2) produced in part in the country imposing the duty.
  9. Supposing all local rates to be abolished, and the expenditure of the local authorities to be met out of funds derived from uniform national taxes, what principles should be adopted in determining the distribution of the sums so raised among the various areas and services involved?
  10. “In so far as we adopt indirect taxation at all, the best form of such a tax is one which hits articles obeying the Law of Diminishing Return.”
    Discuss this statement.

____________________________

[pp. 67-68]

ECONOMIC PRINCIPLES.

MONDAY, June 2, 1924.  1.30—4.30.
  1. Examine the distinction between joint and common (e.g. supplementary) costs and compare the special influences they respectively exert on value.
  2. Discuss the view that a “living wage” should be a first charge on the proceeds of industry.
  3. A commercial undertaking supplies electricity at three different prices: (a) a standard rate to consumers of light; (b) a lower special rate to consumers in the neighbourhood of efficient gas companies; (c) a still lower rate to consumers of power.  Are such discriminations socially desirable?
  4. Consider the causes which may produce differences between the internal and external value of a currency and the effect of such differences on the foreign trade of the country concerned.
  5. “It is becoming more and more clear to Economists that monopoly and competition are not mutually exclusive terms, but are omnibus phrases with no exact connotation.”  Discuss this.
  6. Trace the probable effects on our foreign trade of the adoption, within the country, of a universal seven hours day.
  7. In industry A wages are above, in industry B they are below, the marginal net product of labour.  What are the probable causes of these discrepancies?
  8. “It is changes in the will to buy rather than changes in the power to buy which accentuate the intensity of business cycles.”  Examine this statement.
  9. How would you proceed to find an answer to the question whether or no the material welfare of this country would be increased by a reduction in its population?
  10. Examine the effect on the general rate of interest of a nearer approach to equality of individual incomes.

____________________________

[p. 68]

SUBJECTS FOR AN ESSAY.

TUESDAY, June 3, 1924.  9—12.

Write an Essay on one of the following subjects:

  1. The place of motive in Economic theory.
  2. Economic Security.
  3. Fairness or Expediency.
  4. “The only forces strong enough to drive men to revolution are religion and hunger.”
  5. Public Opinion.
  6. “The magnificent episode of the nineteenth century.”
  7. The causes of the next world war.
  8. The future of Islam.
  9. Inequality.

____________________________

[pp. 68-69]

STRUCTURE AND PROBLEMS OF MODERN INDUSTRY.

TUESDAY, June 3, 1924.  1.30—4.30.
  1. Discuss the extent to which associations of producers are in a position to eliminate the independent middleman.
  2. “The function of the Stock Exchange is to capitalise Securities at their true relative value.”  In this connection discuss the function and rewards of the speculator, and, if you think his remuneration excessive, discuss means by which it could be reduced.
  3. “The growth of joint stock organization means that the problem of leadership is as acute to-day in industry as it is in the services maintained by government.”  Discuss this view.
  4. “The main difficulty in the way of the socialisation of industry lies not in the field of production, but of marketing.”  Discuss.
  5. Discuss the propriety of Government action in stimulating and regulating the supply of the raw materials of industry.  Illustrate your answer from the experience of recent years.
  6. Discuss the extent to which in the leading industrial countries the government of industry has passed into the hands of interests which are primarily financial rather than industrial: and indicate the probable effects of such a development upon national economic welfare.
  7. What British industries seem to you to have the strongest claims to assistance by means of protective tariffs, and on what grounds?
  8. Give some account of the prospects and problems facing any one of the following British industries at the present time :— shipping, cotton, building.
  9. How do you account for the falling-off of 25% in the volume of British exports since 1913?  Indicate the bearing of your answer on the question of how far and in what directions the character of British industry is likely to change in the next half-century.
  10. Discuss the extent to which vertical and horizontal combinations are typical of British industry to-day.  On what technical conditions does the extension of these forms respectively depend, and what is likely to be the trend of development in the future?

____________________________

[pp. 69-70]

STRUCTURE AND METHODS OF GOVERNMENT
IN THE MODERN WORLD.

TUESDAY, June 3, 1924.  1.30—4.30.
  1. “In England the law of the constitution is not the source, but the consequence, of the rights of individuals, as defined and enforced by the courts.”
    Explain this statement, and consider how far the feature it refers to is distinctive of England.
  2. Explain the special difficulties encountered in providing for the amendment of a federal constitution, and consider with what success existing federal states have surmounted them.
  3. “If you will have democracy, you must have something like Caesarism to control it.”  How far is this dictum justified by the experience of the last 10 years?
  4. Consider whether external checks on the action of an elective legislature are more, or less, necessary where there are three or more parties than under the two-party system.
  5. State shortly the objects, and discuss the degree of success, of the principal systems of “proportional representation” in force at the present day.
  6. Compare the federalism of the German Reich with that of the United States.
  7. “The nation [England] has been saved from a bureaucracy, such as prevails over the greater part of Europe, on the one hand, and from the American spoils system on the other, by the sharp distinction between political and non-political officials.”
    Explain and discuss this judgment.
  8. Illustrate from the practice of modern countries the variety of methods by which nationalised services can be administered.
  9. Discuss the merits and demerits of a “communal franchise” where a population is not homogeneous.
  10. Explain the principal differences between the British and any other system of colonial administration.

____________________________

[pp. 70-71]

DISTRIBUTION AND LABOUR.

WEDNESDAY, June 4, 1924.  9—12.
  1. Examine the view that the methods of modern social reform, by encouraging the propagation and survival of the biologically unfit, tend to lower the average quality of the population.
  2. “The man who is unemployed through no fault of his own has a right to full and unconditional maintenance at the expense of the community.”
    “Above all, idleness must be made substantially less lucrative than normal work.”
    Discuss, with special reference to the system in force in Great Britain, the validity of these principles as a guide to the treatment of unemployment.
  3. What is meant by the statement that the differences at present prevailing in this country between the earnings of different grades and groups of labour are economically unjustifiable, and what grounds are there for believing it to be true?
  4. Examine the practical possibilities of so re-casting and developing the system of social insurance in this country as to afford adequate protection to the wage-earner against all the risks of industrial life.
  5. Describe the various possible methods of attaching legal sanction to wage agreements arrived at between the parties themselves and wage awards made by an outside body; and discuss the difficulties which stand in the way of their more extensive adoption in this country.
  6. How far in your opinion is the existing inequality in the distribution of income bound up, whether as cause or effect, with the existing inequality in the distribution of property?  Indicate the bearing of your answer on the question of the practicability of reducing the inequality in the distribution of income.
  7. Elucidate the exact meaning of the proposition that the workers in each industry should exercise a greater share in the control of that industry, and explain how far you consider development along these lines to be (a) desirable, (b) probable.
  8. Investigate the view that the restriction of output by particular groups of work-people is necessarily injurious to the economic welfare of the country as a whole.
  9. Examine the proposal that the standard rates of wages established in each industry should be subject to variation in accordance with the family responsibilities of individual wage-earners.
  10. “Only by extensive cuts in wages can demand be stimulated and markets recovered.”
    “Wage-cuts diminish purchasing-power, and thus aggravate trade depression.”
    In the light of these quotations, prescribe a wise policy for Trade Unionism in the face of a slump in trade.

____________________________

[p. 72]

POLITICAL THEORY.

WEDNESDAY, June 4, 1924.  9—12.
  1. Sketch in outline the origin, historical development, and political importance of the doctrine of the Law of Nature.
  2. “To determine the best form of government was according to Bentham a very simple matter.”  Explain and criticise Bentham’s method of determining it.
  3. Explain the significance in the history of political thought of either Edmund Burke or Giuseppe Mazzini or Karl Marx.
  4. “All men…have certain inherent rights, of which, when they enter into a state of society, they cannot by any compact deprive or divest their posterity.”  Virginia Bill of Rights.
    “A right against society…is a contradiction in terms.” T. H. GREEN.
    Discuss these two opinions.​
  5. “To speak of the group will or the social conscience is not only idle but dangerous; only individuals have either wills or consciences.”  Discuss this view.
  6. Is there, in your opinion, any adequate ground for holding that a democratic form of government is peculiarly favourable to liberty?
  7. To what extent do you accept the principle of self-determination for national groups?
  8. Discuss what are the proper functions of the State with regard to (1) religious education, (2) the supply of information, (3) the supply of alcoholic liquor.
  9. Discuss on what grounds the parliamentary franchise should be granted or withheld, considering in particular the cases of illiterate persons, paupers, and conscientious objectors to military service.
  10. To what extent and in what form is the political representation of economic and vocational “interests” likely, in your opinion, to be effective or beneficial?

____________________________

[p. 73]

MONEY, CREDIT AND PRICES.

WEDNESDAY, June 4, 1924.  1.30—4.30.
  1. Give reasons for thinking that the elasticity of demand for currency is not always, or even usually, unity.  What modifications, if any, does the truth of this view necessitate in the Quantity Theory of Money?
  2. Illustrate from British and American experience the functions of central banks in the modern credit structure.  To what extent is the rate of discount an adequate instrument of credit control?
  3. To what extent do you regard it as legitimate to compare the currency events of the last few years to those usually manifested in the course of a credit-cycle?
  4. “The problem of Reparations is not mainly one of taxation, but of strain upon the mechanism of the Foreign Exchanges.”
    Discuss this statement.
  5. “In truth, the gold standard is already a barbarous relic.”
    Discuss this statement.
  6. Trace the effects on the general level of prices in this country of
    1. a rise of 10% in the wages of British coal miners,
    2. a bad harvest throughout the world.
  7. “A State cannot steady industry by constructing public works in time of depression rather than of boom; for whether it borrows for this purpose at one time or the other its action has no effect upon the purchasing power of the community as a whole.”
    Examine this statement.
  8. What are the causes which are today threatening the position of London as “the financial centre of the world”?
  9. Contrast the organizations of England and Germany for the supply of capital for industrial, as distinguished from commercial, purposes.
  10. How would you construct, with existing information, an index number to show changes in the general level of (money) wages in this country?

____________________________

[pp. 74-75]

INTERNATIONAL LAW.

WEDNESDAY, June 4, 1924.  1.30—4.30.
  1. “Necessity in war overrules the customs of warfare.”
    Discuss this doctrine.
  2. To what extent were the provisions of the Declaration of London observed during the Great War?  If the Declaration of London had been generally ratified, to what extent would its provisions have provided a satisfactory body of rules for the conduct of modern naval warfare?
  3. Discuss the general principles on which in your opinion should be founded the Law of War relating to the use of
    1. Bombing Aircraft.
    2. Poison Gas.
  4. Discuss briefly:
    1. The Alabama Dispute.
    2. The right of Angary.
    3. Neutral Asylum.
  5. Was Pacific Blockade without declaration of war legitimate as a means of coercion before the establishment of the League of Nations?  In what way, if at all, is the doctrine affected by the Covenant?
  6. Discuss the doctrine of Austin concerning the legal nature of International Law.
  7. Give an account of the general principle of the provisions of the Treaty of Vienna concerning international rivers, and of its application and extension in subsequent international conventions.
  8. Discuss the principle of the Three Mile Limit in the light of recent disputes.
  9. Compare the Permanent Court of Arbitration established by the First Hague Conference in 1899 with the Permanent Court of International Justice, and trace the connection between them.
  10. To what extent are the arguments used by international lawyers before the War against the principle of compulsory arbitration of all international disputes valid against the proposal to ratify the optional protocol providing for the compulsory jurisdiction of the Permanent Court of International Justice?

____________________________

[p. 75]

ECONOMIC CONDITIONS IN ENGLAND, 1823—1828, AND CONTEMPORARY SOCIAL THOUGHT.

THURSDAY, June 5, 1924.  9—12.
  1. How far, in your opinion, do Huskisson’s speeches reveal a complete imperial economic policy?
  2. Examine the case of the employers against the Combination Act of 1824.
  3. “With all his keen wit, Place was as blind to the real problems of the future as any Tory.”  Do you agree?
  4. Explain the organization of the silk industry and the effect of recent legislation upon the industry, in 1828.
  5. On what main aspects of the social life of the time do you regard Cobbett’s evidence as of first rate value, and why?
  6. “The problem of emigration, as the committees of 1826 and 1827 learnt, was more an Irish than an English problem.”  Discuss this expression of opinion.
  7. How do you explain William Thompson’s evolution from a disciple of Ricardo into a disciple of Owen?
  8. “Owen’s original scheme of social reconstruction was a child of New Lanark by the Poor Law.”
    Is this view justified?

____________________________

[pp. 75-77]

THE THEORY OF STATISTICS.

THURSDAY, June 5, 1924.  9—12.
  1. Define the geometric mean and discuss its uses in statistics.
    Show that, if deviations are small compared with the mean, we have approximately

G = M (1 – ½v²),

where G is the geometric mean, M the arithmetic mean, and v the coefficient of variation.

  1. Show that the frequencies of 0, 1, 2, … successes in samples of n events are given by the successive terms of a binomial series, and find the mean and standard deviation.  Discuss the applications of these results.
  2. State the formula for the normal curve of errors, describe its principal properties, and find the relation between the fourth and second moments about the mean.
  3. Of 773 men in a certain battalion exposed to an epidemic 138 in all were attacked.  Of the 773, 133 had been inoculated and of these only 18 were attacked.  Set out these data in a table, describe the principal methods of testing for association in such a table, and find whether in the given case the association is or is not significant.
  4. The mean of a sub-sample of n1 observations is compared with the mean of a sample of n1+ n2 observations which contains the sub-sample.  Find the standard error of the difference between the two means.
  5. The following data are given for 90 industrial towns :

X = index-number for wages of unskilled labour,

Y = index-number for rents of working-class dwellings,

Mx = 83·1,        σx = 11·55,

My = 59·7,        σy = 11·86,

rxy = + 0·46.

Explain the meaning of the coefficient of correlation rxy, describe the method of calculation, and determine the two regression equations.  The regression not being linear, what is the significance of the regression equations?

  1. The following are the numbers (in 1000’s) of females in England and Wales, as returned at the Census of 1911, between the ages of 30 and 49.  Obtain by any algebraical method a graduated figure for the number 40 years of age.

Age

Number

Age

Number

30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39

344
282
305
281
289
284
280
255
280
252

40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49

282
208
242
216
208
213
200
192
207
187

  1. How are the “comparative mortality figures” for different occupations, in the Decennial Reports of the Registrar General for England and Wales, obtained?  Discuss the principal sources of untrustworthiness in this data.
  2. Supposing you were given for a certain district (1) the numbers of the population of males, by single years of age from 0 to 5 and by quinquennial groups thenceforward, (2) the average annual deaths of males for the same age-groups, describe in general terms how you would proceed to construct a life-table, including the column for the complete expectation of life.  Mention any practical difficulties that are likely to occur, owing to deficiencies in the data or otherwise, stating how you would surmount them.

Source: Cambridge University. Economics tripos papers, 1921-1926. Cambridge at the University Press, 1927.

Image Source: Cambridge University Coats of Arms. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C.