SOCIAL ETHICS
Social Ethics 1-8
1913-14
Social Ethics 1. Social Problems and Social Policy
Social Ethics 2. Administration of Agencies for Poor-Relief and Neighborhood Welfare
Social Ethics 3. Criminology and Penology [omitted 1913-14]
Social Ethics 4. Immigration and Race Problems
Social Ethics 5. The Housing Problem
Social Ethics 6. Social Amelioration in Europe
Social Ethics 7. Rural Social Development
Social Ethics 8. Child-Helping Agencies
Social Ethics Instructors
1913-14
Jeffrey Richardson Brackett
Robert Franz Foerster
James Ford
Hermann Franklin Arens
Carl Christian Carstens
GENERAL STATEMENT
The courses of this Department are designed to apply ethical principles to social problems, to indicate methods of social research, and to determine measures for social improvement.
Course 1 offers a general survey of social problems, of the agencies and methods of social betterment. Students are advised before taking it to take courses both in Economics and in Philosophy, and must have taken a course, or the equivalent of a course, in one of these subjects.
Courses 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8 are open to students who have received a satisfactory grade in Social Ethics 1. Juniors and Seniors specializing in Economics or Philosophy and graduate students are eligible to enrolment. These courses all deal intensively with specific social problems, — with conditions, principles, and policy. Courses 2 and 8, offered by officials of Massachusetts charitable organizations, are largely concerned with methods and problems of administration. Course 5 is primarily a course in research. Field work is required in Courses 2, 5, and 8, and can be assigned upon request in Courses 4 and 7.
[…]
For Undergraduates and Graduates
_________________________
SOCIAL ETHICS 1
Course Description
1913-14
1. Social Problems and Social Policy. — Lectures, prescribed reading, theses. Tu., Th., Sat., at 10. Asst. Professor Foerster and Asst. Professor Ford.
This course gives a survey of contemporary social problems with special reference to principles and methods of social amelioration.
It begins with a discussion of the bearing of ethics upon social and economic problems and seeks throughout to apply ethical principles to specific problems. Among the subjects dealt with are the methods of social investigation, immigration, incomes and expenditures, the methods of public and private relief of poverty, delinquent and defective classes, control of the liquor traffic, the family, housing, public recreation, wages and hours of labor of men, women and children, industrial disputes and their settlement, compensation for accidents, workmen’s insurance, producers’ and consumers’ coöperation, profit-sharing, ethical aspects of socialism. An important feature of the course is a thesis in the first term dealing with problems of poverty, and in the second term dealing with labor problems; either or both of these may involve field work.
Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 1
1913-14
- Asst. Professor Foerster and Asst. Professor James Ford, assisted by Mr. Arens. — Social Problems and Social Policy. Principles and Methods of Social Amelioration.
Total 77: 4 Graduates; 15 Seniors; 39 Juniors; 10 Sophomores; 2 Freshmen; 7 Others.
Final Examination
Social Ethics 1
1913-14
Answer questions in the order given. So allot your time that you may answer all. Your opinions should be supported by reasons which should take account of the arguments of both reading and lectures.
1. Outline the means by which trade unions attempt to get and retain a monopoly of labor.
2. What are the effects of (a) immigration, (b) trade unionism, on rates of wages?
3. Compare English and German measures for indemnifying employees in case of accident.
4. What are the devices for settlement of industrial disputes in the American states? What are the essentials of a successful method of dealing with industrial disputes?
5. Discuss: —
(a)gain-sharing,
(b)an American example of industrial partnership,
(c)the advantages and disadvantages to railway employees of railway pensions systems.
6. What are the limitations upon consumers’ co-operation? What are the limitations upon workers’ (independent) co-operative production? What are the obstacles to the realization of such a socialist state as Wells describes?
7. What are the characteristics of successful communist societies? What have been the causes of failure of the unsuccessful? From this history of communism can you infer anything as to the feasibility of Wells’ socialist state?
8. What is the program of action of: —
(a)Marxian socialism?
(b)Revolutionary syndicalism?
(c)The Socialist party of the United States?
_________________________
SOCIAL ETHICS 2
Course Description
1913-14
*2 2hf. Administration of Agencies for Poor-Relief and Neighborhood Welfare. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and field work. Half-course (second half-year). Tu., Th., at 2.30, and a third hour by special appointment. Dr. Brackett.
This course studies the administration of public and private agencies of social service, with special reference to the following topics: Forms and sources of relief, treatment of special types of dependents, medical social service, organization of charity, financial management, modification of charitable trusts, supervision by public and private agencies and principles and methods of social settlements and kindred forms of neighborhood work. The course may serve as an introduction to Social Ethics 20c.
There will be frequent personal conferences on reading and field work.
Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 2
1913-14
- 2hf. Dr. Brackett. — Administration of Agencies for Poor Relief and Neighborhood Welfare.
Total 5: 1 Senior; 2 Juniors; 2 Sophomores.
Final Examination
Social Ethics 2
1913-14
1. What is your idea of the
(a)underlying purposes,
(b)the leading methods,
of a social settlement?
2. What argument would you use, to try to persuade a “ministers’ meeting” in a town of ten thousand persons that there is need of a society for organizing charity in their town?
3. What should be the attitude of relief agencies to families in distress because their wage-earners go on a strike?
4. A. What were the leading suggestions of
(a)the majority report,
(b)the minority report,
of the English Poor Law Commission of 1909, as to public aid in relief of distress?
B. What do you think of the majority and the minority reports of the English Commission of 1909 as bearing on the causes of distress?
5. Outline a state policy for dealing with one of the following types: —
A. The feeble-minded
or
B. The delinquent.
6. You are a comparatively new subscriber to a charitable agency whose purposes, as set forth in its publications, seem to you to be very important. It is supported by subscriptions and is under the management of a small board of directors elected at the annual meeting of subscribers. You think, especially from what you hear from social workers in other agencies, that this agency is not well developed, is wasting opportunities of service to the community. What ways would you suggest for securing improvement in the work of that agency?
_________________________
SOCIAL ETHICS 3
Course Description
[omitted 1913-14]
[*3 1hf. Criminology and Penology. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and reports. Half-course (first half-year).]
Omitted in 1913-14.
This course offers a study of crime and its prevention, and includes investigation of historical and of present conditions. The subjects considered comprise the following: methods of study in criminology; classes of crimes and of criminals; causes and effects of crime; prevalent conceptions of crime and of the treatment which society should accord it; agencies especially intended for the punishment and prevention of crime (including certain features of criminal law and its administration, the identification of criminals, the indeterminate sentence, institutions for the detention, punishment, and reformation of criminals, the supervision and aid of convicts on probation or parole or after discharge, and special methods for dealing with young criminals); the influence on the volume of crime of various agencies designed for general social betterment.
_________________________
SOCIAL ETHICS 41
Course Description
1913-14
*4 1hf. Immigration and Race Problems. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and a research. Half-course (first half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 11. Asst. Professor Foerster.
This course deals principally with immigration into the United States, in its international aspects and as an internal problem; secondarily, with the American negro problem. Emigration from foreign countries is first studied — in its causes, its historical course, and its consequences for the countries from which it proceeds. Next are considered the history of immigration into the United States; the condition of immigrants in this country; and the effects, transitory and permanent, upon the United States, under social, industrial, and racial aspects. Questions of American internal policy (contact, utilization, assimilation) and the question of national policy (restriction, non-restriction, selection, protection) are studied, partly in relation to emigration and immigration legislation of other countries. To the negro problem less time is devoted; the rural and urban populations, their economic and social changes in the post-slavery period, and the broad questions of public and private policy are considered.
The method of the course is analytical rather than historical or descriptive. Special emphasis is laid on the thesis, and from time to time research conferences are substituted for lectures.
Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 4
1913-14
- 1hf. Asst. Professor Foerster. — Immigration and Race Problems.
Total 21: 5 Graduates; 2 Seniors; 3 Juniors; 3 Sophomores; 2 Freshmen; 6 Others.
Final Examination
Social Ethics 4
1913-14
Answer questions in the order given. So allot your time that you may answer all. When your conclusions differ from those reached in the course, it is best to indicate wherein and why. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.
I (about 1 hr.)
Comment upon the following citations made from Stelzle’s “American Social and Religious Conditions,” by answering the correspondingly numbered questions below.
1. “The condition of the labor market in the U. S. determines the number of foreigners that come and go, so that the immigrant is in a constant state of flux.”
1. What evidence can you adduce to prove or disprove this statement? How completely are the changes in the demand for labor reflected in the “flux”?
2. “To-day by the mere fact of his arrival, every immigrant increases the value of the land in the United States by $500. Every new-born babe has the same effect upon land values.”
2. How do you prove or disprove this statement? Can you illustrate your argument by citing the position of negroes and Italians in Mississippi?
3. “They come to us, most of these immigrants, after their own countries have paid the cost of their education. They are ready to take up their day’s work the moment they land on our American shore.”
3. Briefly describe the condition of new immigrants as to education and fitness for economic activity.
4. “Not only do they rapidly adopt American customs, but their personal and bodily appearance undergoes a marked change. In many instances, the children of the immigrant show greater height and weight than the same race in the mother country, and in some cases, even the head form, which has always been considered one of the most stable and permanent characteristics of races has undergone very great changes. . . . If these physical changes are so great, we may well conclude that the whole mental and even moral circumstances of the people may also rapidly change under the new conditions.”
4. Discuss the logic of the conclusion as to mental and moral qualities. Giving your reasons in some detail, state whether
(1) the presumption is that immigration
(a)will improve our future race stock,
(b)will not affect it in any respect, or
(c)will hurt it,
or (2) our knowledge of heredity justifies no presumption at all.
5. “However, it must not be assumed that there are no perils in the foreigners who are coming to us in such large numbers. It is quite possible that in many respects they may become an undigested mass. One of the problems which concerns us is that of distribution.”
5. How far and in what sense is distribution practicable? Would its ulterior consequences be good or ill?
II (not more than 1½ hrs.)
6. Hourwich holds that rates of wages are not affected, adversely at least, by immigration. How does he seek to prove his argument? What is your chief reason for accepting or rejecting his argument?
7. How does Fairchild reply to Hourwich’s contention that immigrants have made it possible for American wage earners to rise?
8. Compare the industrial and social consequences of the legal restriction of child or woman labor with those of the legal restriction of unskilled or low-skilled immigration. How is demand for labor related to changes in rates of wages?
9. (Briefly.) Suppose all public and philanthropic expenditures upon immigrants to cease, what main results would follow?
10. “Reading and writing the English language would be our next demand for him. For this we should ask state legislation, establishing compulsory education for non-English speaking adults. If it be objected that school attendance could not be secured on account of the length of working hours, the obvious answer is that hours of labor which shut out all opportunity for exercise of the mental faculties or the social instincts, are thereby shown to be too long and should be reduced.” (Miss Claghorn, in the Survey, Dec. 27, ’13). Do you approve? Should public and philanthropic aid be given to permit immigrants (and Americans in the same occupations) to live according to the More and Chapin standards of efficiency ($800–900 in New York for a family)?
III (about ½ hr.)
11. What occupational training had negroes under slavery?
12. What are the gains and losses to Italy through emigration? Which are greater?
13. Describe either
(a) the boarding system among immigrants, (Fairchild) or
(b) the history, and its significance, of company houses in Lowell (Kenngott).
_________________________
SOCIAL ETHICS 5
Course Description
1913-14
*5 1hf. The Housing Problem. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and a research. Half-course (first half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 10. Asst. Professor Ford.
Primarily a course in social research. Each student is required to make an intensive survey of housing conditions in a selected district, or to undertake an original investigation in some detail of the subject. The lectures and prescribed reading deal with methods and results of existing housing surveys, with the causes and remedies of lot and room congestion, with problems of construction, sanitation, and maintenance of tenements, lodging houses, and cottages. The agencies of improved construction of dwellings — philanthropic, coöperative and governmental — are treated, together with methods of residential and industrial decentralization. The function of health and building codes, taxation, land reform, city planning, in the regulation and improvement of housing conditions, are examined in detail.
Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 5
1913-14
- 1hf. Asst. Professor James Ford. — The Housing Problem.
Total 9: 3 Graduates; 4 Seniors; 2 Others.
Final Examination
Social Ethics 5
1913-14
Answer all questions fully and with precision. Avoid irrelevant discussion. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.
1. Outline the problem of room overcrowding in (a) American and (b) English cities. (c) State the provisions of the New York Tenement House Act (1909) which are designed to control this evil. (d) What means of control are suggested by Veiller (“Room Overcrowding and the Lodger Evil”)? (e) Show the merits and the limitations of (c) and (d). (f) By what further measures can this problem be met advantageously?
2. Outline a practicable housing policy for Boston, that would preclude further disasters of the type of the recent “Arcadia” fire.
3. Outline the provisions of the New York Tenement House Act which deal with the enforcement of that Act.
4. Give a criticism of Howard’s plan for the establishment and operation of Garden Cities. (a) What parts of Howard’s scheme are impracticable? (b) What parts are practicable and of value?
5. “No apartment house shall be erected in residential districts unless the consent of two-thirds of the owners of land in the block in which the erection is proposed, is obtained.” (Ordinance of Calgary, Alberta, 1912.)
(a)What undesirable conditions is this ordinance designed to prevent?
(b)Are these conditions met in a satisfactory way by this ordinance? (Give your reasons in detail.)
(c)Discuss the merits of the “Zone System” as an alternative means of excluding apartment houses from residential districts.
6. “The housing problem is a land problem.”
(a)What is meant by this statement?
(b)In how far is it correct?
(c)Enumerate all methods by which the “land problem” may be attacked to improve housing conditions.
(d)Which of these methods would you urge for immediate adoption in Massachusetts?
(e)Why do you urge these methods?
(f)Why do you exclude other methods?
_________________________
SOCIAL ETHICS 6
Course Description
1913-14
*6 2hf. Social Amelioration in Europe, with especial reference to Social Insurance. — Lectures and prescribed reading. Half-course (second half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 11. Asst. Professor Foerster.
This course is mainly concerned with schemes of social amelioration that have so far been little developed in the United States. It makes a comparative study of the preventive and constructive measures, public and private, of several countries. After a brief consideration of the function of thrift institutions, unemployment and such devices for dealing with it as relief works, labor exchanges, benefit systems, insurance and labor colonies are discussed. Experience in provision for accident, sickness, invalidity, and old age, by systems of compensation, pensions and insurance, are examined. The course closes with a study of recent developments of legislation governing conditions of labor.
The treatment is throughout inductive. The incidence of the burden of comprehensive social measures, their ulterior effects upon the population and the significance of the principles they involve are frequently discussed.
Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 6
1913-14
- 2hf. Asst. Professor Foerster. — Social Amelioration in Europe, with special reference to Social Insurance.
Total 21: 6 Graduates; 2 Seniors; 6 Juniors; 2 Sophomores; 1 Freshman; 4 Others.
Final Examination
Social Ethics 6
1913-14
So allot your time that you may answer all questions. Your opinions should be supported by reasons, which should take account of the arguments of both reading and lectures.
1. “Take the case of one employer who employs ten men on Monday and another who employs ten men in the same class of employment on Tuesday. If there is no such organisation as that contemplated by the labour exchanges, the result will be you will have twenty men partially employed on those two days. The express object of the organisation of the labour exchanges is that instead of having twenty men partially employed, you will have ten men fully employed. . . . Not only will the establishment of labour exchanges not add to employment, but if they are to serve the only purpose which they can economically serve, the necessary consequence of their establishment must be actually to diminish employment. . . . I think it is important that those who are pressing forward this proposal to start labour exchanges should realise that the inevitable economic consequence of establishing those exchanges will be that you will diminish the number of men who can find work of any kind, although you are going to give them a larger living wage.” — F. E. Smith, House of Commons, May 19, 1909.
(a)By what reasoning do you sustain or oppose this argument? In your answer consider Beveridge’s reply to objections to decasualization.
(b)Outline the English system of labor exchanges and indicate whether, because of it, there will be less unemployment during the next cyclical period of depression than there would be if the system had not been established.
2. “But when I look beyond and ask whether it is conceivable that we may begin so to hold out the thought that men may be able to receive from the State that which in olden days they won by their own strong labours, self-denial, and thrift, then I am apprehensive lest we should, in attempting to do a good, do a great and grievous wrong, robbing ourselves and our children of that which is the best inheritance, the inheritance of a sturdy, strong, self-reliant manhood, that will take upon itself the responsibilities of life and be equal, therefore, to the responsibilities of Empire.” — Bishop of Ripon, House of Lords, July 20, 1908, speaking on the bill for old age pensions.
In which of their provisions do the laws dealing with old age in England, Denmark, Belgium, and Germany (considered in order) favor or hinder the maintenance of self-reliance in the population? In your discussion of the English situation review the argument of Hobhouse.
3. Where does the financial burden of old age provision ultimately fall (a) in England, (b) in Germany?
4. “Depend upon it, this Bill when it passes is the death warrant of the friendly societies of this country. . . . It is because I believe that in its present form this Bill is a great danger to liberty that I think it is vital that the country should have a further opportunity of expressing its opinion upon it and of saying whether it desires to have these German shackles put upon it, or whether it would not prefer to have a scheme founded upon the principle of liberty and independence.” — Lord Robert Cecil, House of Commons, December 6, 1911, speaking on the bill for sickness insurance.
(a)Compare the organization and history of the friendly societies with the organization and history of the French mutual aid societies; why the difference of result?
(b)Point out the similarities of the provisions of English and German sickness insurance.
(c)Would you, like Lord Cecil, oppose the state’s interference with the voluntary societies of England? Why?
5. Point out the technical difference between an assessment and a premium system of insurance against industrial accidents. What type exists in Austria? in Germany? How is the employer affected by the two types?
6. Describe (a) Danish unemployment insurance.
(b) Choice and remuneration of doctors under Danish and German sickness insurance.
_________________________
SOCIAL ETHICS 7
Course Description
1913-14
*7 2hf. Rural Social Development. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and a thesis. Half-course (second half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 10. Asst. Professor Ford.
This course deals with the methods of rural social research, and with measures for the improvement of rural social conditions. It begins with an examination of the distribution of rural population in the United States, the bearing of physical and economic environments and of racial distribution upon local social problems. The causes of rural depopulation, degeneracy, poverty, disease are examined, with special reference to ascertaining the means of prevention. Measures are considered for the development of country life from without through “back-to-the-land” movements, urban and State assistance; and for rural reconstruction from within through adaptation of existing local institutions and through coöperative movements.
The third hour of each week is devoted to the discussion of prescribed reading or to direction of research.
Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 7
1913-14
- 2hf. Asst. Professor James Ford. — Rural Social Development.
Total 17: 5 Graduates; 4 Seniors; 2 Juniors; 4 Sophomores; 2 Others.
Final Examination
Social Ethics 7
1913-14
Answer all questions fully and with precision. Avoid irrelevant discussion. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.
1. What data concerning poverty should be sought for a rural social survey in a Massachusetts township? Why is each item important? What are the possible sources of the data on local poverty?
2. Is it wise to place immigrants who were farmers in the country of their birth on farms in this country? Give all important arguments pro and con. Qualify your conclusions where necessary.
3. (a) Define pageant. Outline the plot of the Thetford pageant. Show how the pageant may be made a means of rural social development.
(b) What evidence have we of the part played by environment in producing the degeneracy of the Hill Folk?
4. Describe the work of the Laurel Hill Improvement Society of Stockbridge, Massachusetts. What methods and program for village improvement societies does experience prove to be most effective?
5. Outline the problems of recreation that are characteristic of rural communities. Name four groups of agencies by which these problems might be met. Select one sex and age group and show what is now done and what might be done by each agency to meet the recreation problem of that group.
6. Give arguments for and against consolidation of rural schools. Defend your conclusion.
7. What are the prerequisites of successful co-operation among farmers? (Powell, chap. on “Fundamentals in Co-operation,” and lectures.)
8. Describe fully and critically the forms of co-operative organization and the business methods of California fruit growers.
9. How may rural communities be distinguished from urban?
_________________________
SOCIAL ETHICS 81
Course Description
1913-14
*8 1hf. Child-Helping Agencies: Their Problems and Methods. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and field work under skilled direction. Half-course (first half-year). Tu., Th., at 2.30, and a conference hour by appointment. Dr. Carstens.
This course studies the important phases of child-helping work in well-equipped communities. It treats of the social service rendered by the institutions and the family homes which receive dependent or neglected children, of juvenile courts, probation, training schools for juvenile delinquents, and of the various forms of child protection. The methods of training children defective in sight, hearing, and speech, and the training of the mentally defective are studied. Illegitimacy, infant mortality, and child labor are studied in their bearing upon the work of child-helping agencies.
Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 8
1913-14
- 1hf. Dr. Carstens. — Child-Helping Agencies.
Total 3: 2 Graduates; 1 Sophomore.
Final Examination
Social Ethics 8
1913-14
1. Give the significant steps in the development of the care of dependent children in the United States.
2. Show the inter-relationship of dependence, neglect, and delinquence, and illustrate by examples.
3. What is meant by “The Subsidy System in Private Charity”? Give arguments pro and con.
4. Make clear in what way feeble-mindedness becomes a community concern, and illustrate by examples.
5. What is meant by: (a) Mothers’ Pensions, (b) Guardianship, (c) Binet System, (d) Prenatal Care; and explain their relation to community care for children.
Sources:
Harvard University. Report of the President of Harvard College, 1913-14. Pages 60-61.
Papers set for final examinations in history, history of science, government, economics, philosophy, psychology, social ethics, education, fine arts, music in Harvard College (June, 1914), pp. 74-83.
Image Source: “Die deutsche Sozialversicherung steht in der ganzen Welt vorbildlich und unerreicht da.” Landesarchiv Baden-Württemberg, Hauptstaatsarchiv Stuttgart J 151 Nr 2230, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.