Categories
Exam Questions Harvard Social Insurance Social Work

Harvard. Social Ethics Description, Enrollment, Exams. 1915-1916

Note: Materials for courses offered by the economics department in 1915-16 have been previously posted.

SOCIAL ETHICS

Social Ethics 1-8
1915-16

Social Ethics 1. Social Problems and Social Policy
Social Ethics 2. Poor-Relief and Neighborhood Work
Social Ethics 3. Criminology and Penology [omitted 1915-16]
Social Ethics 4. Immigration and Race Problems
Social Ethics 5. The Housing Problem
Social Ethics 6. Unemployment and Other Interruptions of Income
Social Ethics 7. Rural Social Development
Social Ethics 8. Child-Helping Agencies

GENERAL STATEMENT

The courses of this Department are designed to study methods of social research and policies for social improvement.

Course 1 offers a general survey of social problems and of agencies and methods of social betterment. Students are advised before taking it to take introductory courses in Economics and in Philosophy.

Courses 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8 are open to students who have received a satisfactory grade in Social Ethics 1. They are also open to Juniors and Seniors who have not taken Social Ethics 1 but who are otherwise amply equipped. These courses all deal intensively with specific social problems, — with conditions, principles, and policy.

Courses 2 and 8, offered by officials of Massachusetts charitable organizations, are largely concerned with methods and problems of administration.

Course 5 is primarily a course in research. Field work is required in Courses 2, 5, and 8, and can be assigned upon request in Courses 4 and 7.

Courses 20, 20a and 20b are designed for candidates for higher degrees. Courses 20c and 20d are professional courses intended for students who wish to train for administrative positions.

I. Courses for Undergraduates and Graduates

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 1

Course Description
1915-16

1. Social Problems and Social Policy. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and theses. Tu., Th., Sat., at 10. Asst. Professor Foerster and Asst. Professor Ford, assisted by Mr. Loomis.(XI)

This course gives a survey of contemporary social problems with special reference to principles and methods of social amelioration. It begins with a discussion of the bearing of ethics upon social and economic problems and seeks throughout to apply ethical principles to specific problems. Among the subjects dealt with are the methods of social investigation, immigration, incomes and expenditures, the methods of public and private relief of poverty, delinquent and defective classes, control of the liquor traffic, the family, housing, public recreation, wages and hours of labor of men, women, and children, industrial disputes and their settlement, compensation for accidents, workmen’s insurance, producers’ and consumers’ coöperation, profit-sharing, socialism, and of other radical programmes.

An important feature of the course is a thesis in the first term dealing with problems of poverty, and in the second term dealing with labor problems; either or both of these may involve field work.

The thesis requirement may also be met by an adaptation of field work performed for certain civic and social organizations of Boston and Cambridge under the direction of the Department of Social Ethics.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 1
1915-16

  1. Asst. Professor Foerster and Asst. Professor James Ford, assisted by Mr. [Robert Herbert] Loomis. — Social Problems and Social Policy. Principles and Methods of Social Amelioration.

Total 78: 2 Graduates; 12 Seniors; 27 Juniors; 17 Sophomores; 1 Freshman; 19 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 1
1915-16

Answer questions in the order given. So allot your time that you may answer all. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.

1.(a)Discuss the public regulation of hours of labor of men in the United States in public work and in private work.

(b)Is there public regulation of men’s wages in the United States?

2.(a)What has been the experience of Australia in compulsory arbitration of industrial disputes?

(b)Should there be provision for compulsory arbitration in modern industrial societies? Give your argument in full.

3. Which system of providing old age pensions, the English or the German, should be used as a general model by our American states? Why?

4. In what ways are the interests of the wage earner harmed by scientific management? In what ways are they advanced?

5.(a)What moral values lie in the institution of “welfare work”?

(b)What moral values lie in the institution of “industrial partnership”?

6. Treat briefly (a) an American example of profit sharing, (b) the social philosophy of Robert Owen, (c) the Social Revolution.

7. Contrast contemporary socialism, French syndicalism and the British co-operative movement with reference to their plans for the socialization of industry.

8. What criticism does ethics make of the contemporary economic system?

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 22

Course Description
1915-16

*2 2hf. Poor Relief and Neighborhood Work. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and field work. Half-course (second half-year). Tu., Th., at 2.30, and frequent conferences by special appointment. Dr. Brackett.(XV)

This course studies the leading principles and methods of social service, with special reference to the following topics: Forms and sources of relief, treatment of special types of dependents, medical social service, organization of charity, financial management, modification of charitable trusts, supervision by public and private agencies, conduct of social settlements and kindred forms of neighborhood work. The course may serve as an introduction to Social Ethics 20c.

There will be frequent personal conferences on reading and field work.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 22
1915-16

  1. 2hf. Dr. Brackett. — Poor-Relief and Neighborhood Work.

Total 10: 4 Seniors; 3 Juniors; 1 Sophomore; 2 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 22
1915-16

1. In taking up neighborhood work, — (1) What elements in the neighborhood would you especially aim to reach? (2) What ways of making contact with them would you follow first?

2. Do we wish persons falling or likely soon to fall into need to apply quickly at agencies for relief? Give your reasons.

3. What conditions led to the appointment of the English Poor Law Commissioners in 1832?
Give the chief recommendations of their report.
Are those recommendations of practical value today?

4. What is insanity?
What is feeble-mindedness?
Choosing one of these types, give the chief features of a programme for dealing with it which a state should adopt.

5. What defects in previous methods of treating offenders is the probation system designed to remove?

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 31
[omitted 1915-16]

Course Description
1915-16

[*3 1hf. Criminology and Penology. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and reports. Half-course (first half-year).]

Omitted in 1915-16.

This course deals with the causes, treatment, and prevention of crime. It begins with an analysis of theories of criminology, paying special attention to anthropological, pathological, and sociological theories in an attempt to separate individual and environmental factors. A study is then made of methods applied to the apprehension and conviction of criminals. In connection with an examination of criminal legislation, historical materials are dealt with and special contemporary problems are examined. Systems of penology are compared and analyzed with reference to their aims, the methods of their application, and their effects upon the criminal and upon society. Special study is made of measures for the reformation of criminals and for the prevention of crime.

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 41

Course Description
1915-16

4 1hf. Immigration and Race Problems. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and a research. Half-course (first half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 11. Asst. Professor Foerster.(IV)

This course deals principally with immigration into the United States, in its international aspects and as an internal problem; secondarily, with the American negro problem. Emigration from foreign countries is first studied, — in its causes, its historical course, and its consequences for the countries from which it proceeds. Next are considered the history of immigration into the United States; the condition of immigrants in this country; and the effects, transitory and permanent, upon the United States, under social, industrial, and racial aspects. Questions of American internal policy (contact, utilization, assimilation) and the question of national policy (restriction, non-restriction, selection, protection) are studied, partly in relation to emigration and immigration legislation of other countries. To the negro problem less time is devoted; the rural and urban populations, their economic and social changes in the post-slavery period, and the broad questions of public and private policy are considered.

The method of the course is analytical rather than historical or descriptive. Special emphasis is laid on the thesis, since the opportunities for research in the subject are abundant.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 41
1915-16

  1. 1hf. Asst. Professor Foerster. — Immigration and Race Problems.

Total 36: 4 Graduates; 16 Seniors; 6 Juniors; 1 Sophomore; 9 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 41
1915-16

Answer questions in the order given. So allot your time that you may answer all. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.

I. (Two Hours.)

Answer the questions based on the following correspondence. The question numbers refer to passages in the correspondence designated by like numbers.

Department of Commerce and Labor
Washington, February 12, 1913.

My dear Mr. President:

On the 4th instant Mr. Hilles, by your direction, sent me Senate Bill No. 3175, . . . with the request that I inform you, at my earliest convenience, if I know of any objection to its approval. I now return the bill with my comments.

. . . With respect to the literacy test, I feel compelled to state a different conclusion. . . . It involves a principle of far-reaching consequence with respect to which your attitude will be regarded with profound interest.

. . . The measure proposes to reach its result by indirection, and is defended purely upon the ground of practical policy, the final purpose being to reduce the quantity of cheap labor in this country. I can not accept this argument. No doubt the law would exclude a considerable percentage of immigration from southern Italy, among the Poles, the Mexicans and the Greeks. This exclusion would embrace probably in large part undesirable but also a great many desirable people, and the embarrassment, expense, and distress to those who seek to enter would be out of all proportion to any good that can possibly be promised for this measure. [1.]

My observation leads me to the conclusion that, so far as the merits of the individual immigrant are concerned, the test is altogether overestimated. The people who come from the countries named are frequently illiterate because opportunities have been denied them. The oppression with which these people have to contend in modern time is not religious, but it consists of a denial of the opportunity to acquire reading and writing. Frequently the attempt to learn to read and write the language of the particular people is discouraged by the government, and these immigrants in coming to our shores are really striving to free themselves from the conditions under which they have been compelled to live. [2.]

So far as the industrial conditions are concerned, I think the question has been superficially considered. We need labor in this country, and the natives are unwilling to do the work which the aliens come over to do. It is perfectly true that in a few cities and localities there are congested conditions. It is equally true that in very much larger areas we are practically without help. In my judgment, no sufficiently earnest and intelligent effort has been made to bring our wants and our supply together. . . . In my judgment, no such drastic measure based upon a ground which is untrue and urged for a reason which we are unwilling to assert should be adopted until we have at least exhausted the possibilities of a rational distribution of these new forces. [3.]

Furthermore, there is a misapprehension as to the character of the people who come over here to remain. It is true that in certain localities newly arrived aliens live under deplorable conditions. Just as much may be said of certain localities that have been inhabited for a hundred years by natives of this country. These are not the general conditions, but they are the exceptions. . . . A careful examination of the character of the people who come to stay and of the employment in which a large part of the new immigration is engaged will, in my judgment, dispel the apprehension which many of our people entertain. The census will disclose that with rapid strides the foreign-born citizen is acquiring the farm lands of this country. Even if the foreign-born alone is considered, the percentage of his ownership is assuming a proportion that ought to attract the attention of the native citizens. If the second generation is included it is safe to say that in the Middle West and West a majority of the farms are today owned by foreign-born people or they are descendants of the first generation. This does not embrace only the Germans and the Scandinavians, but is true in large measure, for illustration, of the Bohemians and the Poles. It is true in surprising measure of the Italians; not only of the northern Italians, but of the southern. . . . [4.]

The census returns show conclusively that the importance of illiteracy among aliens is overestimated, and that these people are prompt after their arrival to avail themselves of the opportunities which this country affords. While, according to the reports of the Bureau of Immigration, about 25 per cent of the incoming aliens are illiterate, the census shows that among the foreign-born people of such States as New York and Massachusetts where most of the congestion complained of has taken place, the proportion of illiteracy represents only about 13 per cent. [5.]

I am persuaded that his provision of the bill is in principle of very great consequence. . . . I am forced to advise that you do not approve this bill. [6.]

Very sincerely yours,
Charles Nagel, Secretary.

To the Senate:

. . . I can not make up my mind to sign a bill which in its chief provision violates a principle that ought in my opinion to be upheld in dealing with our immigration. I refer to the literacy test. For the reasons stated in Secretary Nagel’s letter to me, I can not approve that test. The Secretary’s letter accompanies this. [7.]

Wm. H. Taft.

February 14th, 1913.

1. What are your reasons for holding that the statement as to exclusion of desirable people is (a) true or untrue, and (b) important or unimportant?

2 and 5. (a) Do the census figures prove what this paragraph claims? If you think not, what do you consider that they do indicate? In general, to what extent do foreigners find and utilize in this country an educational opportunity denied them at home?

(b) Does emigration of the illiterate, as, for example, from South Italy, lead to the establishment of schools in the home land? Does it in the long run reduce the numbers or proportion of the illiterate population in the home land? In connection with the last question discuss the evidence as to the effect of emigration upon the size of the population of the home country.

3. In what sense do we, or do we not, need labor? What significance do you attach to the statement that Americans are unwilling to do the work that aliens do? How far are the present problems of immigration due to defective distribution? Trace the consequences as to living conditions and as to further immigration which you suppose would have followed had a “rational distribution” been established in 1908.

4. What main evidence can you present as to the occupations and incomes of immigrants? How large a proportion of the immigrants who have arrived in the last twenty years go into agriculture? Can you indicate to what extent the economic position of immigrants improves during their sojourn here? Can you present evidence as to the economic position of immigrants’ children?

6 and 7. What “principle” is in question? What can you say for or against the principle?

II. (One Hour.)

1. (a) What past experiences and characteristics of the negro which are set forth by Tillinghast contribute, in your opinion, to an understanding of the present economic position of the negro as set forth by Stone and Ovington?

(b) In what ways would a wise internal policy regarding the negro take account of this analysis of the factors in the negro problem?

2. “As long as the community tolerates bad housing so that underpaid workmen can be accommodated, the workmen will continue to be underpaid.” (Report of Massachusetts Immigration Commission, p. 57). Is this true? In general, what relation exists between high community standards and the wages of immigrants?

3. Briefly outline the causes of Jewish emigration from Russia.

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 51

Course Description
1915-16

5 1hf. The Housing Problem. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and research. Half-course (first half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 10. Asst. Professor Ford.(III)

Primarily a course in social research. Each student is required to make an intensive survey of housing conditions in a selected district, or to undertake an original investigation in some detail of the subject. The lectures and prescribed reading deal with the methods and results of existing housing surveys, with the causes and remedies of lot and room congestion, with problems of construction, sanitation, and maintenance of tenements, lodging-houses, and cottages. The agencies of improved construction of dwellings — philanthropic, coöperative and governmental — are treated, together with methods of residential and industrial decentralization. The function of health and building codes, taxation, land reform, and city planning, in the regulation and improvement of housing conditions, are examined in detail.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 51
1915-16

  1. 1hf. Asst. Professor James Ford. — The Housing Problem.

Total 10: 4 Seniors; 2 Juniors; 1 Sophomore; 3 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 51
1915-16

Answer all questions fully and with precision. Avoid irrelevant discussion. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.

1. What provisions should be inserted in a housing law to ensure enforcement of the law? Treat under headings: (a) general powers of enforcing body, (b) penalties, (c) procedure.

2. Describe the following briefly showing the special contribution each has made to the betterment of housing conditions: (a) Copartnership Tenants Ltd., (b) Goodyear Heights, (c) English Town Planning Act of 1909.

3. Enumerate and illustrate the peculiar educational functions of philanthropic societies interested in housing. Cite examples wherever possible.

4. Describe the organization, aims and general working methods of (a) building and loan associations, (b) copartnership tenants’ societies.

5. Compare the five types of agency for suburban development with respect to (a) efficiency in reducing rentals, (b) moral value of the personal relationships of tenant to agent involved in each.

6. Defend residential decentralization on moral grounds. (Reduce each of the arguments for residential decentralization to ethical terms.)

7. Compare Gary, Ill. and Garden City, Letchworth, England, with respect to (a) city plan, (b) house types, (c) ownership of land and houses, (d) civic and social life.

8. (a) Show in what ways lot dimensions may affect housing conditions; (b) Show by diagram and explanation how a typical tenement block 200′ × 400′ with lots 25′ × 100′ can be converted for the development (1) of the Philadelphia type of house, (2) of the detached cottage.

9. What social policy would you recommend with reference to future construction of three-flat houses. (In the course of your answer show all of the current arguments for and against the construction of three-flat houses and define narrowly the measures which should govern their construction.)

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 6

Course Description
1915-16

6 2hf. Unemployment and other Interruptions of Income, with Special Consideration of Social Insurance. — Lectures and prescribed reading. Half-course (second half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 11. Asst. Professor Foerster.(IV)

This course is mainly concerned with schemes of social amelioration that have so far been little developed in the United States. It makes a comparative study of the preventive and constructive measures, public and private, of several countries. After a brief consideration of the function of thrift institutions, unemployment, and such devices for dealing with it as relief works, labor exchanges, benefit systems, insurance, and labor colonies are discussed. Experience in provision for accident, sickness, invalidity, and old age, by systems of compensation, pensions, and insurance, is examined in the remainder of the course. While the institutions studied are of necessity chiefly European, the course considers the situation of the United States and suggests a programme of action for the United States.

The treatment is throughout inductive. The incidence of the burden of comprehensive social measures, their ulterior effects upon the population and the significance of the principles they involve are frequently discussed.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 62
1915-16

  1. 2hf. Asst. Professor Foerster. — Unemployment and Other Interruptions of Income, with Special Consideration of Social Insurance.

Total 37: 5 Graduates; 14 Seniors; 7 Juniors; 1 Sophomore; 10 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 62
1915-16

Answer questions in the order given. So allot your time that you may answer all. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.

1.(a)Point out the ways in which the British system of public labor exchanges is superior to our state systems.

(b)What arguments can you present for and against the following recommendation made in the Minority Report of the Royal Commission on the Poor Laws (1909)?

“We propose that it should be made legally compulsory on employers . . . in all those cases in which it is not convenient to them to guarantee a minimum period of employment, which might be put at a month . . . to hire such labor as they want, whether for a job, a day, or a week, exactly as is done without complaint in the mercantile marine, exclusively through the National Labour Exchange.”

2. What are the characteristics of accident compensation legislation in Germany and in England with respect to:

(a)kind and amount of compensation?

(b)employments and injuries covered?

(c)method of administration?

(d)security of payment?

What provisions for security of payment exist in France, Italy and Norway? Compare the suitableness of compulsion in the payment of accident indemnities with that of compulsion in the use of labor exchanges.

3.(a)To what extent, directly or indirectly, does the German workman contribute to the old age pensions provision of his country?

(b)In the House of Lords, July 10, 1908, the Earl of Cromer, speaking in opposition to the old age pensions bill, said,

“When the burden of the fresh taxation which is inevitable begins to be felt, and when in times of national emergency all patriotic men cry out for these lost millions, let it be known, at all events, on whom rests the true responsibility for the creation of so sombre a situation. . . . That responsibility [rests] with the House of Commons.”

On the same day, the Marquis of Lansdowne said,

“Nor was I convinced that arrangements which have been found perfectly workable in Germany . . . should be so entirely impossible of adoption in this country. But I wish to notice for one moment an arrangement which has been often advanced, and which is to this effect, that this is really a contributory scheme.”

To what extent, directly or indirectly, does the English workman contribute to the old age pensions provision of his country? Discuss the utterances of the Earl of Cromer and the Marquis of Lansdowne.

(c)Which law for old age pensions, the German or the English, is the better? Why?

4. Compare sickness insurance in the United States with that of England or of Germany with respect to (a) forms and extent; (b) democratic or co-operative elements in administration.

5. Outline the arguments (a) of Belloc; (b) of Bernhard regarding the consequences of recent forms of social legislation. Upon what grounds do you rest your judgment of these arguments?

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 72

Course Description
1915-16

7 2hf. Rural Social Development. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and a thesis. Half-course (second half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 10. Asst. Professor Ford.(III)

This course deals with the methods of rural social research, and with measures for the improvement of rural social conditions. It begins with an examination of the distribution of rural population in the United States, the bearing of physical and economic environments and of racial distribution upon local social problems. The causes of rural depopulation, degeneracy, poverty, and disease are examined with special reference to ascertaining the means of prevention. Measures are considered for the development of country life from without through “back-to-the-land” movements, and through urban and state assistance; and for rural reconstruction from within through adaptation of existing local institutions and through coöperative movements.

The third hour of each week is devoted to the discussion of prescribed reading or to direction of research.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 72
1915-16

  1. 2hf. Asst. Professor James Ford. — Rural Social Development.

Total 24: 2 Graduates; 5 Seniors; 6 Juniors; 3 Sophomores; 8 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 72
1915-16

Answer all questions fully and with precision. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.

1.(a)What data should be secured in a thorough rural social survey concerning the use of leisure time?

(b)How and from what sources are these data to be secured?

(c)How is such investigation to be justified?

2.(a)What is the bearing of economic condition upon morality?

(b)Enumerate the immediate causes of poverty in rural communities.

(c)What in general are the appropriate agencies of relief of poverty of each type described in (b)? Why?

3. Discuss briefly:

(a)Bohemian immigrants in agriculture.

(b)Woodbine Settlement, N. J.

(c)Pellagra.

(d)Irish Agricultural Organization Society.

4.(a)What are present methods of caring for the sick in rural communities?

(b)Show the relative merits of the four groups of agencies now providing nursing service.

(c)Outline a social policy to provide adequate treatment for the sick in rural America.

5. What are the agencies and forms of:

(a)civic education,

(b)business education (exclude agriculture),

(c)education in hygiene,

which are, or should be available, in rural communities?

6.(a)Show the peculiar merits of the following as sources of moral education:

Organized play (illustrate from one of the typical games of the adolescent period).

Agricultural coöperation (illustrate from fruit-growers’ associations).

(b)Outline a program for the promotion of needful play for rural children over 12 years of age.

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 81

Course Description
1915-16

8 1hf. Child-Helping Agencies: Their Problems and Methods. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and field work. Half-course (first half-year). Tu., Th., at 2.30, and a conference hour by appointment. Dr. Carstens.(XV)

This course studies the important phases of child-helping work in well-equipped communities. It treats of the social service rendered by the institutions and the family homes which receive dependent or neglected children, of juvenile courts, probation, training schools for juvenile delinquents, and of the various forms of child protection. The methods of training children defective in sight, hearing, and speech, and the training of the mentally defective are studied. Illegitimacy, infant mortality and child labor are studied in their bearing upon the work of child-helping agencies.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 81
1915-16

  1. 1hf. Dr. Carstens. — Child-Helping Agencies.

Total 7: 2 Graduates; 4 Seniors; 1 Other.

Sources:

Division of Philosophy. Department of Philosophy and Psychology. Department of Social Ethics 1915-16. Published in Official Register of Harvard University, vol. XII, No. 1, Part 14 (April 28, 1915), pp. 35-38.

Harvard University. Report of the President of Harvard College, 1915-16. Page 67.

Papers set for final examinations in history, history of religions, history of science, government, economics, philosophy, psychology, social ethics, education, fine arts, music in Harvard College (June, 1916), pp. 94-102.

Image Source:  Pamphlets and Leaflets of … the Liberal Publication Department, Leaflet Number 2383. Courtesy British Library Images Online (Shelfmark: 08139.c.97).

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.