Categories
Exam Questions Harvard Social Insurance Social Work

Harvard. Social Ethics Description, Enrollment, Exams. 1914-1915

SOCIAL ETHICS

Social Ethics 1-8
1914-15

Social Ethics 1. Social Problems and Social Policy
Social Ethics 2. Poor-Relief and Neighborhood Work
Social Ethics 3. Criminology and Penology [omitted 1914-15]
Social Ethics 4. Immigration and Race Problems
Social Ethics 5. The Housing Problem
Social Ethics 6. Social Amelioration in Europe
Social Ethics 7. Rural Social Development
Social Ethics 8. Child-Helping Agencies

GENERAL STATEMENT

The courses of this Department are designed to apply ethical principles to social problems, to indicate methods of social research, and to discuss policies for social improvement.

Course 1 offers a general survey of social problems, of the agencies and methods of social betterment. Students are advised before taking it to take introductory courses in Economics and in Philosophy.

Courses 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8 are open to students who have received a satisfactory grade in Social Ethics 1. Juniors and Seniors specializing in Economics or Philosophy and graduate students are eligible to enrolment. These courses all deal intensively with specific social problems, — with conditions, principles, and policy. Courses 2 and 8, offered by officials of Massachusetts charitable organizations, are largely concerned with methods and problems of administration. Course 5 is primarily a course in research. Field work is required in Courses 2, 5, and 8, and can be assigned upon request in Courses 4 and 7.

Courses 20 and 20b are designed for candidates for higher degrees. Courses 20c and 20d are professional courses intended for students who wish to train for administrative positions.

For Undergraduates and Graduates

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 1

Course Description
1914-15

1.  Social Problems and Social Policy. — Lectures, prescribed reading, theses. Tu., Th., Sat., at 10. Asst. Professors Foerster and Ford, assisted by Mr. Staples.(XI)

This course gives a survey of contemporary social problems with special reference to principles and methods of social amelioration.

It begins with a discussion of the bearing of ethics upon social and economic problems and seeks throughout to apply ethical principles to specific problems. Among the subjects dealt with are the methods of social investigation, immigration, incomes and expenditures, the methods of public and private relief of poverty, delinquent and defective classes, control of the liquor traffic, the family, housing, public recreation, wages and hours of labor of men, women and children, industrial disputes and their settlement, compensation for accidents, workmen’s insurance, producers’ and consumers’ coöperation, profit-sharing, ethical aspects of socialism. An important feature of the course is a thesis in the first term dealing with problems of poverty, and in the second term dealing with labor problems; either or both of these may involve field work.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 1
1914-15

  1. Asst. Professor Foerster and Asst. Professor Ford, assisted by Mr. Staples. — Social Problems and Social Policy. Principles and Methods of Social Amelioration.

Total 102: 4 Graduates; 17 Seniors; 41 Juniors; 17 Sophomores; 23 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 1
1914-15

Answer questions in the order given. So allot your time that you may answer all. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.

1.  Describe the nature of recent legislation in the United States providing for the indemnification of industrial accidents. What special evils does such legislation entail? How, if at all, is it to be justified?

2.  What principles should be applied in industrial welfare work? Why?

3.  Having in mind the nature of unemployment and such measures for dealing with it as have been studied in this course, outline a programme of social policy for diminishing the seriousness of unemployment.

4.  Compare workers’ coöperative production and consumers’ coöperative production with respect to: —

(a)form of organization,

(b)management,

(c)remuneration of labor,

(d)distribution of profits.

Sketch the history in Great Britain of both sorts of coöperative production.

5.(a)What is the nature and the value of the Conseils de Prud’hommes.

(b)Criticize the main provisions of the protocol of the New York cloak, suit, and skirt makers’ unions.

6.  Contrast Great Britain with either Germany or Belgium with respect to the history, extent, and form of the consumers’ coöperative movement.

7.  “The main question is this: whether socialism will ever really be in a position to give effect, on its own ground, to the great psychological truth and economic utility which lies in the principle, according to which private interest is made a motive to the discharge of the functions of social production.”

How does Schaeffle answer this question? How would Spargo answer it? What is your answer?

8.  Is a decrease of personal liberty to be feared under socialism? Let your answer include an account of the arguments of Spargo and of Schaeffle.

9.  What is the programme of the Syndicalists for social reconstruction? Criticize this programme. What are your reasons for approving or disapproving this programme?

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 2

Course Description
1914-15

*2 2hf. Poor-Relief and Neighborhood Work. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and field work. Half-course (second half-year). Tu., Th., at 2.30, and frequent conferences by special appointment. Dr. Brackett.(XV)

This course studies the leading principles and methods of social service, with special reference to the following topics: Forms and sources of relief, treatment of special types of dependents, medical social service, organization of charity, financial management, modification of charitable trusts, supervision by public and private agencies, conduct of social settlements and kindred forms of neighborhood work. The course may serve as an introduction to Social Ethics 20c.

There will be frequent personal conferences on reading and field work.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 2
1914-15

  1. 2hf. Dr. Brackett. — Poor Relief and Neighborhood Work.

Total 12: 1 Graduate; 2 Seniors; 3 Juniors; 1 Sophomore; 5 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 2
1914-15

1.  Illustrate the purpose and leading methods of social work by: —

(a)A state policy for treatment of the feeble-minded; and

(b)A state policy for treatment of offenders.

2.  There are in the community a number of boys and young men who have been in the state reformatory school for boys. A suggestion is made that they form an association of alumni of the school.

What do you say for and against the plan?

3.  To what extent would you have the residents in a social settlement undertake to deal with persons who have shown marked anti-social tendencies, as with the drink habit.

4.  What were the chief differences between the work of the English Poor Law commissions of 1832–34 and 1905–09, as to: —

(a)The conditions which they found;

(b)Their recommendations.

5.  Comment on the following extract from a well-known worker and writer: —

“The eternal distinction of charity is that it is personal, the gift of man to man, warmed by feeling and guided by knowledge, where the gift and the giver go together. The state can by no lavishness take the place of such charity; and even when charity creates a fund, which it administers through officers and officials, the personality is lost, and the recipients feel nothing of the power of personal care and thought.”

6.  In a city of 25,000 inhabitants there is talk of the formation of an “Associated Charities.” The objection is made that there is no call for such an agency in such a place; that there are only a few charities, and that everybody knows everybody else.

What would you say in answer to such objections?

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 3
[not offered 1914-15]

Course Description
1914-15

*3 1hf. Criminology and Penology. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and reports. Half-course (first half-year).

This course offers a study of crime and its prevention, and includes investigation of historical and of present conditions. The subjects considered comprise the following: methods of study in criminology; classes of crimes and of criminals; causes and effects of crime; prevalent conceptions of crime and of the treatment which society should accord it; agencies especially intended for the punishment and prevention of crime (including certain features of criminal law and its administration, the identification of criminals, the indeterminate sentence, institutions for the detention, punishment, and reformation of criminals, the supervision and aid of convicts on probation or parole or after discharge, and special methods for dealing with young criminals); the influence on the volume of crime of various agencies designed for general social betterment.

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 41

Course Description
1914-15

4 1hf. Immigration and Race Problems. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and a research. Half-course (first half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 11. Asst. Professor Foerster.(IV)

This course deals principally with immigration into the United States, in its international aspects and as an internal problem; secondarily, with the American negro problem. Emigration from foreign countries is first studied — in its causes, its historical course, and its consequences for the countries from which it proceeds. Next are considered the history of immigration into the United States; the condition of immigrants in this country; and the effects, transitory and permanent, upon the United States, under social, industrial, and racial aspects. Questions of American internal policy (contact, utilization, assimilation) and the question of national policy (restriction, non-restriction, selection, protection) are studied, partly in relation to emigration and immigration legislation of other countries. To the negro problem less time is devoted; the rural and urban populations, their economic and social changes in the post-slavery period, and the broad questions of public and private policy are considered.

The method of the course is analytical rather than historical or descriptive. Special emphasis is laid on the thesis, and from time to time research conferences are substituted for lectures.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 4
1914-15

  1. 1hf. Asst. Professor Foerster. — Immigration and Race Problems.

Total 27: 5 Graduates; 8 Seniors; 8 Juniors; 6 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 4
1914-15

Answer questions in the order given. So allot your time that you may answer all. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.

1.  According to the Nation (November 19, 1914), Professor Tsaukoff of the University of Sofia calculates the cost to Bulgaria of the recent Balkan struggles as $256,000,000. “To this,” the editor comments, “must, of course, be added the immense damage wrought in the economic structure of the nation which lost a large part of its laboring population, — 58,000 men between twenty and forty-five years of age, or 6.7 per cent of the male workers.” A passage in the Quarterly Journal of Economics (November, 1908), is as follows: “For the entire kingdom [Italy] the permanent emigration has in effect deprived the country of one man in the fullest years of life out of every eight; for Campania and Basilicata, one out of six; for Calabria and Sardinia, one out of five.” How far, in your opinion, do the situations set forth in these citations coincide in their significance, and how far do they not?

2.  The view of an Irish bishop, who had visited America, is cited as follows by R. J. Kelley in “The Evils of Emigration”:

“Rarely is the condition of emigrants improved by their change of residence. . . . They are brought into daily contact with persons of little morality and less faith, and the struggle to maintain the soul in its primeval rectitude amid such surroundings often proves too great for the stability of human nature. Nor, in most instances, are the temporal circumstances of the emigrants benefited by the change. Were the same energy expended in industrial pursuits in our own country as is demanded abroad, those who have attained success in other lands would have been equally fortunate at home. . . . Indeed, everything considered, men who have experience of the conditions of life at home and abroad do not hesitate to express their preference for the quiet, innocent joys of an Irish rural home rather than for the irritating strain and wearying struggle which burden life elsewhere.”

Does your view of the gains or losses to immigrants in America agree or disagree with this view? What are the grounds of your opinion?

3.  At what points is the housing problem complicated by immigration?

4.  Wherein is the immigration problem related to (a) the question of a protective tariff, (b) the invention and use of machinery, (c) the policy of conservation of resources?

5.  Do you justify the trade unions in their opposition to unrestricted immigration?

6.  “The remedy for the moral indigestion which unchecked immigration is said to induce is in enlarging the organs of digestion. . . . Immigration consists of masses of our fellow men moving upon our country in pursuit of their share of human happiness. . . . There is no lack of resources, material or spiritual, for carrying out our half of the assimilation programme. . . . We are letting a few do the work we should all be helping in.” (Mary Antin in “They who Knock at our Gates.”)

Outline an argument supporting or opposing this view.

7.  “In two particulars of vital consequence this bill embodies a radical departure from the traditional and long-established policy of this country, a policy in which our people have conceived the very character of their Government to be expressed, the very mission and spirit of the nation in respect of its relations to the peoples of the world outside their borders. It seeks to all but close entirely the gates of asylum which have always been open to those who could find nowhere else the right and opportunity of constitutional agitation for what they conceived to be the natural and inalienable rights of men, and it excludes those to whom the opportunities of elementary education have been denied without regard to their character, their purposes or their natural capacity. . . . The new tests here embodied are not tests of quality or of character or of personal fitness, but tests of opportunity.”

Review this main argument of President Wilson’s in veto of the Burnet bill, from the point of view of (a) the significance of the “gates of asylum,” (b) the distinction between tests of “quality” (etc.), and tests of “opportunity,” and the significance of this distinction.

8.  Consider each of the following statements asking yourself (1) Is it true? and (2) If only partly true wherein is it true and wherein false? Be careful to show what evidence or reasons may be given for the position you take.

(a)The Italians in Mississippi outstrip the negroes of the same region in economic accumulation.

(b)Immigrants have a higher rate of crime than the native population has.

9.  How does prejudice against the negro operate? Do you agree or disagree with Shaler in his recommendations as to the treatment of race prejudice?

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 51

Course Description
1914-15

5 1hf. The Housing Problem. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and research. Half-course (first half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 10. Asst. Professor Ford.(III)

Primarily a course in social research. Each student is required to make an intensive survey of housing conditions in a selected district, or to undertake an original investigation in some detail of the subject. The lectures and prescribed reading deal with methods and results of existing housing surveys, with the causes and remedies of lot and room congestion, with problems of construction, sanitation, and maintenance of tenements, lodging houses, and cottages. The agencies of improved construction of dwellings — philanthropic, coöperative and governmental — are treated, together with methods of residential and industrial decentralization. The function of health and building codes, taxation, land reform, city planning, in the regulation and improvement of housing conditions, are examined in detail.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 5
1914-15

  1. 1hf. Asst. Professor James Ford. — The Housing Problem.

Total 16: 2 Graduates; 8 Seniors; 2 Juniors; 4 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 5
1914-15

Answer all questions fully and with precision. Avoid irrelevant discussion. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.

1.  Discuss the following: —

(a)Loss of seal.

(b)The building zones of Boston.

(c)The balcony fire escape.

2.  Show how tuberculosis is transmitted from person to person. Outline all the provisions which should be incorporated in an urban housing ordinance to prevent the transmission of this disease in multiple dwellings.

3.  Describe in detail the plan, equipment, and management of

(a)The Riverside Dwellings, Brooklyn.

(b)The Rowton Houses of London.

4.  Give arguments for the decentralization of industry. Outline a satisfactory policy which might be applied in Massachusetts (a) to decentralize industry, (b) to provide for the housing of industrial employees.

5.  “Die Wohnungsfrage ist eine Kreditfrage” (Fuchs). In how far is this statement true? How should it be qualified? Outline the typical American method of meeting this problem.

6.  Outline the laws of France which are designed to promote the construction of workmen’s dwellings. Show how far the powers under these laws are utilized. Would you advocate the application of any of the provisions of the French law in Massachusetts? Give reasons fully.

7.  Describe and illustrate by diagram the “Philadelphia type of house.” Explain the prevalence of this type in Philadelphia.

8.  Outline the methods of districting applied in German cities. Compare with those of American cities.

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 6

Course Description
1914-15

6 2hf. Social Amelioration in Europe, with special reference to Social Insurance. — Lectures and prescribed reading. Half-course (second half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 11. Asst. Professor Foerster.(IV)

This course is mainly concerned with schemes of social amelioration that have so far been little developed in the United States. It makes a comparative study of the preventive and constructive measures, public and private, of several countries. After a brief consideration of the function of thrift institutions, unemployment and such devices for dealing with it as relief works, labor exchanges, benefit systems, insurance and labor colonies are discussed. Experience in provision for accident, sickness, invalidity, and old age, by systems of compensation, pensions and insurance, is examined. The course closes with a study of recent developments of legislation governing conditions of labor.

The treatment is throughout inductive. The incidence of the burden of comprehensive social measures, their ulterior effects upon the population and the significance of the principles they involve are frequently discussed.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 6
1914-15

  1. 2hf. Asst. Professor Foerster. — Social Amelioration in Europe, with special reference to Social Insurance.

Total 22: 5 Graduates; 6 Seniors; 8 Juniors; 3 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 6
1914-15

Answer questions in the order given. So allot your time that you may answer all. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.

1.  Speaking in the House of Commons on May 19, 1909 on proposed legislation providing for a system of national labor exchanges, Mr. Winston Churchill said: “There is one thing in connection with labour exchanges. They will not to any large extent create new employment. In so far as facilities for getting labour on particular occasions sometimes lead to extra men being taken on, they will increase employment. That, however, is only a very small result. They will not directly add to the volume of employment. I never contemplated that they should. It would be to invest the policy with an air of humbug if we were to pretend that labour exchanges are going to make more work.” Give your reasons for accepting or not accepting this argument.

2.  Describe unemployment insurance in (a) Ghent; (b) Norway. Would an adaptation of the Norwegian system be feasible and desirable in Massachusetts?

3.  In the course of a speech on legislative provision for old age, on May 7, 1908 (before the enactment of the English law) the Prime Minister, Mr Asquith, said in the House of Commons: “I need not remind the Committee that this question in one shape or another has been before the country now for the best part of thirty years. . . . In the meantime other countries have been making experiments. The German system, which is one of compulsory State-aided assurance, has been in existence since 1889. . . . More instruction, I think, for our purposes is to be derived from the legislation initiated in Denmark in 1891, in New Zealand in 1898, and subsequently in New South Wales and Victoria.” Indicate what are the important problems involved in legislating for old age and show as far as you can how these problems have been dealt with in the laws of the countries under review.

4.  Outline the main provisions of such a law for the indemnification of industrial accidents as in your opinion one of our eastern states might best adopt; show how each of these provisions compares with the corresponding provisions of the important European laws, and indicate reasons for your choice of the terms of the law you propose.

5.  In the plan for sickness insurance submitted to the Commission on Industrial Relations, and published by the United States Public Health Service, the rates of contribution are fixed as follows: —

Employees . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 50 per cent.

Employers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40 per cent.

Community . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 to 10 per cent.

State . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 to 10 per cent.

The contribution by employers is explained as “probably necessary to give them the same interest in the fund which employees have; without this responsibility and incentive to save, only the exceptionally wise or humane employer would take any interest in the prevention of sickness.” What portion does the employer pay in the European systems of sickness insurance which you have studied? How adequate do you regard the explanation given of the need for an employer’s contribution?

6.  Sir Rufus Isaacs, Attorney-General, speaking of German experience in social insurance in the House of Commons on May 24, 1911, said: “Germany has gradually built up a system which by common consent is of most beneficent character and is working to the advantage not only of the employer, but also of the employed . . . without impairing the independence of the workers.” Discuss the issue of “independence” from such points of view as you have studied, particularly from the point of view of Belloc.

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 7

Course Description
1914-15

7 2hf. Rural Social Development. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and a thesis. Half-course (second half-year). Mon., Wed., Fri., at 10. Asst. Professor Ford.(III)

This course deals with the methods of rural social research, and with measures for the improvement of rural social conditions. It begins with an examination of the distribution of rural population in the United States, the bearing of physical and economic environments and of racial distribution upon local social problems. The causes of rural depopulation, degeneracy, poverty, disease are examined, with special reference to ascertaining the means of prevention. Measures are considered for the development of country life from without through “back-to-the-land” movements, urban and State assistance; and for rural reconstruction from within through adaptation of existing local institutions and through coöperative movements.

The third hour of each week is devoted to the discussion of prescribed reading or to direction of research.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 7
1914-15

  1. 2hf. Asst. Professor James Ford. — Rural Social Development.

Total 16: 2 Graduates; 6 Seniors; 1 Junior; 2 Sophomores; 5 Others.

Final Examination
Social Ethics 7
1914-15

Answer all questions fully and with precision. Support your opinions by reasons, drawing upon the reading of the course wherever it is pertinent.

1.  What data should be secured in a thorough rural social survey concerning local poverty and the relief of poverty? Answer in detail.

2.  Compare immigrant races in rural communities with reference to the rapidity of assimilation. Name and explain the factors which operate to promote or retard assimilation.

3.  Discuss (a) the Kallikak family; (b) the Boerenbond of Belgium.

4.  State in detail the moral value of play. Outline a policy for the provision of developmental play for farm boys of 12–16 years of age.

5.  Compare urban and rural mortality rates within the United States registration area from any three transmissible diseases. Account for the differences between the urban and rural rates from each of these diseases.

6.  (a) Describe the forms of organization and the business methods of coöperative grain elevator associations. (b) Show fully in what ways the coöperative movement may promote the moral development of the individual member.

7.(a)Compare urban and rural population in the United States with respect to: —

age distribution,
school attendance,
illiteracy.

(b)Show the causes and consequences of rural conditions noted in (a).

8.  “One of the most distinctive features of capitalism is the division of the population connected with industry into two great social classes — those who own but do not use and those who use but do not own, the instruments by which wealth is produced and distributed.” (Simons: “The American Farmer”) (a) In which of these classes does Simons place the American farmer? (b) For what reasons? (c) Show the weaknesses of his argument.

_________________________

SOCIAL ETHICS 8

Course Description
1914-15

8 1hf. Child-Helping Agencies: Their Problems and Methods. — Lectures, prescribed reading, and field work under skilled direction. Half-course (first half-year). Tu., Th., at 2.30, and a conference hour by special appointment. Dr. Carstens.(XV)

This course deals with the important phases of child-helping work in well equipped communities. It treats of the historical development of this form of social service, the advantages of institutions and individual family homes for dependent and neglected children, juvenile courts and probation, juvenile delinquency, the various forms of child protection, the training of defectives in sight, hearing, and speech, and the training and custody of the mentally defective. In addition special studies are made of illegitimacy, infant mortality, child labor and other special phases of child-helping work.

Each student is required to become acquainted with at least one of the important groups of organizations in child-helping service that are found in Boston and vicinity.

Course Enrollment
Social Ethics 8
1914-15

  1. 1hf. Dr. Carstens. — Child-Helping Agencies.

Total 7: 2 Graduates; 1 Senior; 1 Junior; 3 Others.

Sources:

Division of History, Government, and Economics 1914-15. Published in Official Register of Harvard University, vol. XI, No. 1, Part 14 (May 19, 1914), pp. 73-76.

Harvard University. Report of the President of Harvard College, 1914-15. Pages 65-66.

Papers set for final examinations in history, history of science, government, economics, philosophy, social ethics, education, fine arts, music in Harvard College (June, 1915).

Image Source:  F. Séguin “Conseil des Prud’hommes. Tribunal de Conciliation” (1895) in Musée Carnavalet, Histoire de Paris (D.13479).